"The Incredible Hulk vs. The Unstoppable Juggernaut"

Hulk.

Post Deleted.

In a knock-down drag out fight, who would come out on top, The Incredible Hulk or The Unstoppable Juggernaut. This fight is assuming they are both at full power, fully intent on killing each other, and are in NYC, AND ONE OF THEM HAS TO DIE.
Post Edited:2007-02-07 22:49:41

Hulk never tires and he's always getting stronger. That means Hulk would just keep getting stronger and stronger.

My money's still on Juggs.

Yeah, but he could eventually get strong enough to hurl Juggs into space, where he would eventually fall into a star.

Hulk couldn't hurt the Juggernaut. From the Marvel Universe "the mystical energy of Cytorrak makes him impervious to all injury up to and including molecular disintegration".

Hulk is faster. He'd get to Juggs first to knock him into space.

Or maybe they knock each other into space. Assuming Hulk has to breathe id say Juggs still wins.

It would be an awesome city destroying fight! I don't think Juggs could really hurt the hulk either.

Hulk. Eventually he'll get strong enough to rip the gem out of him like Onslaught did.

I dont think anything can actually hurt the Juggernaut unless it has magical or reality warping power.

Onslaught didn't have magic or reality warping power (when he took the gem out).

Last I heard (after juggernaut go his power back from Black Tom Cassidy) he threw the gem into space so no-one else could get it. I guess a writer had to figure out a way for Onlsaught to beat Juggs, selectively forgot that he threw the gem into space, and decided to put it inside of him.

The Onslaught thing was just plain bad writing... Classic Juggs does not have the gem inside him. Physically, you just can't beat Juggs. Plus he doesn't even need air, food, rest, etc.

I'd say Juggernaut... the fight would last months, though...
Post Edited:2007-01-30 21:10:00

Like I said, I don't mind characters evolving, but don't re-write history and and try and erase what has happened in previous comics.

The potential collateral damage surrounding the fight would be enormous. Maybe if he gets his powers back they'll re-visit this idea in the comics, and we'll see who would actually win.

Post Deleted.

Without the X-Men or the Leader, Juggernaut would had killed the Hulk twice by now.

How so ?

Hulk was proving to be too weak to stop the Juggernaut's killer urges towards him, then Xavier magically appeared and mind-zapped him (Hulk knocked off his helmet).

Juggernaut knocked Hulk unconscious, and then was on his way to literally beating Hulk to death until the Leader told him to stop.

Juggy Rulz!!

Yeah, the old Juggernaut was so powerful that Thor couldn't hurt him, and Hulk was barely able to put a dent in him. Hulk may be powerful, but Wolverine can cut him, and Wolvie can't make a nick in Juggs. Hulk has a healing factor, but that wouldn't kick in if Juggernaut just ripped his head off.

What makes you think that Hulk could even lift Juggernaut to throw him into space? Juggernaut hasn't even MOVED when punched by Colossus, or hit by Thor's hammer.

In fact, the only way Thor could beat him was to open a portal to another dimension that sucked Juggernaut in -- and Juggs promptly conquered the planet he landed on!

HOWEVER -- new Juggernaut on Excalibur has steadily been losing power. The Wrecking Crew handed him his ass. This Juggernaut would be pulped by the Hulk.

Boo to bad writing.

Well the Hulk did manage to knock Juggs away when they fought. But he wasnt moving at the time, so im not sure if the Hulk was just that powerful or Juggs wasn't paying attention. If I remember correctly Juggs was trying to recruit Hulk to be his partner in crime. Can you imagine the destruction those two would bring about if they worked together ?

Did anyone remember Hulk's healing factor?

Hulk is always getting stronger! If it goes on forever, he'll be able to lift over 300 tons, or more! He can dent Juggernaut. And Hulk is wa faster.

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-3934651591022114445

I think this speaks for itself.

HULK

Didn't somebody cut off everything but pure rage from the Hulk's mind when that happened ?

He had Banner's mind but felt like he was slowly losing it. So that even drives the point further. Here was an unsavage Hulk able to hold up a freakin' mountain. Don't recall Jugg-head doing that. But in Juggy's defense, he did do the deed with She-Hulk (not that Bruce could 'cause that would be sick).

Everyone secretly wants a piece of She-Hulk. Dont deny it.

Not if she's your cousin!!

Post Deleted.

apparantly not on attilan

Prurience Man says:

"There are laws against that (in most locales)."

What happens in Alabama, stays in Alabama.

The Hulk fought him once in the 70's and beat him so he would do it again. The madder he gets the stronger he gets.

Juggernaut would snap She-Hulk in half...hey wait! Isn't She-Hulk a HERO. Last time I checked superheroines didn't run around doing villians. When was the last time Wonder Woman laid Darkseid?

The man speaks the truth. by the way, I said the second quote, not my man Porcupine.

Maybe it would just be a tie if neither can hurt the other.

What it really comes down to would be if it occured in an issue of the Incredible Hulk or an issue of Excalibur. The writer could make it go either way. Juggy has been de-powering. Hulk could be really tired or something. I'd still go with Hulk but it would really depend.

Well I meant more or less if the battle took place IF Juggs got re-powered.

I'm still gonna say Hulk. But I'd wanna know what version we're talking about. Also where would the "venue" be? Location could be a factor. I don't remember if it's been mentioned and I'm too lazy to look back but what is Juggy's strength level? Hulk is definitely stronger plus the whole madder he gets... thing.

The Voidwalker says:

"In a knock-down drag out fight, who would come out on top, The Incredible Hulk or The Unstoppable Juggernaut. This fight is assuming they are both at full power, fully intent on killing each other, and are in NYC."

Last time I checked back when Juggs was still Unstopable he and Hulk were around the same strength level, but we dont really know if he ever really had a limit, I haven't seem him struggle to pick up anything.