Thor vs the Collective
Sentry was pushed to his limits with him and still couldn't stop him
How would Thor do?
NO PREP
NO BFR
Thor
Collective
Mjolnir should deal with Collective. IMO The Collective is much more powerfull then Thor, but he isn't a Skyfather level and I doubt that anyone below Skyfather can overpower Mjolnir.
In normal battle (like against Thanos or Gladiator) it won't matter so much, but here it does matter because The Collective depends on limited sorce of energy and Mjolnir will be able to drain him and use his energy to make a shield.
Only chance for The Collective is finish this fast, but I doubt he can one-two shot someone as durable as Thor.
" Mjolnir should deal with Collective. IMO The Collective is much more powerfull then Thor, but he isn't a Skyfather level and I doubt that anyone below Skyfather can overpower Mjolnir. In normal battle (like against Thanos or Gladiator) it won't matter so much, but here it does matter because The Collective depends on limited sorce of energy and Mjolnir will be able to drain him and use his energy to make a shield. Only chance for The Collective is finish this fast, but I doubt he can one-two shot someone as durable as Thor. "I think you need to look at Thor as others see Strange or Superman
There are classic version of characters and current
Thor hasn't been shown to do any of that lately
Or even close to his classic version
@StrongestOneThereIs said:
" @czarny_samael said:" Mjolnir should deal with Collective. IMO The Collective is much more powerfull then Thor, but he isn't a Skyfather level and I doubt that anyone below Skyfather can overpower Mjolnir. In normal battle (like against Thanos or Gladiator) it won't matter so much, but here it does matter because The Collective depends on limited sorce of energy and Mjolnir will be able to drain him and use his energy to make a shield. Only chance for The Collective is finish this fast, but I doubt he can one-two shot someone as durable as Thor. "I think you need to look at Thor as others see Strange or Superman There are classic version of characters and current Thor hasn't been shown to do any of that lately Or even close to his classic version "
" @czarny_samael said:Current Thor is Classic Thor." Mjolnir should deal with Collective. IMO The Collective is much more powerfull then Thor, but he isn't a Skyfather level and I doubt that anyone below Skyfather can overpower Mjolnir. In normal battle (like against Thanos or Gladiator) it won't matter so much, but here it does matter because The Collective depends on limited sorce of energy and Mjolnir will be able to drain him and use his energy to make a shield. Only chance for The Collective is finish this fast, but I doubt he can one-two shot someone as durable as Thor. "I think you need to look at Thor as others see Strange or Superman There are classic version of characters and current Thor hasn't been shown to do any of that lately Or even close to his classic version "
Current Strange isn't Sorceror Supreme.
Current Supe isn't SA Supe.
If someone once show some ability, it will always count. And Thor pretty often is using this power.
" @StrongestOneThereIs said:" @czarny_samael said:Current Thor is Classic Thor. Current Strange isn't Sorceror Supreme. Current Supe isn't SA Supe. If someone once show some ability, it will always count. And Thor pretty often is using this power. "" Mjolnir should deal with Collective. IMO The Collective is much more powerfull then Thor, but he isn't a Skyfather level and I doubt that anyone below Skyfather can overpower Mjolnir. In normal battle (like against Thanos or Gladiator) it won't matter so much, but here it does matter because The Collective depends on limited sorce of energy and Mjolnir will be able to drain him and use his energy to make a shield. Only chance for The Collective is finish this fast, but I doubt he can one-two shot someone as durable as Thor. "I think you need to look at Thor as others see Strange or Superman There are classic version of characters and current Thor hasn't been shown to do any of that lately Or even close to his classic version "
thor has shown a few of his classic abilities. i posted a scan above
Thanks adam for that showing
I assumed Thor's hammer could absorb a degree of mystical energy
Anything showing other energies that are current
@czarny_samael:
Superman was a bad example
Even before he lost his title as Sorcerer Supreme, he still wasn't on is classic level
U have anything showing this shield creation?
And remember that the Collective wasn't just energy powers
Do you remember the list of mutants that were shown?
"@blackadam:
Thanks adam for that showing
I assumed Thor's hammer could absorb a degree of mystical energy
Anything showing other energies that are current
@czarny_samael: Superman was a bad example Even before he lost his title as Sorcerer Supreme, he still wasn't on is classic level U have anything showing this shield creation? And remember that the Collective wasn't just energy powers Do you remember the list of mutants that were shown? "
what does makes you think he can only absorb mystical energy? althought, mystical energies are differenmt form any pther source of energy, that does not he is limited to only absorbd mystical. this is a feat of energy absorbtion.
you said there is a differenre between clasic thor and current, i dont know about that, as of late other classic feats had been reference; in thor 613 they talk about how thor fight the midgard serpent, in astonishing thor he was talkin g about the effect a god bloast would have on ego the living planet, super speed shown in thor 617. so, i am starting to think there is really no difference at all.
" @StrongestOneThereIs said:Outside of his classic feats, I haven't seen Thor absorb energies outside of mystical (ex: Power Cosmic, Psionic or Hulk's gamma)"@blackadam:what does makes you think he can only absorb mystical energy? althought, mystical energies are differenmt form any pther source of energy, that does not he is limited to only absorbd mystical. this is a feat of energy absorbtion. you said there is a differenre between clasic thor and current, i dont know about that, as of late other classic feats had been reference; in thor 613 they talk about how thor fight the midgard serpent, in astonishing thor he was talkin g about the effect a god bloast would have on ego the living planet, super speed shown in thor 617. so, i am starting to think there is really no difference at all. "
Thanks adam for that showing
I assumed Thor's hammer could absorb a degree of mystical energy
Anything showing other energies that are current
@czarny_samael: Superman was a bad example Even before he lost his title as Sorcerer Supreme, he still wasn't on is classic level U have anything showing this shield creation? And remember that the Collective wasn't just energy powers Do you remember the list of mutants that were shown? "
I have seen him deflect these energies
The difference between them are in their feats
" @blackadam said:" @StrongestOneThereIs said:Outside of his classic feats, I haven't seen Thor absorb energies outside of mystical (ex: Power Cosmic, Psionic or Hulk's gamma) I have seen him deflect these energies The difference between them are in their feats ""@blackadam:what does makes you think he can only absorb mystical energy? althought, mystical energies are differenmt form any pther source of energy, that does not he is limited to only absorbd mystical. this is a feat of energy absorbtion. you said there is a differenre between clasic thor and current, i dont know about that, as of late other classic feats had been reference; in thor 613 they talk about how thor fight the midgard serpent, in astonishing thor he was talkin g about the effect a god bloast would have on ego the living planet, super speed shown in thor 617. so, i am starting to think there is really no difference at all. "
Thanks adam for that showing
I assumed Thor's hammer could absorb a degree of mystical energy
Anything showing other energies that are current
@czarny_samael: Superman was a bad example Even before he lost his title as Sorcerer Supreme, he still wasn't on is classic level U have anything showing this shield creation? And remember that the Collective wasn't just energy powers Do you remember the list of mutants that were shown? "
dude, i know about the feats. i just said he had done few of his classic feats.
so, you think he is limited now to only absorb mystical energies? sorry, but mjonir does not have that limitation. and that above was is a feat of energy absorbing. but, have it your way and we just have to wait so thior can perfrom a feat like that, which he can, but if you need prove you will have to wait.
He also one-shoted comet that was able to destroy Earth and rescue Rulk from death in Black Hole." @StrongestOneThereIs said:
"@blackadam:what does makes you think he can only absorb mystical energy? althought, mystical energies are differenmt form any pther source of energy, that does not he is limited to only absorbd mystical. this is a feat of energy absorbtion. you said there is a differenre between clasic thor and current, i dont know about that, as of late other classic feats had been reference; in thor 613 they talk about how thor fight the midgard serpent, in astonishing thor he was talkin g about the effect a god bloast would have on ego the living planet, super speed shown in thor 617. so, i am starting to think there is really no difference at all. "
Thanks adam for that showing
I assumed Thor's hammer could absorb a degree of mystical energy
Anything showing other energies that are current
@czarny_samael: Superman was a bad example Even before he lost his title as Sorcerer Supreme, he still wasn't on is classic level U have anything showing this shield creation? And remember that the Collective wasn't just energy powers Do you remember the list of mutants that were shown? "
@StrongestOneThereIs said:
" @czarny_samael: Superman was a bad example Even before he lost his title as Sorcerer Supreme, he still wasn't on is classic level U have anything showing this shield creation? And remember that the Collective wasn't just energy powers Do you remember the list of mutants that were shown? "
1.Unitil it is said that someone is depowered, all his feats count. Time between current comics and oldest doesn't matter.
2.It isn't a clear shield like Cap's. He channeling energy and blocking his enemy from releasing from it or using any other pwoer on Thor. It works like shield, but it isn't shield. I am sure that we already had that discussion, so I thought You would know what I've mean. Do You remember my scans with Thor draining Presence?
3.Pointer don't have their powers. He convert them into pure energy.
" Thor. Col. hasn't fought anyone that is as durable as Thor. Mjolnir can just drain him. "Drain what?
That is what we are discussing. You have some insight to this? We are debating energies other than mystical
And Sentry has shown a level of durability equal to Thor in my opinion
"@blackadam said:He also one-shoted comet that was able to destroy Earth and rescue Rulk from death in Black Hole." @StrongestOneThereIs said:
"@blackadam:what does makes you think he can only absorb mystical energy? althought, mystical energies are differenmt form any pther source of energy, that does not he is limited to only absorbd mystical. this is a feat of energy absorbtion. you said there is a differenre between clasic thor and current, i dont know about that, as of late other classic feats had been reference; in thor 613 they talk about how thor fight the midgard serpent, in astonishing thor he was talkin g about the effect a god bloast would have on ego the living planet, super speed shown in thor 617. so, i am starting to think there is really no difference at all. "
Thanks adam for that showing
I assumed Thor's hammer could absorb a degree of mystical energy
Anything showing other energies that are current
@czarny_samael: Superman was a bad example Even before he lost his title as Sorcerer Supreme, he still wasn't on is classic level U have anything showing this shield creation? And remember that the Collective wasn't just energy powers Do you remember the list of mutants that were shown? "
@StrongestOneThereIs said:1.Unitil it is said that someone is depowered, all his feats count. Time between current comics and oldest doesn't matter. 2.It isn't a clear shield like Cap's. He channeling energy and blocking his enemy from releasing from it or using any other pwoer on Thor. It works like shield, but it isn't shield. I am sure that we already had that discussion, so I thought You would know what I've mean. Do You remember my scans with Thor draining Presence? 3.Pointer don't have their powers. He convert them into pure energy. "" @czarny_samael: Superman was a bad example Even before he lost his title as Sorcerer Supreme, he still wasn't on is classic level U have anything showing this shield creation? And remember that the Collective wasn't just energy powers Do you remember the list of mutants that were shown? "
yes, and he was flying near that blackhole; thor woudl had have to be flying ftl to be able to scape and save the red hulk
@blackadam:
Was it ever said that Strange was depowered before losing the title?
I don't think so. And everyone here notes classic Strange is different in power level
Not sure what is being stated by the blackhole thing
@StrongestOneThereIs:
Just added every mutant NAMED on panel as being power sources for the Collective during New Avengers if it helps any.
Collective
"Thanks dude
@StrongestOneThereIs:
Just added every mutant NAMED on panel as being power sources for the Collective during New Avengers if it helps any.
Collective "
But i did that already
" @czarny_samael:1.Yes, but I'm not an expert of Strnage. It has something with his mind... He turn too much to black magic or something. I remember that he used black magic on Sentry before Civil War, but seriously I am not sure when it happened.
@blackadam: Was it ever said that Strange was depowered before losing the title? I don't think so. And everyone here notes classic Strange is different in power level Not sure what is being stated by the blackhole thing "
2.In his apperance in Hulk 26 or 27.
@StrongestOneThereIs said:
" @Achilles. said:" Thor. Col. hasn't fought anyone that is as durable as Thor. Mjolnir can just drain him. "Drain what? That is what we are discussing. You have some insight to this? We are debating energies other than mystical And Sentry has shown a level of durability equal to Thor in my opinion "
3.I've already showed You in tha past Thor draining not-mystcial beings. He did it to Presence (nuclear pwoer similar to Hulk's), he did it to Magneto (but only to take off his shields, becuase when Thor is starting to drain soemone he most times kills his enemy).
4.Sentry can't survive on sun. Thor can survive in sun. Void can reform them, this is the only reason why the were living so long. He can absorb at least planetary busting level attacks, but planet busting < surviving in sun (what was also proved by Sentry ;) ).
" @czarny_samael: current thor is no way the same as classic thor the feat what he did in chaos war is yet to be explain (read the top of your scan)an after doing such a feat he would have no change back to Donald Blake an this is 1 of his biggest feat so far hope marvel gives a good explanation for this it would be nice to see him become the powerhouse again "Current Thor isn't as powerfull as Classic. He also isn't near that powerfull. He also isn't more powerfull.
He is Classic Thor.
He don't have to prove anything. He never was depowered. He only got up-grade like Runes or Odinforce. He lost them, but he know is the same one who fought with Celestials and used God Blast on Galactus.
" @tensor said:I can't agree with you here" @czarny_samael: current thor is no way the same as classic thor the feat what he did in chaos war is yet to be explain (read the top of your scan)an after doing such a feat he would have no change back to Donald Blake an this is 1 of his biggest feat so far hope marvel gives a good explanation for this it would be nice to see him become the powerhouse again "Current Thor isn't as powerfull as Classic. He also isn't near that powerfull. He also isn't more powerfull.
He is Classic Thor. He don't have to prove anything. He never was depowered. He only got up-grade like Runes or Odinforce. He lost them, but he know is the same one who fought with Celestials and used God Blast on Galactus. "
Their are many characters that show greater feats in the past
And lesser ones that negate them now
And there has been nothing stated that depowers them
Examples would be Gladiator, Strange, Hulk (before the current)
Thor use to match Hulk mostly in strength (which never seemed right)
Now he can't beat him using strength alone
" @czarny_samael said:All of thier loses to weaker characters is PIS. Until someone is depower, he shouldn't lose to wekaer character. Lesser ones don't negate best feats." @tensor said:I can't agree with you here Their are many characters that show greater feats in the past And lesser ones that negate them now And there has been nothing stated that depowers themExamples would be Gladiator, Strange, Hulk (before the current) Thor use to match Hulk mostly in strength (which never seemed right)Now he can't beat him using strength alone "" @czarny_samael: current thor is no way the same as classic thor the feat what he did in chaos war is yet to be explain (read the top of your scan)an after doing such a feat he would have no change back to Donald Blake an this is 1 of his biggest feat so far hope marvel gives a good explanation for this it would be nice to see him become the powerhouse again "Current Thor isn't as powerfull as Classic. He also isn't near that powerfull. He also isn't more powerfull.
He is Classic Thor. He don't have to prove anything. He never was depowered. He only got up-grade like Runes or Odinforce. He lost them, but he know is the same one who fought with Celestials and used God Blast on Galactus. "
" @StrongestOneThereIs said:History negates their best feats" @czarny_samael said:All of thier loses to weaker characters is PIS. Until someone is depower, he shouldn't lose to wekaer character. Lesser ones don't negate best feats. "" @tensor said:I can't agree with you here Their are many characters that show greater feats in the past And lesser ones that negate them now And there has been nothing stated that depowers themExamples would be Gladiator, Strange, Hulk (before the current) Thor use to match Hulk mostly in strength (which never seemed right)Now he can't beat him using strength alone "" @czarny_samael: current thor is no way the same as classic thor the feat what he did in chaos war is yet to be explain (read the top of your scan)an after doing such a feat he would have no change back to Donald Blake an this is 1 of his biggest feat so far hope marvel gives a good explanation for this it would be nice to see him become the powerhouse again "Current Thor isn't as powerfull as Classic. He also isn't near that powerfull. He also isn't more powerfull.
He is Classic Thor. He don't have to prove anything. He never was depowered. He only got up-grade like Runes or Odinforce. He lost them, but he know is the same one who fought with Celestials and used God Blast on Galactus. "
Do you have a reason why Thor wouldn't fall under the same conditions as the others
Or do you disagree with the masses that these characters are different from their classic versions?
" @czarny_samael: current thor is no way the same as classic thor the feat what he did in chaos war is yet to be explain (read the top of your scan)an after doing such a feat he would have no change back to Donald Blake an this is 1 of his biggest feat so far hope marvel gives a good explanation for this it would be nice to see him become the powerhouse again "
he became donald blake again because he was midn raped, you can read in the captions. le lost his memory, thats what it seems, because he can not remember what happened, or why he got there
" @czarny_samael:
@blackadam: Was it ever said that Strange was depowered before losing the title? I don't think so. And everyone here notes classic Strange is different in power level Not sure what is being stated by the blackhole thing "
the black hole thing is to show thor is faster than light in space; light can't scape a black hole. so, was flying ftl to scape the gravitational pull of the black hole
" @blackadam: ok fine i agree on that, miss that bit out just look it over an saw that, but marvel need to explain the power that help him pull through the battle what is it? "
i don't think it was a power per se,but the logical explanation would be that the woman praying to thor gave him inner strength; i thing to keep fighting for. if you remember the woman who saved donald blake had a statues of various gods, one of the statues was thor. to me it wasn't a power because it didn't upgrade thor abilities, it just gave him a motive to keep fighting. i think it was of a phycological thing, rather than a power boost.but, i could be wrong. we have to wait and see what was that "spark".
"@StrongestOneThereIs said:" @czarny_samael:the black hole thing is to show thor is faster than light in space; light can't scape a black hole. so, was flying ftl to scape the gravitational pull of the black hole "
@blackadam: Was it ever said that Strange was depowered before losing the title? I don't think so. And everyone here notes classic Strange is different in power level Not sure what is being stated by the blackhole thing "
But that again is travel
I know Thor travels at speeds nearly matching the Surfer
That's stated in his official bio
But I want to know of any example of speed shown on his currrent or even his last series
As far as the thread
I think Thor had a better chance than the Sentry did at the level where he fought
But I don't think Thor would win
Early in his creation he beat Binary (a cosmic level character)
And was slowly gaining ground on Sentry
And the longer he fought, the more powerful he would have become
Thor i would give this battle to Thor.
Even that choas war scan posted earlier he did something beyond him he was already defeated and no power to do anything yet even tho it was the hammer that did most of it. He shouldnt have been able to do most of it. Its like Marvel was saying he got the power out of no where beyond his broken will bascally an act of miracles. Which many super heroes have at times,:)
" @czarny_samael said:No, it don't. All heroes have better and worse showings. Would You say that Firelord is weak because he losed to Spider-Man? PIS don't count. If someone did something once, he can do it again (if he wasn't depowered)." All of thier loses to weaker characters is PIS. Until someone is depower, he shouldn't lose to wekaer character. Lesser ones don't negate best feats. "History negates their best feats Do you have a reason why Thor wouldn't fall under the same conditions as the others Or do you disagree with the masses that these characters are different from their classic versions? "
Masses? Who cares about masses? And for the record, most people here belives in all feats. No matter when they happened.
" @StrongestOneThereIs said:" @czarny_samael said:No, it don't. All heroes have better and worse showings. Would You say that Firelord is weak because he losed to Spider-Man? PIS don't count. If someone did something once, he can do it again (if he wasn't depowered). Masses? Who cares about masses? And for the record, most people here belives in all feats. No matter when they happened. "" All of thier loses to weaker characters is PIS. Until someone is depower, he shouldn't lose to wekaer character. Lesser ones don't negate best feats. "History negates their best feats Do you have a reason why Thor wouldn't fall under the same conditions as the others Or do you disagree with the masses that these characters are different from their classic versions? "
Many fell that was PIS with Spiderman
But hey don't consider all the reason that happened
Firelord could have killed Spiderman outright but it would have endangered innocents
That limited his use of his power
Spiderman once began to wear down Masterson as Thor with the same speed attack tactic
I will admit that it was a big big stretch but with some basis for reasoning
Now Black Panther holding Surfer arm in a lock was PIS
Thor is simply not the Thor of the classic era
Much like Strange isn't
Strange use to converse with beings like Eternity
Thor use to fight Celestials but everything since Walt Simonson show a lesser character
There are classic feats for characters like Thor, Strange, Hulk, Namor, Wonder Man and many more
That are just not seen anymore
They don't show the level of power anymore and it was not due to be depowered
They are just not written that way anymore
I understand what your saying about a feat being a feat and unless the character is stated as be depowered then it holds
But when a feat is so far in a characters history and has yet to be duplicated in slightly in two series, then something is negated
And on the Vine, sadly the masses count
Becaue I totally disagree with this crossover rule
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment