All of the watch men team agaisnt the well known people from the justice league (batman,wonderwomen,flash etc) not superman as i want it to be a fair fight
Watchmen vs justice league
rorschach may be clever, no where near as smart/fast/strong as the rest of the JLA though, that goes for all of the members, the only ones who might pose a problem are ozymandias (Flash takes him out easily) and doctor manhattan, who I see green lantern and Martian Manhunter beating.
"Dr Manhattan has enough power to create a bas on mars with his mind i dont see him getting beat easily and i can see rorschach beating flash but not batman however overall i think it would be a really close one"You see Rorschach, beating Flash??? It is as AtPhantom said: JLA vs Dr. Manhattan.
"btw rorscharch wouldnt die that easy he is to clever for that"He's not too clever for Batman to knock his @$$ out.
lordalif said:
"Dr Manhattan has enough power to create a bas on mars with his mind i dont see him getting beat easily and i can see rorschach beating flash but not batman however overall i think it would be a really close one"Explain how Rorschach beats someone that moves and reacts hundreds of times faster than him. And, Dr. Manhattan didn't make a base on Mars with his mind. He did it through molecular manipulation. Other than that, he doesn't have a defense against telepathy and has never showed it in the graphic novel. Green Lantern (preferrably Hal Jordan) and Martian Manhunter can deal with him.
"Nobody said:He needs no physical body to hurt and can basically do whatever he wants. The only way I really see anybody doing anything to him is with magic, but even then we don't know how magic would effect him."Dr. Manhattan wins."Make a case.
"
"He needs no physical body to hurt and can basically do whatever he wants."I bet telepathy would work.
"Nobody said:Would it?"He needs no physical body to hurt and can basically do whatever he wants."I bet telepathy would work.
"
Phantom Stranger could just summon The Spectre to erase Manhattan from existence...
"And why cant this fight be taken to a Celestial level with the Phantom Stranger ?Phantom Stranger isn't in the battle.
Phantom Stranger could just summon The Spectre to erase Manhattan from existence...
"
"Nobody said:I think it depends on who's telepathy. Aquaman's only works on humans because they share a part of the brain with fish. As stated, Dr. M doesn't even have a brain if he chooses not to. So his telepathy couldn't work on him. I'm not sure how MM's work."Would it?"Dr. Manhattan has a mind. Thus, it can work.
"
"King Saturn said:Yeah I see he made rosters inside the thread after the OP..."And why cant this fight be taken to a Celestial level with the Phantom Stranger ?Phantom Stranger isn't in the battle.
Phantom Stranger could just summon The Spectre to erase Manhattan from existence...
"
"
well now the JL will have a hard road ahead of them then...
"So its basically Martian Manhunter versus Doc Manhattan... cause I dont think even Diana can hurt Manhattan... but maybe the GL and MM can do somethingI'm not sure what a GL could do. Manhattan still has no body to hurt.
"
"King Saturn said:He could do more than WW, Green Arrow, Batman..."So its basically Martian Manhunter versus Doc Manhattan... cause I dont think even Diana can hurt Manhattan... but maybe the GL and MM can do somethingI'm not sure what a GL could do. Manhattan still has no body to hurt.
"
"
I think the GL probably could contain Manhattan for a while via Energy Constructs...
"Nobody said:But Dr. Manhattan's body is not really necessary for him. He could probably just float out of the constructs like he floats through anything else."King Saturn said:He could do more than WW, Green Arrow, Batman..."So its basically Martian Manhunter versus Doc Manhattan... cause I dont think even Diana can hurt Manhattan... but maybe the GL and MM can do somethingI'm not sure what a GL could do. Manhattan still has no body to hurt.
"
"
I think the GL probably could contain Manhattan for a while via Energy Constructs...
"
"But I don't see how, if there is nothing to contain.Well Manhattan's body is still some form of Energy...
"
GLs have contained Energy Sources before in Solid Constructs...
"Nobody said:His body is more like a puppet though. He could just fabricate another one if the first was contained."But I don't see how, if there is nothing to contain.Well Manhattan's body is still some form of Energy...
"
GLs have contained Energy Sources before in Solid Constructs...
"
Dr. Manhattan could just form another body for himself if he wanted. At one point in the comic he had like 3 bodies all doing different tasks and wasn't struggling to remain focused.
"Whats to stop Manhattan from destroying the construct? Or the ring?MM's Telepathy could be a weapon here as the GL Contains him... I cant see Manhattan destroying the Ring but the Construct would eventually give out
"
"Nobody said:As stated before, we aren't even sure if telepathy could work on Dr. M"Whats to stop Manhattan from destroying the construct? Or the ring?MM's Telepathy could be a weapon here as the GL Contains him... I cant see Manhattan destroying the Ring but the Construct would eventually give out
"
"
"King Saturn said:Why Not ? Didnt MM's Telepathy work on The Spectre at one point ?"Nobody said:As stated before, we aren't even sure if telepathy could work on Dr. M"Whats to stop Manhattan from destroying the construct? Or the ring?MM's Telepathy could be a weapon here as the GL Contains him... I cant see Manhattan destroying the Ring but the Construct would eventually give out
"
"
"
"Nobody said:I don't know."King Saturn said:Why Not ? Didnt MM's Telepathy work on The Spectre at one point ?"Nobody said:As stated before, we aren't even sure if telepathy could work on Dr. M"Whats to stop Manhattan from destroying the construct? Or the ring?MM's Telepathy could be a weapon here as the GL Contains him... I cant see Manhattan destroying the Ring but the Construct would eventually give out
"
"
"
"
"Nobody said:If his body is energy why can the GL ring absorb him or at least his body? the GL rings have absorbed or contained Quantum energy before."But I don't see how, if there is nothing to contain.Well Manhattan's body is still some form of Energy...
"
GLs have contained Energy Sources before in Solid Constructs...
"
I don't think that the members of JL in this fight would be able to do much to Dr. Manhattan here...
Manhattan is a child. He would not be anywhere near prepared for a fight with the JLA. MM would ruin him. Look how easily he was manipulated by Ozymandias and the press without telepathy. He would probably freak and either teleport himself or his opponents away. He's a pretty non-confrontational guy when it comes down to it. Plus, he has no idea how super powers work, and there is quite a variety opposing him.
"King Saturn said:Thats another Good Point"Nobody said:If his body is energy why can the GL ring absorb him or at least his body? the GL rings have absorbed or contained Quantum energy before."But I don't see how, if there is nothing to contain.Well Manhattan's body is still some form of Energy...
"
GLs have contained Energy Sources before in Solid Constructs...
"
"
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment