The Shade vs Mirror Master

Pre New 52 versions

Morals off for both

Battle is in Opal City by the community swimming pool(s)

Mirror Master is McCullough

Win by KO, Incapacitation or Death.

Mirror Master

MM

bump

Still Mirror Master.

Shade. Evan can't really do anything to hurt him, and Shade just operates on a higher level with much more impressive feats to back it up.

Oooo

@juiceboks: Shade's not that hard to hurt honestly. He has a few good showings but he's been brought down by Knives and arrows before.

@highaccuser: Mirror Master can be brought down by the same though.

@highaccuser: He's had his heart ripped out and merely seemed annoyed.

@highaccuser: When was he brought down by knives? Given the nature of his powers, physical attacks shouldn't bother him.

@juiceboks: I don't know exactly when he was dropped by knives (I might not even have read the issue come to think of it) but during his miniseries Spider dropped him by throwing an arrow at his chest. Granted he was taken off guard but that wouldn't change his healing.

@supermanwithatan01: He was briefly dropped by that, and much less has been able to fell him.

@heirtothekingdom: But Shade doesn't have the means to employ any attack like that given he can't reach Mirror Master when he's in another dimension.

@highaccuser: in the instance I'm referring to, he wasn't dropped. He got pissed off and scared the hell out of the black lanterns

Edit, apologies you're right he did fall to his knees.

@highaccuser: Yes you are right, just wanted to add that in.

Isn't Shade above classic Fate? He's been dropped by arrows and knives...really? @xiix scans?

Evan

bump. I'm surprised people are picking MM for the win. Can Shade go through dimensions?

Likewise

Shade

Why does mm win?

@juiceboks:

When was he brought down by knives? Given the nature of his powers, physical attacks shouldn't bother him.

They better have been made of Nth Metal, otherwise that is craziness.

Swift.

I thought the Shade's control of the Darkness would give him the edge here anyway as Mirrors don't work without light. I mean as soon as Evan hears his opponent call himself Mirror Master and lets face it McCullough will talk/brag. Then he plunges the pool and room into darkness. At this point MM is losing.

Not to mention all the powers The Shade has in general from demon summoning to near immortality, Dr Fate has remarked Spectre would have trouble with him what is MM going to do?

To win MM needs to surround him in total light and I don't think he is smart enough to figure that out in time.

bump

Eh, in hindsight I may have given Shade's low showings too much focus in this thread and he should win if we don't extrapolate too heavily on them.

@highaccuser: what do you think about this battle now? I'm not really sure what Richards base power level is...ideas?

Shade is casually planet level and has overpowered Obsidian who stomped Kyle Rayner. He wins in all logical likelihood. Even if we focus on low showings Evan has those too in terms of competence.

Shade Stomps

Bump