Thor vs Hulk

I'm surprised this hasn't been done.

Thor(mastered all the abilities he's displayed over the years) NO Odin Force or Rune Magic!!

vs

Hulk(Savage)

Both bloodlusted, win by death, takes place in an unpopulated New York City at day time. Win by death. No bfr or time manipulation allowed.

Thor though it's hard to say with all the jobbing he does these days.

So long as Thor doesn't job, Thor curbstomps.

@venomoushatred1001 said:

So long as Thor doesn't job, Thor curbstomps.

What is jobbing? And I disagree based on their past fights.

@majestic99 said:

@venomoushatred1001 said:

So long as Thor doesn't job, Thor curbstomps.

What is jobbing? And I disagree based on their past fights.

Losing to someone weaker than you.

@venomoushatred1001: Do you mean in general, due to PIS, what?

Like how Wolverine could go toe to toe with Thor?

What can savage Hulk do?

@terry2012 said:

What can savage Hulk do?

He's stronger than Thor. And tough enough to withstand Thor's attacks.

@majestic99: Ok. But is he smart?

@terry2012 said:

@majestic99: Ok. But is he smart?

Smart enough to go toe to toe with Thor on several occasions.

@majestic99 said:

@terry2012 said:

What can savage Hulk do?

He's stronger than Thor.

that's quite unfounded.^

@majestic99:

Okay than there my answer. Hulk

@jaywray: Why

@jaywray said:

that's quite unfounded.^

I guess it's wrong. Thor has stalemated Hulk's strength for an entire hour, showing they're at least equal in strength.

@majestic99 said:

@terry2012 said:

@majestic99: Ok. But is he smart?

Smart enough to go toe to toe with Thor on several occasions.

Because that requires some prodigious level of intellect? I have a newfound respect for Ulik.

@terry2012: Because Thor has better strength showings than hulk.

@majestic99: I agree they could be close but I still think since you said it's a Thor who has mastered all his abilities he's not jobbing, So I'm going with Thor.

When you say they stalemated, in what way? I know they've fought for a good while but what showing of strength did they stalemate in?

@terry2012:

Stalemating Hulk's strength from Defenders #10.

We haven't seen a Savage Hulk for a decent amount of time now. It's always been consistently a similar incarnation to the Green Scar.

I'd say Thor edges out the win to his far greater array of powers and lack of restrictions in this bout.

@jaywray: Read my above comment, thor stalemated Hulk's strength for an entire hour.

@CitizenBane said:

Because that requires some prodigious level of intellect? I have a newfound respect for Ulik.

.....Ulik?

@jaywray: Ok

I really don't know what to think. Every time I've seen them fight, Hulk has always beaten him. Yet I'm sure there have been plenty of times in the last like forty something years it's been the other way around. It's to my understanding that Thor cannot beat Hulk in brute force alone, but considering he has speed, intelligence, fighting ability, and pretty much everything else on his side I'm sure he COULD beat him, but I would think it would have to be quickly since Hulk's strength and durability just keep going up and up.

Thor wins he is more powerful

Thor

@GunGunW said:

Every time I've seen them fight, Hulk has always beaten him.

How many times have you seen them fight?

@majestic99: Cheers wasn't sure if you meant in just a battle or an actual feat of strength, although it is well known that Thor jobbers like mad when he's facing Hulk, after all, he was specifically made to be stronger than hulk and has better feats lol.

But still in a fight Thor simply has more skills to use which will give him the win.

Thor with mastery of all his plot device powers would destroy Hulk, unless you want this to remain in character, in which case he is content to brawl with Hulk and it makes little difference.

thor easily

Thor easy

@CitizenBane: Considering you ignored my entire message except for that one part, I think you're trying to pick a fight with me.

Also, even if it doesn't count, whenever they fight in the movies and cartoons, Hulk wastes him. Plus, didn't they kick Hulk out of the Avengers because they couldn't control him?

@GunGunW said:

@CitizenBane: Considering you ignored my entire message except for that one part, I think you're trying to pick a fight with me.

Also, even if it doesn't count, whenever they fight in the movies and cartoons, Hulk wastes him. Plus, didn't they kick Hulk out of the Avengers because they couldn't control him?

Because the rest of your comment is based on that single line. You say Thor cannot beat Hulk with brute strength, and your reasoning for said statement is that in every fight between the two you have seen, Hulk has won. So I'm wondering how many of their fights you've seen, because I like to consider myself the expert on the history of the Hulk/Thor fights.

Movies and cartoons are not canon. Kicking Hulk out of the Avengers is hardly relevant.

Thor would fry the hulk and this has been done several times hasnt it? why make a new one...LOL

I've always been to the opinion that if Thor fights with his abilities, he can take Hulk quite comfortably in a fight.

If Thor fights Hulk and plays Hulk's game (doesn't use any abilities Hulk can't do, reduces his combat to brawling) Hulk will win.

@CitizenBane: My bad then, sorry for over reacting

@TheAcidSkull said:

@CitizenBane: http://hero-envy.blogspot.com/2011/09/hulk-vs-thor.html

this should clear things up, thor has shown a limit, he neede beta ray bill's help to hold up asgard, hulk has yet not shown a limit to his brute strength , if thor can KO hulk in time he can win, if the fight goes on long enough then hulk would beat him.

I've read every Hulk/Thor fight ever published. I am in no need of clarification.

@TheAcidSkull: Here, this should clear things up even better.

http://www.comicvine.com/thor/29-2268/thor-and-hulk-what-really-happened-and-what-would-really-happen/92-663395/?

@TheAcidSkull: If you've read the post you'd know that I made my thoughts on that clear already.

If thor has mastered energy absorbtion can't he just absorb all the chemical and kinetic and heat energy from Hulks body?

Thor has to many abilities and better feats over the Hulk. Only thing impressive about Hulk is his durability, healing and speed... Thor is a Thunder God who can teleport, fly and has magic. since thor can fly how can hulk get ahold of him or do anything? He can't.

Thor Stomps!!!

@CitizenBane said:

Thor though it's hard to say with all the jobbing he does these days.

@blackadamFTW: What does it mean to wield a plot device for a weapon?

@jaywray said:

@majestic99: Cheers wasn't sure if you meant in just a battle or an actual feat of strength, although it is well known that Thor jobbers like mad when he's facing Hulk, after all, he was specifically made to be stronger than hulk and has better feats lol.

But still in a fight Thor simply has more skills to use which will give him the win.

1. What is jobbering?

2. Finally, someone other than me knows Thor was created to be stronger and more powerful than Hulk.

@majestic99: iagree with you thor can take this.also there are far to many hulks.

@majestic99 said:

@blackadamFTW: What does it mean to wield a plot device for a weapon?

It basically means that Mjolnir can do anything the writer wants it to.

@TheAcidSkull said:

@majestic99: whaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa????

I asked what does it mean to wield a plot device for a weapon, because I've been hearing that alot about Classic Thor.

Here's my answer:

@blackadamFTW said:

It basically means that Mjolnir can do anything the writer wants it to.

Are you saying that classic thor's feats are PIS?