TV/movie Superheroes vs Fantasy team

In this battle, a team of live action superheroes will take on a live action fantasy team, but who will win?

Superheroes:

• Batman (Nolan trilogy)
• Captain America (MCU)
• Black Widow (MCU)
• Arrow

Fantasy Team:

• Legolas
• Gimli
• Peter (Chronicles of Narnia)
• Nick Burkhardt (Grimm)

Fight takes place in a field with sparse tree cover. Time is twilight. Starting distance is 40 feet

Standard gear for all. Arrow only has standard arrows. Nick has 2 guns and any weapon from the trailer.

All are in character. Nick is fighting as though the superheroes are wesen. Victory by ko or death

Which team will win?

Peter isn't even that great. The only one he'd arguably beat is Baleman, and even that's doubtful.

Nolan Trilogy:

@rbt @rogueshadow@risingbean@pokeysteve@godzilla44

@fallschirmjager@jokerpoker@sophia89@jayc1324

Lord of the Rings:

@rogueshadow@iheartzombies92@lunacyde@pope052@The_Deathstroker

MCU:

@rogueshadow@risingbean@pokeysteve@pope052@lukehero

@fallschirmjager@stupid_people@sophia89

Arrow:

@funsiized@princearagorn1@rogueshadow@jokerpoker@godzilla44

@rbt @pokeysteve@fetts@fallschirmjager@princearagorn1@lukehero

@allstarsuperman@deathstroke19@homicidalmaniac@sophia89

Grimm:

@nerdchore@penderor@llehdevil@misterwhisper@frozen@uugieboogie@noone301994@buttersdaman000

What about the others?

@arcus: I don't know anything about Nick, and Gimli isn't that great either. Unless Nick is really good, the superheroes take this quite easily.

Legolas is MVP of team 2; he is going for kill shots.

Cap is MVP of team 1; he'll kill adult soldiers, but he'll take it easy on Peter.

Black Widow knocks Peter out with the stingers though.

Team 1 should win.

Heroes.

Legolas solos... For real the guy's ridiculous, he is certainly beyond bullet timing.

By movie feats only Peter is the weak link of the fantasy team, by book feats he is no slouch, old Peter is a beast.

Nolanverse Batman is the weak link from the heroes team and Peter would take him down rather easy.

@stormdriven: Nick's basically low level superhuman, I can try to post some feats later

I wasn't gonna include Peter, but I couldn't think of any other movies or shows to go with. Any suggestions?

@lucano: Legolas will be a big problem, but Cap alone could give him a pretty even fight, I don't see him soloing

@arcus: DCAU Shining Knight? While the DCAU itself isn't fantasy, the character fits well enough. Unless you're only looking for live action.

I'm thinking Team 1 wins.

Hmm, I do like Shining Knight. Technically he's a super hero too, but we can ignore that

Dontbknow team 2

@allstarsuperman: that could make things difficult

DCAU Shining Knight would be too much I'm sure, he was deflecting bullets with his sword, punching/destroying steel doors, he wounded General Eling and tanked quite a beating from him.

Fantasy Team.

@noone301994: any reasons?

I don't know. I think Cap could stand up to Shining Knight.

@scouterv: Ehh.....perhaps, but SK had hella durability going for him and his reflexes are bullet level, his sword being able to cut through things like butter and his strength enough to punch through steel doors. Or...well not punch through per say, but dent them heavily.

Although the shield, yeah I could see posing a problem.

I can not comment on Peter, her got into Narnia, honestly it looked stupid to me.

Gimli is not beating anyone on team 1.

Legolas can beat Oliver, but bullets are not the same as arrows, he gets shot but he may take out Oliver first.

I would say team 1, more due to better gear than better skills though.

team 2 wins.

both nick and legolas can beat everyone on team one cept for cap. gimli can maybe take widow or baleman. peter is weak link.

honestly send gimli and peter at cap to disctract him while nick and legolas take out ollie widow and baleman. then its two on 1 and team beats cap.

Since when?

fantasy

Honestly, as much as I love Legolas, I think he's being pretty overrated. Honestly, I'd say Cap could solo. Heck, I'd argue that Arrow could potentially solo. Though admittedly I don't know too much about Nick so I could be jumping the gun.

You know, unless Nick proves to be a deciding factor, I'd even argue that Black Widow could solo. Because as far as I'm aware, none of them are bullet timers, so unfortunately for them she could just shoot them. Sad but true.

@arcus: i miss your avatar threads

@haoalchemist: I'll be making more

If Legolas doesn't have any help, there isn't much he's going to be able to do. Cap will most likely point out that both he and Nick are the biggest targets since they have range, having Oliver and Widow pick them off. Peter is a good swordsman, but he is seriously outclassed in CQC here, and Gimli is tough, but not fast whatsoever. I'll wait for some feats for Nick, but as it stands, the superheroes win this easily IMO

Live action team due to FAR superior weaponry.

Legolas and Nick are only big factorsof second team, while Gimli might kill Batman. I have to think about this.

Plus, Peter is...15 years old kid with almost no feats (if these are only movie feats).

Legolas and Gimli are going to have to try and carry their team...but that's a helluva uphill carry.

I think I'd back team 1.

Nick is being severly underestimated. Team fantasy wins

@sachmoo: ...they're both live action

True, but your not taking into account my stupidity.Superhero team wins, is what i meant.

@sachmoo: hahaha that's what I figured you meant

Team 2 wins

@godzilla44: Since he moved fast and swiftly enough to climb falling rocks and use them as steps.