• 86 results
  • 1
  • 2
#1 Edited by Floopay (8610 posts) - - Show Bio

Alright, I did find one of these, but it was a bit ridiculous so I'm gonna try and make this a little simpler.

Rules:

1. 3 Rounds, best of 2

2. Win by Death, KO, or Submission

3. Follow the rules within each round

4. Classic levels for Punisher and feats (Pretty much any version of either, except things like Franken Castle, or blood stone, or special one shot powers), New 52 Bane.

5. Each has about 1 hour to research the other, in a library, with only newspapers and magazines (So they can only really see what the other has been seen doing, and all second hand info).

Battlefield:

Round 1: Wrestling

1. Start 10 meters apart

2. No equipment or venom

3. Can obviously used improvised weaponry

4. 15 minutes to familiarize themselves with their environment (but no taking anything or laying traps/etc.)

5. Takes place at dawn.

Round 2: No Fire Arms

1. Start across the construction zone from one another

2. Frank gets his Kevlar suit, 3 throwing knives, a combat knife, and a machete.

3. Bane gets venom, and a set of brass knuckles that fit him

4. Each gets 30min to lay improvised traps, familiarize themselves with their environment, and find the best tactical position to start

5. Starts at dusk with 30 minutes of light left

Round 3: Firearms

1. Start across the construction zone from one another

2. Frank gets Kevlar suit, 5 throwing knives, 1 combat knife, two Smith And Wesson 3913 with one clip each, M60 machine gun with one clip, 1 claymore, and 2 frag grenades

3. Bane gets his venom, 2 combat knives, a set of brass knuckles, M-32 Grenade Launcher (He has 4 40mm Explosive Grenades, and 2 40mm Smoke Cylinders), and an AA-12 Combat Shotgun (8 Round Clip and 1 Clip).

4. Each gets 1 hour of prep to lay traps, improvised traps, familiarize themselves with their environment, and find the best tactical position to start

5. Fight start at midnight.

Best out of three rounds, who is the winner?

Frank Castle

Bane (Pre-52)

Thanks for reading,

Floopay

#2 Posted by hyiena (1790 posts) - - Show Bio

Very nice

#3 Posted by BigCimmerian (7853 posts) - - Show Bio

Bane tears him apart in round 1 and in round 2, in 3 round Punisher has a chance

#4 Posted by Lunacyde (17929 posts) - - Show Bio

Just a t first glance. 
 
1. Bane 
2. Bane 
3. Castle

#5 Posted by JediXMan (29619 posts) - - Show Bio

1. Bane.

2. Probably Bane. Though Punisher might be able to set up decent traps, but I doubt it.

3. Punisher.

#6 Posted by Uno_Oscuro (743 posts) - - Show Bio

Punisher is reduced to h2h and melee combat in the first two rounds, in which case Bane is going to win. But round three goes to the Punisher.

#7 Posted by nickzambuto (12959 posts) - - Show Bio

Bane wins round 1. Look up the word "brutal" in the dictionary, and you'll see a picture of Frank Castle. In terms of improv, he's also a member of the big leagues, so a construction site suits him well.

Unfortunately, that's not enough to beat Bane.

Round 2, Bane as well. I doubt if knives will even pierce his skin while on venom.

Round 3 however, is where Punisher has the advantage. But it is by no means a stomp. None of them are, save for round 2.

#8 Edited by troller (911 posts) - - Show Bio

PUNISHER IS A BADASS

#9 Posted by Dhor (282 posts) - - Show Bio

bane destroys him. The punisher might b a good fighter but Bane is wicked smart and that would be the decisive factor

#10 Posted by Super_SoldierXII (6174 posts) - - Show Bio

@JediXMan said:

1. Bane.

2. Probably Bane. Though Punisher might be able to set up decent traps, but I doubt it.

3. Punisher.

Pretty much this.

Though Frank with knives in round 2 could be pretty dangerous despite the venom. I know Bane on Venom shrugs off bullets, but a knife to the jugular is a knife to the jugular. Still, odds are against Frank pulling it off due to a distinct skill disadvantage.

#11 Edited by VercingetorixTheGreat (2823 posts) - - Show Bio

Round 1. Definitively Bane

Round 2. Again its Bane... looking at that picture he wasn't on Bane so yea thats what pretty much happens to Punisher.

Round 3. A close one but Frank comes out on top. Though I remember in Secret Six he popped bullets out of his skin, however enough should kill him.

#12 Posted by CrimsonCake (2669 posts) - - Show Bio

Bane wins Round 1 -Wrestling really leans this towards bane's favor.

Bane wins Round 2

Punisher Wins Round 3

Both are tactically smart so maybe he could beat bane in round 2 depending on his level of strategic thinking.

#13 Posted by matchesmalone21 (8420 posts) - - Show Bio

Round 1: Bane. Even without Venom,his strength is greater than a normal human being. Like the time,he punch the Man-Bat,break the Judomaster's back or break Killer Croc arms.

Round 2: Bane. Nothing more to say

Round 3: 50/50,but Bane has iM-32 Grenade Launcher,this is a huge advantage.

#14 Posted by tg1982 (2715 posts) - - Show Bio

Round 1: Bane

Round 2: Bane

Round 3: Won't happen, Bane already won best of 2 so Punisher would get swept.

But for the sake of argument let's say they get a round three, just because, then Pun would win it.

#15 Posted by Picard (982 posts) - - Show Bio

Frank, piece of advice: aim for the head! :)

#16 Posted by Floopay (8610 posts) - - Show Bio

OP Changes: Punisher now has a Machete, a Kevlar Suit, and 1 extra throwing knife for round 2

BUMP and discuss :D.

Thanks for reading,

Floopay

#17 Posted by Nefarious (18760 posts) - - Show Bio

Round 1: Bane 
 
Round 2: Bane 
 
Round 3: Bane

#18 Posted by _Beastmaster_ (1515 posts) - - Show Bio
@Floopay: Great setup.
Bane for the first two rounds, Punisher for third.
#19 Posted by Recoil1985 (521 posts) - - Show Bio
  1. Bane will be the victor.  He's physically superior to Frank Castle and a more gifted unarmed combatant.  If Frank wishes to survive he'll need to use the environment in his favor, but even then it doesn't seem likely.
  2. Bane.  Again, he's the more talented combatant in close range.  Frank holds some potential to dish out decent damage to Bane, but in the end his bladed weapons won't counter-act Bane's superior skill and now improved physicals on venom.
  3. Flip a coin.  Frank undeniably has the better accuracy feats, but Bane has proven more than competent with firearms (No Man's Land and Bane of the Demon).  Seeing as they're both armed to the teeth with heavy explosives and had the opportunity to deploy traps before entering the field, I honestly believe they stand at virtually even odds of winning.  
#20 Posted by ThatThorFan (951 posts) - - Show Bio

Bane

Bane

Punisher

#21 Posted by DTFB (191 posts) - - Show Bio

im new to the vine but i take Bane for the first 2 and Punisher for the last

#22 Posted by ImmortalOne (3304 posts) - - Show Bio

1. Bane

2. Bane

3. Punisher- but only if he can keep Bane at a range.

#23 Posted by XMen1963 (484 posts) - - Show Bio

Bane with a little bit of trouble

Castle

Castle

#24 Posted by Floopay (8610 posts) - - Show Bio

Bump!

#25 Posted by XMen1963 (484 posts) - - Show Bio

Punisher > The Russian > Bane

Punisher loses round one 6/10

Punisher wins rounds two and three 9/10

#26 Posted by matchesmalone21 (8420 posts) - - Show Bio

Round 1:Bane,. Even withou Venom superpas human strength and durability,can whistand gunfire and letrical shocks. Bane gonna rip Castle's arms off.

scans without Venom:

Round 2: Bane. C'mon he break Killer Croc arms (twice),and gave a memorable beating on Batman, Azrael (in his own series),break a mutated dinosaur's neck during Salvation Run

Round 3:50/50

#27 Posted by IKnowEverything (359 posts) - - Show Bio

Round 1: Bane stomps

Round 2: Punisher wins with difficulty

Round 3: Punisher stomps.

#28 Posted by matchesmalone21 (8420 posts) - - Show Bio

@IKnowEverything: what?? round 2 Bane with Venom and Punisher wins??

#29 Posted by IKnowEverything (359 posts) - - Show Bio

@matchesmalone21: With difficulty yes, i believe so. I could be swayed, but i think Frank can beat him with the weapons from the OP if Bane gets only brass knuckles and venom. I think Frank could kill him without Bane landing a hit.

but like i said, i could be swayed by a great bane with venom agility feat. i just don't think he would be as fast as frank would be with combat knives.

#30 Posted by matchesmalone21 (8420 posts) - - Show Bio

@IKnowEverything:Sorry,he can win Round 3 but 2 ,nor evn close. If Bane resists to bullets without Venom, with the Venom even knives can cause major injuries and with Venom he heals faster than a human being, as Captain America. You forget the battle happend in a construction?? He can use anything as a weapon, to play upon it

#31 Posted by Pokergeist (22351 posts) - - Show Bio
@Super_SoldierXII said:


                   

@JediXMan said:

1. Bane.

2. Probably Bane. Though Punisher might be able to set up decent traps, but I doubt it.

3. Punisher.

Pretty much this.

Though Frank with knives in round 2 could be pretty dangerous despite the venom. I know Bane on Venom shrugs off bullets, but a knife to the jugular is a knife to the jugular. Still, odds are against Frank pulling it off due to a distinct skill disadvantage.



                   

               

Agreed.
#32 Posted by IKnowEverything (359 posts) - - Show Bio

@matchesmalone21 said:

@IKnowEverything:Sorry,he can win Round 3 but 2 ,nor evn close. If Bane resists to bullets without Venom, with the Venom even knives can cause major injuries and with Venom he heals faster than a human being, as Captain America. You forget the battle happend in a construction?? He can use anything as a weapon, to play upon it

frank is smart and he can tangle with Spidey in h2h. with a combat knife i think he can get a killshot on Bane pumped up. it doesn't make him faster. just stronger. venom won't stop frank from a killshot. plus in a construction site there are tools that BOTH characters can use. Bane is not the only person who can take advantage of the environment.

#33 Posted by matchesmalone21 (8420 posts) - - Show Bio

@IKnowEverything: Yes don't make him faster,but he is well agile.

This valid for both side,so..this more to 50/50

frank is smart and he can tangle with Spidey in h2h. with a combat knife i think he can get a killshot on Bane pumped up. it doesn't make him faster. just stronger. venom won't stop frank from a killshot. plus in a construction site there are tools that BOTH characters can use. Bane is not the only person who can take advantage of the environment.

#34 Posted by Floopay (8610 posts) - - Show Bio

@IKnowEverything: @matchesmalone21: I think you both are making very good points. I was hoping less people would view this as an auto-win for a specific character in a specific round than have. It's good to see a nice analysis of each character with both being taken seriously for their tactics, physical prowess, and for once someone noticing the environment and how it could play into the battle.

Thanks for reading,

Floopay

#35 Posted by GhostRider29 (2673 posts) - - Show Bio

Bane

Punisher

Punisher

#36 Posted by AngryHulks (3001 posts) - - Show Bio

1. Bane (9/10)

2. Bane (7/10)

3. Punisher (6/10)

#37 Posted by TheBane2890 (1958 posts) - - Show Bio

ROUND 1: Bane rips Castle into little bitty pieces!

ROUND 2: Bane breaks Castle's back!

ROUND 3: Bane outsmarts Castle, and wins by KO!

#38 Posted by theicon (1797 posts) - - Show Bio

Frank is on par with his H2H, and with his weapons , say Grenade launcher bane meets his Bane even if bane attempts to back break Frank, Frank will slip out that secret knife to slash his wrists or stabb him in the back of his neck...i say Frank but battered and brused very bad

#39 Posted by Pokergeist (22351 posts) - - Show Bio


@TheBane2890
said:


                   

ROUND 1: Bane rips Castle into little bitty pieces!

ROUND 2: Bane breaks Castle's back!

ROUND 3: Bane outsmarts Castle, and wins by KO!



                   

               

LOL that last one is funny. 
 
Alright time for some Punisher Picks since no one else will.  
 


Punisher reflex is enough to Block Caps Shield throw and step on it. Cap is shocked. 
 







This is from Punisher Max where Punisher is in his 50s vs a Nasty Ex Navy Seal who dont feel pain called Barricuda. 
 



Punisher in CC gets the Kill on Bucky Barnes AKA Captain America. 
 









Punisher beats Bullseye not once but Twice. 
 



Punisher matching Dare Devil in CC. With no Weapons. 
 


Punisher beat SHIELD Agents with NVGs with no Weapons. 
 




Punisher Tagging and Spidey on a Physical LvL. 
 
 
    
    





Punisher works with what he has to stay one step ahead of Wolverine and take out the Badguys.  
 
 
Punisher is no slouch in CC and he is a Master of using the Eviroment around him. He uses what he has to get the Job done. 
 
I also find it pointless to put Scans of Punisher Marksman Feats since every Punisher Comic has those Feats in there. No way Bane is a better Marksman or knows Real World Firearms better than Frank.
#40 Posted by matchesmalone21 (8420 posts) - - Show Bio

@Floopay: Thanks dude

#41 Posted by sandiego008 (3283 posts) - - Show Bio

Bane

8/10 punisher

punisher.

Unless I'm mistaken Punisher has tangled and has experience fighting much stronger opponents than bane does, in many of these situations he is forced to go hand to hand and he always survives. As impressive as banes track record is (very impressive) he loses here because I believe frank has a better track record.

#42 Posted by theicon (1797 posts) - - Show Bio

@CadenceV2: lol best ever!

#43 Posted by Pokergeist (22351 posts) - - Show Bio
@theicon
Frank just needs some loving every now and then. Everyone has Scans of Bane awsomness. And he is AWSOME. But Frank is too.
#44 Posted by tomdickharry1984 (834 posts) - - Show Bio

B, B, P

#45 Posted by Typhion (622 posts) - - Show Bio

Bane 7/10 - Frank can hold his own in H2H, but even without Venom, Bane is a complete brute, and a well established warrior.

Bane 6/10 - Frank has a slight edge in weapons, but Bane has a bigger edge in innate physical ability and resistance.

Frank 7/10 - Frank's edge just got bigger.

#46 Posted by XMen1963 (484 posts) - - Show Bio

@sandiego008 said:

Bane

8/10 punisher

punisher.

Unless I'm mistaken Punisher has tangled and has experience fighting much stronger opponents than bane does, in many of these situations he is forced to go hand to hand and he always survives. As impressive as banes track record is (very impressive) he loses here because I believe frank has a better track record.

#47 Posted by Kinasin_ (1141 posts) - - Show Bio

@Nefarious said:

Round 1: Bane Round 2: Bane Round 3: Bane
#48 Posted by (((Prodigy))) (2443 posts) - - Show Bio

Bane wins 1 and 2. Punisher wins 3.

#49 Posted by Floopay (8610 posts) - - Show Bio

Bump

Thanks for reading,

Floopay

#50 Posted by TheCheeseStabber (7798 posts) - - Show Bio

@JediXMan said:

1. Bane.

2. Probably Bane. Though Punisher might be able to set up decent traps, but I doubt it.

3. Punisher.

This.

The Bane scan is Epicness xD