#1 Posted by Magnus/Murdock (428 posts) - - Show Bio
#2 Posted by High Revolutionary (3171 posts) - - Show Bio

Jesus.

(Or anybody possessing  the Spear of Destiny).

#3 Posted by BatDance (2248 posts) - - Show Bio

Manhattan is just a Captian Atom able to rebuild himself. People who will beat him Prof X if he's allowed take the first shot (he will turn Jon into a blubbering vegetable), Spectre, PC Darkseid, Surfer, Thanos, Odin, Phoenix, Death, Dormammu, Mr. Mxyzptlk, Godwave, Brainiac 13, Thor, Watcher and Nullifier...Manhattan never owned anyone of note, he beat rookies or street levelers that's why he looks strong. Most skyfather, reality warpers will beat him.

#4 Posted by the creator (8577 posts) - - Show Bio
BatDance said:
"Manhattan is just a Captian Atom able to rebuild himself. People who will beat him Prof X if he's allowed take the first shot (he will turn Jon into a blubbering vegetable), Spectre, PC Darkseid, Surfer, Thanos, Odin, Phoenix, Death, Dormammu, Mr. Mxyzptlk, Godwave, Brainiac 13, Thor, Watcher and Nullifier...Manhattan never owned anyone of note, he beat rookies or street levelers that's why he looks strong. Most skyfather, reality warpers will beat him."
What evidence do you have to say that Telepathy will work on Dr Manhattan ?
To my knowledge, Manhattan never was hit with any telepathic attack, so there is no evidence to say either way if this would work on him.
It is clear that Manhattan's mind is significantly different from a normal humans due to it's processing of both sensory and temporal information.
#5 Posted by BatDance (2248 posts) - - Show Bio

Ozy could read his mind, manipulate him into cowering on Mars and finally trick him into giving up and he didn't have even a tiny bit of Xavier's powers. Different thought processes are no biggie for Xavier, this man has taken out alien minds before.

#6 Posted by the creator (8577 posts) - - Show Bio
BatDance said:
"Ozy could read his mind, manipulate him into cowering on Mars and finally trick him into giving up and he didn't have even a tiny bit of Xavier's powers. Different thought processes are no biggie for Xavier, this man has taken out alien minds before."
That was physcological manipulation and as for reading his mind, that was based on facial expressions (as Manhattan began life as a human, so he still formed facial expressions).

As I said, what evidince do you have to say Manhattan is susceptible to mental attacks as It looks like its an assumption.
#7 Posted by BatDance (2248 posts) - - Show Bio

What evidence do you have to say he isn't,  show me where in the comicbook. I know there is no definite answer therefore you theory is also speculation. You have also made an assumption that he isn't susceptible. If Professor is allowed take the first shot, I say he will win since I speculate he is susceptible and all he needs is just one little hypnotic suggestion

#8 Posted by Erik (33329 posts) - - Show Bio

Has Xavier ever been able to influence a cosmic level being? I do not recall him having that ability. 

#9 Posted by the creator (8577 posts) - - Show Bio
BatDance said:
"What evidence do you have to say he isn't,  show me where in the comicbook. I know there is no definite answer therefore you theory is also speculation. You have also made an assumption that he isn't susceptible. If Professor is allowed take the first shot, I say he will win since I speculate he is susceptible and all he needs is just one little hypnotic suggestion"
I am not saying he cannot be affected by Telepathy but lets look at your first post again,

BatDance said:
People who will beat him Prof X if he's allowed take the first shot (he will turn Jon into a blubbering vegetable),
So you are clearly saying that Prof X can mindwipe him.
Again, what do you base this unfounded assumption on ?
You have no facts, no evidence to support this assumption and therfore it's completely irrevelant.

#10 Edited by MrDirector786 (43636 posts) - - Show Bio

I'm going to be honest. Manhattan is over-rated. He may be powerful, but he is no way unbeatable. People that I think/know can beat him include:
1. Anti-Monitor
2. Galactus
3. Thor
4. Dr. Doom (with prep)
5. Dr. Strange
6. Spectre
7. Imperiex
8. Living Tribunal
9. Beyonder
10. Dr. Fate
11. Silver Surfer
12. Thanos
13. Eternity
14. Mxyzptlk
15. Monarch
16. Doomsday (maybe)
17. Parasite (who might be able to absorb his energy form)
18. Spawn
19. Man of Miracles
20. Pheonix
There are definitely more than this, but I'm too lazy to think of any more.

#11 Posted by Yaujtapool (7577 posts) - - Show Bio

Doom with some prep .

#12 Posted by BatDance (2248 posts) - - Show Bio

Yes he can Xavier can hurt cosmic level, but if they have weird defenses he will have trouble.  I think X will have trouble with Magneto, SilverSurfer and Shadow King since Magneto is a genius and can design things to block his mind, Galactus created SS and made SS weird barriers and Shadow King is pure evil psychic energy so he doesn't exactly have a brain like normal people. Doctor Fate and Zatanna are some more characters who could barrier themselves against Xavier. X isn't invincble with his mind, an extremly smart metahuman with prep would beat him. Even Batman preped could beat Xavier but if you give Xavier the first shot its too much. Manhattan is really powerful like Captian Atom but there is nothing which says to me Dr. Manhattan cannot be affected by Telepathy. I rank Manhattan much lower than Skyfathers he is just Captain Atom with a power up. Then again me saying Prof X turns Dr M into a blubbering vegetable perhaps is going overboard, I take that back.

#13 Posted by AtPhantom (14521 posts) - - Show Bio
  1. Spectre
  2. Galactus
  3. Any Celestial
  4. Any Guardian
  5. Any Monitor
  6. Darkseid
  7. Phoenix
  8. Monarch
  9. Superman Prime one million
  10. Highfather
  11. Odin
  12. Anti-Monitor
  13. Original Ion
  14. Original Parallax
  15. Doctor Fate
  16. classic Doctor Strange
  17. H/P Doomsday
  18. Adam Warlock
  19. Thanos
  20. Beyonder
  21. Molecule man
  22. Infinity Man
  23. Yuga Khan
  24. Captain Atom
  25. Mad Jim Jaspers
#14 Posted by SwaggaB0y (5262 posts) - - Show Bio

SPIDERMAN

#15 Posted by betacarotene (48 posts) - - Show Bio

ill go w/ galactus..or thanos

#16 Posted by King Saturn (224720 posts) - - Show Bio
AtPhantom said:
"
  1. Spectre
  2. Galactus
  3. Any Celestial
  4. Any Guardian
  5. Any Monitor
  6. Darkseid
  7. Phoenix
  8. Monarch
  9. Superman Prime one million
  10. Highfather
  11. Odin
  12. Anti-Monitor
  13. Original Ion
  14. Original Parallax
  15. Doctor Fate
  16. classic Doctor Strange
  17. H/P Doomsday
  18. Adam Warlock
  19. Thanos
  20. Beyonder
  21. Molecule man
  22. Infinity Man
  23. Yuga Khan
  24. Captain Atom
  25. Mad Jim Jaspers
"
This list will work...

lol
Online
#17 Posted by the creator (8577 posts) - - Show Bio
BatDance said:
"Yes he can Xavier can hurt cosmic level, but if they have weird defenses he will have trouble.  I think X will have trouble with Magneto, SilverSurfer and Shadow King since Magneto is a genius and can design things to block his mind, Galactus created SS and made SS weird barriers and Shadow King is pure evil psychic energy so he doesn't exactly have a brain like normal people. Doctor Fate and Zatanna are some more characters who could barrier themselves against Xavier. X isn't invincble with his mind, an extremly smart metahuman with prep would beat him. Even Batman preped could beat Xavier but if you give Xavier the first shot its too much. Manhattan is really powerful like Captian Atom but there is nothing which says to me Dr. Manhattan cannot be affected by Telepathy. I rank Manhattan much lower than Skyfathers he is just Captain Atom with a power up. Then again me saying Prof X turns Dr M into a blubbering vegetable perhaps is going overboard, I take that back."
You still did not answer the question.
Plus 10 points for avoiding it again.
#18 Posted by AtPhantom (14521 posts) - - Show Bio
King Saturn said:
"AtPhantom said:
"
  1. Spectre
  2. Galactus
  3. Any Celestial
  4. Any Guardian
  5. Any Monitor
  6. Darkseid
  7. Phoenix
  8. Monarch
  9. Superman Prime one million
  10. Highfather
  11. Odin
  12. Anti-Monitor
  13. Original Ion
  14. Original Parallax
  15. Doctor Fate
  16. classic Doctor Strange
  17. H/P Doomsday
  18. Adam Warlock
  19. Thanos
  20. Beyonder
  21. Molecule man
  22. Infinity Man
  23. Yuga Khan
  24. Captain Atom
  25. Mad Jim Jaspers
"
This list will work...

lol
"
I actually wanted to do a hundred of them like Vance did on who can beat the hulk, but after 25, I got bored. lol
#19 Posted by BatDance (2248 posts) - - Show Bio
AtPhantom said:
"King Saturn said:
"AtPhantom said:
"
  1. Spectre
  2. Galactus
  3. Any Celestial
  4. Any Guardian
  5. Any Monitor
  6. Darkseid
  7. Phoenix
  8. Monarch
  9. Superman Prime one million
  10. Highfather
  11. Odin
  12. Anti-Monitor
  13. Original Ion
  14. Original Parallax
  15. Doctor Fate
  16. classic Doctor Strange
  17. H/P Doomsday
  18. Adam Warlock
  19. Thanos
  20. Beyonder
  21. Molecule man
  22. Infinity Man
  23. Yuga Khan
  24. Captain Atom
  25. Mad Jim Jaspers
"
This list will work...

lol
"
I actually wanted to do a hundred of them like Vance did on who can beat the hulk, but after 25, I got bored. lol"
Anyone near Yuga Khan or Thanos levels destroys him
#20 Posted by the creator (8577 posts) - - Show Bio
the creator said:
"BatDance said:
"Yes he can Xavier can hurt cosmic level, but if they have weird defenses he will have trouble.  I think X will have trouble with Magneto, SilverSurfer and Shadow King since Magneto is a genius and can design things to block his mind, Galactus created SS and made SS weird barriers and Shadow King is pure evil psychic energy so he doesn't exactly have a brain like normal people. Doctor Fate and Zatanna are some more characters who could barrier themselves against Xavier. X isn't invincble with his mind, an extremly smart metahuman with prep would beat him. Even Batman preped could beat Xavier but if you give Xavier the first shot its too much. Manhattan is really powerful like Captian Atom but there is nothing which says to me Dr. Manhattan cannot be affected by Telepathy. I rank Manhattan much lower than Skyfathers he is just Captain Atom with a power up. Then again me saying Prof X turns Dr M into a blubbering vegetable perhaps is going overboard, I take that back."
You still did not answer the question.

#21 Posted by Legend.Killah (143 posts) - - Show Bio

Doomsday or Imperiex

#22 Posted by Power NeXus (9899 posts) - - Show Bio

Hulk with a Red Lantern Ring

#23 Posted by BatDance (2248 posts) - - Show Bio

What am I supposed to answer? Ok, Xavier might not be able to murder him, that overkill business is wrong and was pure speculation on my part. But it was also pure speculation on your part Dr. Manhattan is immune to telepathy.

I say he is susceptible to some from it, he is still based on the human body and if Xavier gets a first shot all he needs is just one little hypnotic suggestion. whatever tricks Ozy pulled on Dr M to manipulate him Xavier will be able to amp it up X50.

 In defense of Manhattan maybe M could  vaporize X before he gets a hypnotic suggestion. So once again we are going back to speculation part and opening a whole other box of what-ifs

#24 Posted by the creator (8577 posts) - - Show Bio
BatDance said:
"What am I supposed to answer? Ok, Xavier might not be able to murder him, that overkill business is wrong and was pure speculation on my part. But it was also pure speculation on your part Dr. Manhattan is immune to telepathy. I say he is susceptible to some from it, he is still based on the human body and if Xavier gets a first shot all he needs is just one little hypnotic suggestion. whatever tricks Ozy pulled on Dr M to manipulate him Xavier will be able to amp it up X50. In defense of Manhattan maybe M could  vaporize X before he gets a hypnotic suggestion. So once again we are going back to speculation part and opening a whole other box of what-ifs"
I never said that he was definately immune.
What I said was

the creator said:
What evidence do you have to say that Telepathy will work on Dr Manhattan ?
To my knowledge, Manhattan never was hit with any telepathic attack, so there is no evidence to say either way if this would work on him.
#25 Posted by melvinmaverick (32 posts) - - Show Bio

noone can beat manhattan end this now.

#26 Posted by Methos (40103 posts) - - Show Bio

you'ew just ignoring the massive list of characters that could beat him without barely recieving a scratch then

M

#27 Posted by claws (5060 posts) - - Show Bio

spectre
beyonder
spwan at full power
living tribunal

#28 Posted by The Crimson Nutcase (813 posts) - - Show Bio

Squirrel Girl lol!

#29 Posted by geraldthesloth (33313 posts) - - Show Bio

lmao wouldn't silver samurais blade work on him since it uses tachyons?

#30 Posted by lagoon_boy (10962 posts) - - Show Bio
zeus odin thor ghost rider
#31 Posted by King Hyperion (3714 posts) - - Show Bio

Who can beat Dr. Manhattan? Hmm...

The Masters of Doom:

Rulk with The Power Cosmic (or maybe even without it):

Just to name a couple.
#32 Posted by lagoon_boy (10962 posts) - - Show Bio



ghost rider

#33 Posted by mv (1876 posts) - - Show Bio
@High Revolutionary said:
"Jesus.(Or anybody possessing  the Spear of Destiny)."

LOL I was gonna say JC
#34 Posted by Vance Astro (91355 posts) - - Show Bio

1.Vance Astro
2.Lindsay Lohan
3.Miley Cyrus
4.Toucan Sam
5.Romeo Miller
6.Alphonso Ribiero
7.Rose Wilke
8.Skinny Jeans
9.The Bra Slasher
10.Forest Law

Moderator
#35 Posted by Kal'smahboi (3572 posts) - - Show Bio

As far as I'm concerned, anyone that relies on physical strength cannot defeat him. A very powerful telepath might  have have a chance (assuming that there is a brain to manipulate) but I think that energy/matter manipulation is the only way (Silver Surfer and the like.)

#36 Posted by Halopwnz (8 posts) - - Show Bio

Yet again, you are all wrong. Dr Manhattan can read minds, and he protects the present past and future. so he knows every thing that is coming. so he would read their minds and then blow them up. Pwned.
#37 Posted by castleking (24119 posts) - - Show Bio

#38 Posted by castleking (24119 posts) - - Show Bio

IM can turn into galactus and eat him and convert him into pure energy food

#39 Posted by Halopwnz (8 posts) - - Show Bio

Dr Manhattan would see this coming, and blow him up with his mind. Derrrr
#40 Posted by Halopwnz (8 posts) - - Show Bio

Dr. Manhattan Is undefeatable. There is no one who could even touch him.
#41 Posted by Superparody (2011 posts) - - Show Bio
@BatDance:
No i think he is saying that Dr.M's Anatomy isnt that of a human's all he is is a skin ,muscle and bones... I dont think he even uses his human Brain... I think his entire structure is his mind, I dont know how telepathy would work on Dr.M, it might work but it could also confuse the Telepather due to his vast amount of knowledge and bioledgy. 
#42 Posted by Halopwnz (8 posts) - - Show Bio

I agree. Dr Manhattan can do any thing he wants- therefor = win
#43 Posted by FLCL1 (9580 posts) - - Show Bio

doesnt dr.m count as a cosmic being
#44 Posted by zachyhavik (168 posts) - - Show Bio

Are we all forgetting Amazo I think that'd be interesting.

#45 Posted by Power NeXus (9899 posts) - - Show Bio

Killer Croc with a boulder.
#46 Posted by NightFang (10196 posts) - - Show Bio
@AtPhantom said:
"
  1. Spectre
  2. Galactus
  3. Any Celestial
  4. Any Guardian
  5. Any Monitor
  6. Darkseid
  7. Phoenix
  8. Monarch
  9. Superman Prime one million
  10. Highfather
  11. Odin
  12. Anti-Monitor
  13. Original Ion
  14. Original Parallax
  15. Doctor Fate
  16. classic Doctor Strange
  17. H/P Doomsday
  18. Adam Warlock
  19. Thanos
  20. Beyonder
  21. Molecule man
  22. Infinity Man
  23. Yuga Khan
  24. Captain Atom
  25. Mad Jim Jaspers
"
            You forgot abour Doctor Who, Lucifer  Morningstar and maybe Doomsday.
#47 Posted by Halopwnz (8 posts) - - Show Bio

Green Lantern. Although he can not get rid of Dr Manhattan, he can permanetly dis assemble him. Assuming the universe is infinite, if he were to scratter his particles across the universe, it would take Dr Manhattan an infinite ammount of time to re assemble himself.
#48 Edited by RaDicalCannibal (1053 posts) - - Show Bio

1. Silver Surfer
2. Franklin Richards - you don't exist manhattan, buh bye now enjoy life being non existent lol
3. Mr. M - same abilities as Franklin, but supposedly Mr. M has evolved to become immortal, doesn't die, just evolves
4. Mad Jim Jaspers
5. Phoenix
 6. Beyonder
7. Spawn 
8. Thor
9. Galactus


All you need is 2-4 really, no need for divine, cosmic beings to dispose of Dr. M, Dr. Manhattan is weak compared to even some of the best mutants LOL

#49 Posted by CAPiTA (1520 posts) - - Show Bio
@Halopwnz said:
" Dr Manhattan would see this coming, and blow him up with his mind. Derrrr "
you're wrong on so many levels, it's sad.
 
he can see the past, present, and future as one. yes. can he change the outcome of the future? no. he says so himself that he can see the strings of time, yet he's still just a puppet bound to them.
 
so when one of these guys come up to him, he'll say, "yeah, i know... you're gonna kick my ass" and proceed to get his ass handed to him.
#50 Posted by Perfect Cell (3470 posts) - - Show Bio

Dr. Manhattan is -probably- the equivalent to The Watcher. Only not Physical.