Posted by emcardle660 (6 posts) 1 year, 2 months ago

Poll: Thor .vs. The Hulk (49 votes)

Thor 63%
The Hulk 41%

Me and my friend have debated this for a while... I wont give my answer yet but I would like to know what everyone else thinks :) The fights always seem to be pretty even, and even in the 'Avengers Assemble' and comics, this fight could've went any way.

Im new here so sorry if I've not posted correctly or anything :)

#1 Posted by tikhunt (676 posts) - - Show Bio

Welcome to the vine

#2 Posted by Extremis (3350 posts) - - Show Bio

Welcome!

And you couldn't have started with a more controversial topic with who wins: The Mighty Thor or the Jade Giant. Lots of opinions on this, but I think writers like to always end it in a draw, or something happens and they have to stop. It's one of those great perpetual rivalries in comics. Somedays I say Hulk, sometimes Thor. It's a pretty even matchup IMO. It really depends what their limitations are or the environment.

#3 Posted by emcardle660 (6 posts) - - Show Bio

@tikhunt thanks for the welcome :p

and @extremis yea i think you're right, it does really depend on limitations and/or environment :)

Ill be happy to see everyone else's opinion :)

#4 Posted by Catsnlynne (1031 posts) - - Show Bio

I'm more of a Thor fan, but truthfully I really don't know who would win.

#5 Posted by comicace3 (5233 posts) - - Show Bio

Welcome to comicvine... and I'd go with thor.

#6 Posted by GhostRavage (8955 posts) - - Show Bio

Everybody will go for Mjolnir... Versatility and blah blah blah... HULK SMASH! They call him the World Breaker! In character personally i think Hulk wins,

#7 Posted by Shavo (2061 posts) - - Show Bio

thor stomps the only reason thor hasn't smoked hulk yet is because he doesn't want to kill bruce banner

#8 Posted by dondave (37294 posts) - - Show Bio

I'd go Hulk due to the fact that Thor barely use the more exotic abilities of his hammer when fighting

#9 Posted by Jgames (1686 posts) - - Show Bio

Thor, he usually hold back when fighting Thor, and usually stalemate, if he go full out, and beat him quick, he most likely win

#10 Posted by The_Lunact_And_Manic (3286 posts) - - Show Bio

@kingjames447 said:

thor stomps the only reason thor hasn't smoked hulk yet is because he doesn't want to kill bruce banner

#11 Posted by jashro44 (21532 posts) - - Show Bio

Welcome to the site! Personally I would give it to Thor.

#12 Posted by OmgOmgWtfWtf (7031 posts) - - Show Bio

Well if this counts for anything, then Hulk would be stronger. But I don't how valid of a claim this is.

#13 Posted by venomoushatred1001 (12334 posts) - - Show Bio
#14 Edited by OmgOmgWtfWtf (7031 posts) - - Show Bio

@venomoushatred1001 said:

@omgomgwtfwtf: He was being sarcastic.

Given that it was from Fear Itself, it was probably a joke, since the whole event was a running gag :P

#15 Posted by ThatGuyWithHeadPhones (11029 posts) - - Show Bio

They're Even
Nuff Said

#16 Posted by comic_book_fan (5616 posts) - - Show Bio

hulk thor got beat down by emma phoenix in avx and hulk was called in later and gave her trouble when she had more of the pf.

#17 Posted by pooty (11112 posts) - - Show Bio

in character: Hulk probably wins

fighting with some common sense: Thor wins

#18 Edited by New_World_Order (13179 posts) - - Show Bio

Thor stomps. Hulk only srands a chance in comics because everyone holds back cause Bruce and cause Hul fans would compkain.

#19 Edited by venomoushatred1001 (12334 posts) - - Show Bio

After Thor: GoT, Its just plain silly to think Hulk can beat Thor.

#20 Posted by GhostRavage (8955 posts) - - Show Bio

After Thor: GoT, Its just plain silly to think Hulk can beat Thor.

Actually, people often forgets about WBH, which Thor stands no chance against. And that's no power amp no nothing, that's something HUlk has inside, so don't bring OdinForce nor anything similar.

#21 Edited by WarMachine4Life (37 posts) - - Show Bio

Thor can speed blitz him before he turns angry. Also Thor is charming, funny, he can make peace with Hulk. After Hulk turns back into Bruce Banner, and they are at a bar having a beer, THOR SMASHES BRUCE'S HEAD IN LIGHTNING SPEED!!!!

#22 Posted by venomoushatred1001 (12334 posts) - - Show Bio

@venomoushatred1001 said:

After Thor: GoT, Its just plain silly to think Hulk can beat Thor.

Actually, people often forgets about WBH, which Thor stands no chance against. And that's no power amp no nothing, that's something HUlk has inside, so don't bring OdinForce nor anything similar.

The feats that Thor did in that comic had nothing to do with Odin Force so I don't see your point.

#23 Posted by cfrehse (1004 posts) - - Show Bio

nul hulk was weaker than hulk anyways. Hulk broke free from his control and then destroyed the hammer

#24 Edited by GhostRavage (8955 posts) - - Show Bio

@venomoushatred1001: Was a just in case statement, because people always go with "If your using the strongest version of Hulk lets use the strongest version of Thor which implies OdinForce or Runes.... But those are external features that put Thor on that level. Anyway, true, you didn't mentioned anything so you're right.

#25 Posted by TheGodofThunder (598 posts) - - Show Bio

@cfrehse: So the hammers made everyone stronger except hulk? Why is he the exception?

#26 Posted by cfrehse (1004 posts) - - Show Bio

@thegodofthunder: nul has no feats that are on par with any of hulks other feats. He was just possessed. Nul was no where near world breaker or wwh level. He might have been stronger than savage hulk. I think hulk was the only one who broke free from possession by himself

#27 Edited by DanM (133 posts) - - Show Bio

Common sense will tell you that a Thor who's not holding back should wipe the floor with the Hulk, though they have been evenly matched with the Hulk besting him on a few occasions. I believe most non biased followers would go with Thor, though with these two good luck finding non biased debaters. Hulk has plenty of high level feats and is a complete powerhouse but relies heavily on brute strength where Thor is more versatile, in straight H2H I can see Thor getting bested in a good fight but in a well thought out battle, Thor should be the victor if both are fighting at their best and everything is taken into consideration.

#28 Posted by jackbancroft17 (12 posts) - - Show Bio

Thor has admitted to the hulk that the hulk is physically the strongest being he has ever encountered.

thor has met zeus, odin ect.

therefore the hulk is physically stronger than odin, and odin could beat thor.

but physical strength isnt what this fight is about, physical strength can only get so far yes but the hulk has beaten thor over and over again, shown to be able to smash mjolnir with the clench of his hand, withstand thors strongest lightning bolts so my vote goes with the hulk

#29 Posted by Bezza (3634 posts) - - Show Bio

Hulk has beaten Thor in the battles I have seen, particularly the ones in the animated universe. I really want Thor to be able to win this, because he is supposed to be only a bit weaker than Hulk but faster, have more range of powers and the mighty mjolnir, but Hulk never seems to lose any fights against other premier league Marvel characters, so I suspect he would win!

#30 Posted by dondave (37294 posts) - - Show Bio

Hulk

#31 Posted by xxxddd (3572 posts) - - Show Bio
#32 Edited by XLR87T3 (2761 posts) - - Show Bio

@ghostravage said:

@venomoushatred1001 said:

After Thor: GoT, Its just plain silly to think Hulk can beat Thor.

Actually, people often forgets about WBH, which Thor stands no chance against. And that's no power amp no nothing, that's something HUlk has inside, so don't bring OdinForce nor anything similar.

Classic Thor > any version of Hulk!

#33 Posted by GhostRavage (8955 posts) - - Show Bio

@xlr87t3 said:

@ghostravage said:

@venomoushatred1001 said:

After Thor: GoT, Its just plain silly to think Hulk can beat Thor.

Actually, people often forgets about WBH, which Thor stands no chance against. And that's no power amp no nothing, that's something HUlk has inside, so don't bring OdinForce nor anything similar.

Classic Thor > any version of Hulk!

Hmmm... I seriously doubt that... What feats does he has to put him on Par with WBH.

#34 Posted by venomoushatred1001 (12334 posts) - - Show Bio

@xlr87t3 said:

Classic and current Thor > any version of Hulk!

Fixed it for ya.

#35 Posted by gav (694 posts) - - Show Bio

Thor feats > Hulk feats

In showings against each other they are near equals which can be explained by one or more of the following (all debatable)

  1. Thor is holding back
  2. PIS/CIS
  3. Bad match up, Hulk is just a bad match up for Thor

Here is a great write up on the topic: http://hero-envy.blogspot.com/2011/09/hulk-vs-thor.html

#36 Posted by New_World_Order (13179 posts) - - Show Bio

Yes hulk is physically superior to Thor if he gets angry enough, but a base strength? No. Even if he did get stronger some how, Thor still hits harder. Take his fight with Gor recently. He was causing explosions on other planets that were not the one he was on just by striking Gorr. Thor is also so much more versatile, can fly, faster, and more durable too. Only reason why Hulk looks so durable is because he has a healing factor.

#37 Edited by Visemoon (396 posts) - - Show Bio

#38 Posted by NorrinBoltagonPrime21 (5877 posts) - - Show Bio

@gav said:

Thor feats > Hulk feats

In showings against each other they are near equals which can be explained by one or more of the following (all debatable)

  1. Thor is holding back
  2. PIS/CIS
  3. Bad match up, Hulk is just a bad match up for Thor

Here is a great write up on the topic: http://hero-envy.blogspot.com/2011/09/hulk-vs-thor.html

The only problem with that blog is that the writer is a big fanboy.

#39 Posted by gav (694 posts) - - Show Bio

@gav said:

Thor feats > Hulk feats

In showings against each other they are near equals which can be explained by one or more of the following (all debatable)

  1. Thor is holding back
  2. PIS/CIS
  3. Bad match up, Hulk is just a bad match up for Thor

Here is a great write up on the topic: http://hero-envy.blogspot.com/2011/09/hulk-vs-thor.html

The only problem with that blog is that the writer is a big fanboy.

Of course any writer of a blog about comics would be a fan boy! I can read bias stuff and still learn things and find enjoyment, and figured others could as well.

#40 Posted by MasterKungFu (1373 posts) - - Show Bio

Thor has admitted to the hulk that the hulk is physically the strongest being he has ever encountered.

thor has met zeus, odin ect.

therefore the hulk is physically stronger than odin, and odin could beat thor.

but physical strength isnt what this fight is about, physical strength can only get so far yes but the hulk has beaten thor over and over again, shown to be able to smash mjolnir with the clench of his hand, withstand thors strongest lightning bolts so my vote goes with the hulk

thor admitted that to hulk to make hulk feel better. thor has fought guys way stronger than hulk, way out of hulk's league. guys that hulk could never dream of going up against, that is a vast difference in power.

yes hulk is stronger than odin to start off with unless odin amps himself in which hulk has no way of exceeding odin

hulk could never beat thor unless the writers wanted him to. hulk has never smashed mjolnir in actual continuity. he never could he never will. u have no idea how strong thors strongest lightning bolts really are.

#41 Posted by MonsterStomp (17850 posts) - - Show Bio

I wanna say Hulk.

#42 Edited by Wolverine08 (42132 posts) - - Show Bio

Well if this counts for anything, then Hulk would be stronger. But I don't how valid of a claim this is.

Wrong image.