I vote for the original for obvious reasons but I would like to hear other opinions than my own ^^
I like Eddie more because well, its Eddie. But Gargan will win. He's much more powerful than Carnage, and way more powerful than Eddie. He will win. If they had the same amount of power, Eddie would win because of his experience.
"Gargan would win because not only does he have webbing,he can also form his scorpion tail out of the suit."
They have the same things. Only difference is, Gargan has more physical abilities and Eddie has experience.