i hate the phrase "solo's" but he really does in this one...
First prove he is immune to telepathy, and you might have an argument. Otherwise, team X takes him down via telepathy.
he was able to restructure his body after ozy reduced it to atoms/smaller
i think at the very least it would be a stalemate, as jean is possibly the only mutant he couldnt instantly bolognese
possibly
Restructuring his body is a far cry from immunity to telepathy my friend. He can reform himself after the removal of his intrinsic field, that doesn't equate to being immune or even resistant to mental attacks.
i hate the phrase "solo's" but he really does in this one...
First prove he is immune to telepathy, and you might have an argument. Otherwise, team X takes him down via telepathy.
he was able to restructure his body after ozy reduced it to atoms/smaller
i think at the very least it would be a stalemate, as jean is possibly the only mutant he couldnt instantly bolognese
possibly
Restructuring his body is a far cry from immunity to telepathy my friend. He can reform himself after the removal of his intrinsic field, that doesn't equate to being immune or even resistant to mental attacks.
well we have no evidence of his level of resistance to telepathic attacks, whether or not they would even matter against a being seemingly incapable of death. i am merely stipulating that imo jean would be the only real challenge, but again imo she wouldnt be
well we have no evidence of his level of resistance to telepathic attacks, whether or not they would even matter against a being seemingly incapable of death. i am merely stipulating that imo jean would be the only real challenge, but again imo she wouldnt be
Therein lies the key to his defeat in this thread -- the lack of evidence. As well, this battle isn't listed as "to the death", so death is not the only means of winning here.
I'll not fault your opinion, but without actual proof to back up the idea of some sort of resistance to telepathic attacks...well...Manhattan goes down to the telepaths.
well we have no evidence of his level of resistance to telepathic attacks, whether or not they would even matter against a being seemingly incapable of death. i am merely stipulating that imo jean would be the only real challenge, but again imo she wouldnt be
Therein lies the key to his defeat in this thread -- the lack of evidence. As well, this battle isn't listed as "to the death", so death is not the only means of winning here.
I'll not fault your opinion, but without actual proof to back up the idea of some sort of resistance to telepathic attacks...well...Manhattan goes down to the telepaths.
Ah well, we can agree to disagree and move on.
This is why people should stop using Watchmen and Hancock in Battles...they have very little feats to substantiate a prolonged debate against many other characters.
This is why people should stop using Watchmen and Hancock in Battles...they have very little feats to substantiate a prolonged debate against many other characters.
Yeah, there is the problem of lack of intel with the series.
Most of Watchmen will be killed in less than 3 seconds, Wolverine alone could do it in less than 1 minute.
Dr. Manhattan will be left, but since there is nothing about telepathy have ever been mentioned in Watchmen yet, so it's possible that he might not be immune to telepathy.
I'll say X-Men for now, probably with some casualties.
People act like Manhatten reconstituting himself and things make him superior in these battles. If you really think about it, it's really not that serious..Manhatten are similar to people like Iceman and X Man..They are able to reconstitute themselves because their minds/consciousness can act dependent of a body and therefore live on after the corporeal body is destroyed. A telepath/reality warper can easily destroy Manhatten's psyche or consciousness, effectively rendering brain-dead (which is why iceman is rarely put into fights with telepaths..shut down/mindrape/destroy his mind/consciousness and he can't reform). all organisms have some sort of consciousness may it be subconscious or anything else. for a specimen to illustrate any form of skill or ability or power... it all starts with the mind or the conscious the conscious is like the headquarters of the being, it transports the code to form decisions, follow orders, set goals etc.. this all takes some type of psionic energy, may it be physical, or physcological...TELEPATHS manipulate this very energy..Manhatten exhibits thought, does he not?? Even if he has resistance (which hasn't been shown, so it isn't fair to assume so) he sure doesn't have enough to not be overwhelmed by 3 omega psis: Emma, Phoenix (Jean), and Psylocke (heck jean as phoenix is the NEXUS of all psionic energy..shutting him down mentally should be child's play). Manhatten gets mindraped into oblivion here in less than a conscious thought!
Manhattan has a conscious mind and no enhanced thought/reaction speed. He doesn't need a physical brain for telepaths to defeat him. Emma solos, Betsy solos, Jean solos.
There's no need for any Pheonix on the X team cause they have enough power to defeat the watchmen. with Psylocke and Cloak alone can beat everyone of them Psylocke can manipulate their minds and cloak can teleport them else where, the rest of the team the beast alone can beat or cyclops optic blasts alone can wipe them out.
It all goes down to an epic finale between Jean Grey and Dr Manhatten, whilst Wolverine is lying on the floor watching the confrontation, but the Doctor has that nitch for waving his hand and *poof*, so I think Watchmen will win this.
Manhattan blows up all the X-Men. The rest of the Watchmen are irrelevant. Although Dr. Manhattan "may" not have immunity to telepathy, he should easily be able to vaporize everyone with a wave of his hand. The X-Men die.
Log in to comment