#1 Posted by Gambit474 (1467 posts) - - Show Bio

Thrall vs Arthas,no prep

Round 1 Thrall vs Paladin Arthas

Round 2 Thrall vs Reign of Chaos Death Knight Arthas

#2 Posted by THC (367 posts) - - Show Bio

It sucks so hard that WoW made Arthas killable by random fucking men-at-arms in raids, so dumb

Are they allowed magic?

1. Definitely going with Pally Arthas. It's hammer vs. hammer, only Arthas' is a lot longer. If they're allowed magic, Arthas' Divine Shield and healing powers will help him a lot more than Thrall's Far Seer abilities.

2. Arthas again. He stomped Illidan 1v1 purely on fighting skill. People often overlook what a significant feat that is. Illidan is one of the greatest Night Elf fighters and was one of the most significant figures in Night Elf society for thousands of years. He was imprisoned for thousands of years, yes, but he still had his weapons with him and was apparently in great shape when he got out so presumably he was training I guess, lol.

#3 Posted by Thedarklordpandamonium (4825 posts) - - Show Bio

@thc said:

It sucks so hard that WoW made Arthas killable by random fucking men-at-arms in raids, so dumb

Are they allowed magic?

1. Definitely going with Pally Arthas. It's hammer vs. hammer, only Arthas' is a lot longer. If they're allowed magic, Arthas' Divine Shield and healing powers will help him a lot more than Thrall's Far Seer abilities.

2. Arthas again. He stomped Illidan 1v1 purely on fighting skill. People often overlook what a significant feat that is. Illidan is one of the greatest Night Elf fighters and was one of the most significant figures in Night Elf society for thousands of years. He was imprisoned for thousands of years, yes, but he still had his weapons with him and was apparently in great shape when he got out so presumably he was training I guess, lol.

Well said, and yes it does suck.

#4 Posted by Gambit474 (1467 posts) - - Show Bio

I used Reign of Chaos Arthas though..he wasn't as powerful as he was in the frozen throne after Ner'Zhul supercharged him

#5 Posted by GhostRavage (8825 posts) - - Show Bio

When did Arthas defeated Illidan in Reign of Chaos? More like Frozen Throne.

Anyway, Round 1 i give it to thrall, he's a far seer but he can control some nature aspects and summon creatures.

Round 2 ill give it to Arthas without much trouble. Frostmourne its f*cked up...

#6 Posted by THC (367 posts) - - Show Bio

@gambit474 said:

I used Reign of Chaos Arthas though..he wasn't as powerful as he was in the frozen throne after Ner'Zhul supercharged him

IIRC Arthas was actually getting weaker by the second in Frozen Throne because Ner'zhul was dying, wasn't he?

You might be right though; I just re-watched their duel and it ends pretty quickly, seemingly just 'cause Arthas was a lot more powerful than Illi

#7 Posted by Gambit474 (1467 posts) - - Show Bio

He was weakening yeah but he gave Arthas like this last amount of power so he could take back the throne in that last mission