The Amazing Spider-Man Andrew Garfield vs Spider-Man Toby Maguire

Both wonder the city of New York hoping to see a criminal at work.As they both swing and turn they bump into each other.Are they both seeing double?.Peter(Andrew Garfield) gets cocky while the other Peter(Toby Maguire) is no mode for such behavior.Peter(Toby Maguire) says imma put some dirt in your eye and the other Peter(Andrew Garfield says do it !.who win this epic

Using 2002 Spider-Man

Rules:

5 hours prep

Morals on

All abilities in Spider Man 2002 and The Amazing Spider-Man film on

Both full strength

Battle Death or KO

Who will win

@Sci_Fi_Rulez: Full strength Toby was in Spider-Man 2, when he was taking out Doc Ock ...... that movie was better than any Spider-Man movie so far ....... so he wins

I saw Amazing Spider-Man today though, he was good but not that good ..... Toby stopped a train Andrew got shot in the leg ...... fail

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez: Full strength Toby was in Spider-Man 2, when he was taking out Doc Ock ...... that movie was better than any Spider-Man movie so far ....... so he wins

I saw Amazing Spider-Man today though, he was good but not that good ..... Toby stopped a train Andrew got shot in the leg ...... fail

i saw it too.pretty cool and we are using the both the first movies

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez: Full strength Toby was in Spider-Man 2, when he was taking out Doc Ock ...... that movie was better than any Spider-Man movie so far ....... so he wins

I saw Amazing Spider-Man today though, he was good but not that good ..... Toby stopped a train Andrew got shot in the leg ...... fail

i saw it too.pretty cool and we are using the both the first movies

First movie spiderman wasn't that great ... but he was still stronger, held the tram car full of children with one arm ....... and he found Uncle Ben's killer and dealt with him, unlike Andrew ........

I havent seen the new movie yet. I just wanted to say Tobys Spider Suit is much Sweeter than Andrews. Toby wins the fashion round.

OK, I've seen both movies. And I'll say Toby wins this.

Tobey McGuire.

http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles/7/amazing-spider-man-vs-spider-man/677442/#28

I'm about to go and see this movie so I'll know who will win by then.

Toby -
1st  movie - Stopped a train before he even learned full use of his powers.
1st movie - Shoots webs without using some kind of technology.
2nd movie - Held up a freaking wall with only a little effort.
 
The only thing really better about this new movie is the jumping through air scenes.  Actually makes it look super realistic with amazing backgrounds.

Tobey wins, much stronger using all feats. But I'd like to see Andrew's Spidey by the end if they do a trilogy with this, he has potential.

@Mad8Baller said:

Toby - 1st movie - Stopped a train before he even learned full use of his powers.

What train did he stop?

tobey for reasons stated. new movie looks great though.

Tobey wins, much stronger using all feats. But I'd like to see Andrew's Spidey by the end if they do a trilogy with this, he has potential.

@Mad8Baller said:

Toby - 1st movie - Stopped a train before he even learned full use of his powers.

What train did he stop?

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez: Full strength Toby was in Spider-Man 2, when he was taking out Doc Ock ...... that movie was better than any Spider-Man movie so far ....... so he wins

I saw Amazing Spider-Man today though, he was good but not that good ..... Toby stopped a train Andrew got shot in the leg ...... fail

i saw it too.pretty cool and we are using the both the first movies

First movie spiderman wasn't that great ... but he was still stronger, held the tram car full of children with one arm ....... and he found Uncle Ben's killer and dealt with him, unlike Andrew ........

Ok, two spoilers is enough, I'm just gonna leave this thread before I get anymore.

@nickzambuto: lol information like snobby rich kids or chunky milk ...... SPOILERS FTW

@Mad8Baller said:

@HBKTimHBK said:

Tobey wins, much stronger using all feats. But I'd like to see Andrew's Spidey by the end if they do a trilogy with this, he has potential.

@Mad8Baller said:

Toby - 1st movie - Stopped a train before he even learned full use of his powers.

What train did he stop?

I mean second. I mixed the movies. But 2nd or 1st, he was still weak cause 1st he was new to powers and 2nd he was losing his edge.

Actually, Spidey lost his... spider impotence-thing at that point in the movie. He wasn't weak anymore.

Toby,He's stronger and faster.And so far he's had more feats.

With the implementation of rules, without a shadow of doubt, Toby over Andrew. As far as preparation, Toby can rely on himself, Andrews needs the "middle class union workers of new york" to aid him swing his handicap ass, along with NYPD's chief of police, to help him take out his first real supervillan. Toby uses webs not caring around a bunch of web cartridges, which give him no need to reload webbing. Toby can take alot of damage as far as i can remember with his fight with supervillans, Andrews weakness is firearms and experience with decision-making scenarios. Toby by a long shot, break his skinny skaterboy wirst web technology, and you can easily see Toby, letting the less experience spiderman go, cause I guess they both arent going to kill each other cause Morals are on, New York is a big city man, have Andrew take care of the little human law breaking and Toby take care of supervillans.

Toby>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Garfield. They tried playing off The Dark Knight's "This city needs you" theme, as well as the "Stuff you've never known about Spiderman... Revealed!" When nothing new came my way. As far as feats, Toby stomps Garfield. Toby weaved through GG's razor bat things, Garfield got shot.

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez: Full strength Toby was in Spider-Man 2, when he was taking out Doc Ock ...... that movie was better than any Spider-Man movie so far ....... so he wins

I saw Amazing Spider-Man today though, he was good but not that good ..... Toby stopped a train Andrew got shot in the leg ...... fail

i saw it too.pretty cool and we are using the both the first movies

First movie spiderman wasn't that great ... but he was still stronger, held the tram car full of children with one arm ....... and he found Uncle Ben's killer and dealt with him, unlike Andrew ........

That wasn't uncle Ben's killer he doesn't fine the real killer until Spider man 3 and the real killer is sandman

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez: Full strength Toby was in Spider-Man 2, when he was taking out Doc Ock ...... that movie was better than any Spider-Man movie so far ....... so he wins

I saw Amazing Spider-Man today though, he was good but not that good ..... Toby stopped a train Andrew got shot in the leg ...... fail

i saw it too.pretty cool and we are using the both the first movies

First movie spiderman wasn't that great ... but he was still stronger, held the tram car full of children with one arm ....... and he found Uncle Ben's killer and dealt with him, unlike Andrew ........

That wasn't uncle Ben's killer he doesn't fine the real killer until Spider man 3 and the real killer is sandman

But in Andrew's movie, it blatantly shows the other guy shoot Ben.

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez: Full strength Toby was in Spider-Man 2, when he was taking out Doc Ock ...... that movie was better than any Spider-Man movie so far ....... so he wins

I saw Amazing Spider-Man today though, he was good but not that good ..... Toby stopped a train Andrew got shot in the leg ...... fail

i saw it too.pretty cool and we are using the both the first movies

First movie spiderman wasn't that great ... but he was still stronger, held the tram car full of children with one arm ....... and he found Uncle Ben's killer and dealt with him, unlike Andrew ........

That wasn't uncle Ben's killer he doesn't fine the real killer until Spider man 3 and the real killer is sandman

But in Andrew's movie, it blatantly shows the other guy shoot Ben.

Yeah i know,but they said in part one that Toby's spider man found uncle Ben 's killer even though that dude wasn't the killer.It was Sandman.

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez: Full strength Toby was in Spider-Man 2, when he was taking out Doc Ock ...... that movie was better than any Spider-Man movie so far ....... so he wins

I saw Amazing Spider-Man today though, he was good but not that good ..... Toby stopped a train Andrew got shot in the leg ...... fail

i saw it too.pretty cool and we are using the both the first movies

First movie spiderman wasn't that great ... but he was still stronger, held the tram car full of children with one arm ....... and he found Uncle Ben's killer and dealt with him, unlike Andrew ........

That wasn't uncle Ben's killer he doesn't fine the real killer until Spider man 3 and the real killer is sandman

But in Andrew's movie, it blatantly shows the other guy shoot Ben.

Yeah i know,but they said in part one that Toby's spider man found uncle Ben 's killer even though that dude wasn't the killer.It was Sandman.

He might as well be the killer because Sandman was forced to push the trigger right after his partner bumped into him.

TM takes this

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez: Full strength Toby was in Spider-Man 2, when he was taking out Doc Ock ...... that movie was better than any Spider-Man movie so far ....... so he wins

I saw Amazing Spider-Man today though, he was good but not that good ..... Toby stopped a train Andrew got shot in the leg ...... fail

i saw it too.pretty cool and we are using the both the first movies

First movie spiderman wasn't that great ... but he was still stronger, held the tram car full of children with one arm ....... and he found Uncle Ben's killer and dealt with him, unlike Andrew ........

That wasn't uncle Ben's killer he doesn't fine the real killer until Spider man 3 and the real killer is sandman

But in Andrew's movie, it blatantly shows the other guy shoot Ben.

Yeah i know,but they said in part one that Toby's spider man found uncle Ben 's killer even though that dude wasn't the killer.It was Sandman.

He might as well be the killer because Sandman was forced to push the trigger right after his partner bumped into him.

He still pull the trigger and sandman even admitted he shot him but it was an accented,but still murdered him

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez: Full strength Toby was in Spider-Man 2, when he was taking out Doc Ock ...... that movie was better than any Spider-Man movie so far ....... so he wins

I saw Amazing Spider-Man today though, he was good but not that good ..... Toby stopped a train Andrew got shot in the leg ...... fail

i saw it too.pretty cool and we are using the both the first movies

First movie spiderman wasn't that great ... but he was still stronger, held the tram car full of children with one arm ....... and he found Uncle Ben's killer and dealt with him, unlike Andrew ........

That wasn't uncle Ben's killer he doesn't fine the real killer until Spider man 3 and the real killer is sandman

But in Andrew's movie, it blatantly shows the other guy shoot Ben.

Yeah i know,but they said in part one that Toby's spider man found uncle Ben 's killer even though that dude wasn't the killer.It was Sandman.

He might as well be the killer because Sandman was forced to push the trigger right after his partner bumped into him.

He still pull the trigger and sandman even admitted he shot him but it was an accented,but still murdered him

That's true, but he wouldn't have pulled the trigger if his partner didn't bump into his arm. Anyway, Tobey has far greater feats than Andrew. He heals fast, is far stronger able to dead stop what appeared to be a 40 ton steel wall and toss it aside like paper. Has incredible durability which he was able to take a pumpkin grenade to the face and not bleed and tanked several tons of pressure between his webs and a speeding train. Have Giant Sandman pound the sh1t out off him while Venom was holding him down. He's reaction timing and Spider Sense were far superior than Andrew's which enables him almost pre-cognition and sees dangerous situations in slow motion. Tobey was pretty much the comic Spider-Man with some modifications.

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez: Full strength Toby was in Spider-Man 2, when he was taking out Doc Ock ...... that movie was better than any Spider-Man movie so far ....... so he wins

I saw Amazing Spider-Man today though, he was good but not that good ..... Toby stopped a train Andrew got shot in the leg ...... fail

i saw it too.pretty cool and we are using the both the first movies

First movie spiderman wasn't that great ... but he was still stronger, held the tram car full of children with one arm ....... and he found Uncle Ben's killer and dealt with him, unlike Andrew ........

That wasn't uncle Ben's killer he doesn't fine the real killer until Spider man 3 and the real killer is sandman

But in Andrew's movie, it blatantly shows the other guy shoot Ben.

Yeah i know,but they said in part one that Toby's spider man found uncle Ben 's killer even though that dude wasn't the killer.It was Sandman.

He might as well be the killer because Sandman was forced to push the trigger right after his partner bumped into him.

He still pull the trigger and sandman even admitted he shot him but it was an accented,but still murdered him

That's true, but he wouldn't have pulled the trigger if his partner didn't bump into his arm. Anyway, Tobey has far greater feats than Andrew. He heals fast, is far stronger able to dead stop what appeared to be a 40 ton steel wall and toss it aside like paper. Has incredible durability which he was able to take a pumpkin grenade to the face and not bleed and tanked several tons of pressure between his webs and a speeding train. Have Giant Sandman pound the sh1t out off him while Venom was holding him down. He's reaction timing and Spider Sense were far superior than Andrew's which enables him almost pre-cognition and sees dangerous situations in slow motion. Tobey was pretty much the comic Spider-Man with some modifications.

I'm using Toby Maguire from the first Spider Man movie.Its a Movie 1 vs Movie 1 debate.To me Andrew presented more swiftness in his speed in the films,but yeah i guess Toby went through tougher opstacles,but Andrew was more acrobatic, and his skill with his webs shooters were outstanding...Spider senses are a little off though.

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez: Full strength Toby was in Spider-Man 2, when he was taking out Doc Ock ...... that movie was better than any Spider-Man movie so far ....... so he wins

I saw Amazing Spider-Man today though, he was good but not that good ..... Toby stopped a train Andrew got shot in the leg ...... fail

i saw it too.pretty cool and we are using the both the first movies

First movie spiderman wasn't that great ... but he was still stronger, held the tram car full of children with one arm ....... and he found Uncle Ben's killer and dealt with him, unlike Andrew ........

That wasn't uncle Ben's killer he doesn't fine the real killer until Spider man 3 and the real killer is sandman

But in Andrew's movie, it blatantly shows the other guy shoot Ben.

Yeah i know,but they said in part one that Toby's spider man found uncle Ben 's killer even though that dude wasn't the killer.It was Sandman.

He might as well be the killer because Sandman was forced to push the trigger right after his partner bumped into him.

He still pull the trigger and sandman even admitted he shot him but it was an accented,but still murdered him

That's true, but he wouldn't have pulled the trigger if his partner didn't bump into his arm. Anyway, Tobey has far greater feats than Andrew. He heals fast, is far stronger able to dead stop what appeared to be a 40 ton steel wall and toss it aside like paper. Has incredible durability which he was able to take a pumpkin grenade to the face and not bleed and tanked several tons of pressure between his webs and a speeding train. Have Giant Sandman pound the sh1t out off him while Venom was holding him down. He's reaction timing and Spider Sense were far superior than Andrew's which enables him almost pre-cognition and sees dangerous situations in slow motion. Tobey was pretty much the comic Spider-Man with some modifications.

I'm using Toby Maguire from the first Spider Man movie.Its a Movie 1 vs Movie 1 debate.To me Andrew presented more swiftness in his speed in the films,but yeah i guess Toby went through tougher opstacles,but Andrew was more acrobatic, and his skill with his webs shooters were outstanding...Spider senses are a little off though.

Tobey can jump 60 feet off the ground too. Andrew can jump 10 to 15 feet off the ground (basket ball scene)

Actually they tried pulling off "comic spiderman here". Peter always used Web cartridges in the comic (except with the venom suit) and he was never able to stop a train. Spiderman 2 was really pushing it with Peters abilities. I think this reboot did a better job portraying spiderman. And Toby wins.

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez: Full strength Toby was in Spider-Man 2, when he was taking out Doc Ock ...... that movie was better than any Spider-Man movie so far ....... so he wins

I saw Amazing Spider-Man today though, he was good but not that good ..... Toby stopped a train Andrew got shot in the leg ...... fail

i saw it too.pretty cool and we are using the both the first movies

First movie spiderman wasn't that great ... but he was still stronger, held the tram car full of children with one arm ....... and he found Uncle Ben's killer and dealt with him, unlike Andrew ........

That wasn't uncle Ben's killer he doesn't fine the real killer until Spider man 3 and the real killer is sandman

But in Andrew's movie, it blatantly shows the other guy shoot Ben.

Yeah i know,but they said in part one that Toby's spider man found uncle Ben 's killer even though that dude wasn't the killer.It was Sandman.

He might as well be the killer because Sandman was forced to push the trigger right after his partner bumped into him.

He still pull the trigger and sandman even admitted he shot him but it was an accented,but still murdered him

That's true, but he wouldn't have pulled the trigger if his partner didn't bump into his arm. Anyway, Tobey has far greater feats than Andrew. He heals fast, is far stronger able to dead stop what appeared to be a 40 ton steel wall and toss it aside like paper. Has incredible durability which he was able to take a pumpkin grenade to the face and not bleed and tanked several tons of pressure between his webs and a speeding train. Have Giant Sandman pound the sh1t out off him while Venom was holding him down. He's reaction timing and Spider Sense were far superior than Andrew's which enables him almost pre-cognition and sees dangerous situations in slow motion. Tobey was pretty much the comic Spider-Man with some modifications.

I'm using Toby Maguire from the first Spider Man movie.Its a Movie 1 vs Movie 1 debate.To me Andrew presented more swiftness in his speed in the films,but yeah i guess Toby went through tougher opstacles,but Andrew was more acrobatic, and his skill with his webs shooters were outstanding...Spider senses are a little off though.

Tobey can jump 60 feet off the ground too. Andrew can jump 10 to 15 feet off the ground (basket ball scene)

I'm pretty sure Andrew jumped higher in other senses,but i kinda forgot the movie lol.Andrew faced a tougher and smarter enemy.Movie Lizard would own Movie Green Goblin.

@CapitolPunishment said:

Actually they tried pulling off "comic spiderman here". Peter always used Web cartridges in the comic (except with the venom suit) and he was never able to stop a train. Spiderman 2 was really pushing it with Peters abilities. I think this reboot did a better job portraying spiderman. And Toby wins.

That's the only exception. Web Cartridges.

Other than that, Andrew's Spiderman was closer to the rebooted comic version. Meaning weaker...

Tobey was pretty much classic Spiderman with the exception of not having web cartridges.

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez: Full strength Toby was in Spider-Man 2, when he was taking out Doc Ock ...... that movie was better than any Spider-Man movie so far ....... so he wins

I saw Amazing Spider-Man today though, he was good but not that good ..... Toby stopped a train Andrew got shot in the leg ...... fail

i saw it too.pretty cool and we are using the both the first movies

First movie spiderman wasn't that great ... but he was still stronger, held the tram car full of children with one arm ....... and he found Uncle Ben's killer and dealt with him, unlike Andrew ........

That wasn't uncle Ben's killer he doesn't fine the real killer until Spider man 3 and the real killer is sandman

But in Andrew's movie, it blatantly shows the other guy shoot Ben.

Yeah i know,but they said in part one that Toby's spider man found uncle Ben 's killer even though that dude wasn't the killer.It was Sandman.

He might as well be the killer because Sandman was forced to push the trigger right after his partner bumped into him.

He still pull the trigger and sandman even admitted he shot him but it was an accented,but still murdered him

That's true, but he wouldn't have pulled the trigger if his partner didn't bump into his arm. Anyway, Tobey has far greater feats than Andrew. He heals fast, is far stronger able to dead stop what appeared to be a 40 ton steel wall and toss it aside like paper. Has incredible durability which he was able to take a pumpkin grenade to the face and not bleed and tanked several tons of pressure between his webs and a speeding train. Have Giant Sandman pound the sh1t out off him while Venom was holding him down. He's reaction timing and Spider Sense were far superior than Andrew's which enables him almost pre-cognition and sees dangerous situations in slow motion. Tobey was pretty much the comic Spider-Man with some modifications.

I'm using Toby Maguire from the first Spider Man movie.Its a Movie 1 vs Movie 1 debate.To me Andrew presented more swiftness in his speed in the films,but yeah i guess Toby went through tougher opstacles,but Andrew was more acrobatic, and his skill with his webs shooters were outstanding...Spider senses are a little off though.

Tobey can jump 60 feet off the ground too. Andrew can jump 10 to 15 feet off the ground (basket ball scene)

I'm pretty sure Andrew jumped higher in other senses,but i kinda forgot the movie lol.Andrew faced a tougher and smarter enemy.Movie Lizard would own Movie Green Goblin.

Dude, Norman would destroy Lizard. If Tobey can take Lizard easily, Goblin can too. And Connar is not smarter than Otto and Norman. Conner only specialized in biology. Norman specialized in biology, mechanics, and war strategy.

@Magethor said:

@CapitolPunishment said:

Actually they tried pulling off "comic spiderman here". Peter always used Web cartridges in the comic (except with the venom suit) and he was never able to stop a train. Spiderman 2 was really pushing it with Peters abilities. I think this reboot did a better job portraying spiderman. And Toby wins.

That's the only exception. Web Cartridges.

Other than that, Andrew's Spiderman was closer to the rebooted comic version. Meaning weaker...

Tobey was pretty much classic Spiderman with the exception of not having web cartridges.

I don't see him being weaker then Tobey.The only thing is,he can run of webs but his strength and speed didn't prove him to be weak.He took on a faster and more durable enemy and The Lizard was getting hit in face and feeling Andrew hits...The original Amazing Fantasy and The Amazing Spider comics in the 60's,he didn't have organic webs but i could be wrong but i agree Tobey suit is much more like the original Spidey suit.

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@CapitolPunishment said:

Actually they tried pulling off "comic spiderman here". Peter always used Web cartridges in the comic (except with the venom suit) and he was never able to stop a train. Spiderman 2 was really pushing it with Peters abilities. I think this reboot did a better job portraying spiderman. And Toby wins.

That's the only exception. Web Cartridges.

Other than that, Andrew's Spiderman was closer to the rebooted comic version. Meaning weaker...

Tobey was pretty much classic Spiderman with the exception of not having web cartridges.

I don't see him being weaker then Tobey.The only thing is,he can run of webs but his strength and speed didn't prove him to be weak.He took on a faster and more durable enemy and The Lizard was getting hit in face and feeling Andrew hits...The original Amazing Fantasy and The Amazing Spider comics in the 60's,he didn't have organic webs but i could be wrong but i agree Tobey suit is much more like the original Spidey suit.

Yes, but when Andrew was getting hit by the Lizard, he was bruising up pretty badly. But when Tobey's face meets the explosion of a pumpkin bomb, all it did was tear off his mask while Tobey's face was fine.

1st 30 seconds

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez: Full strength Toby was in Spider-Man 2, when he was taking out Doc Ock ...... that movie was better than any Spider-Man movie so far ....... so he wins

I saw Amazing Spider-Man today though, he was good but not that good ..... Toby stopped a train Andrew got shot in the leg ...... fail

i saw it too.pretty cool and we are using the both the first movies

First movie spiderman wasn't that great ... but he was still stronger, held the tram car full of children with one arm ....... and he found Uncle Ben's killer and dealt with him, unlike Andrew ........

That wasn't uncle Ben's killer he doesn't fine the real killer until Spider man 3 and the real killer is sandman

But in Andrew's movie, it blatantly shows the other guy shoot Ben.

Yeah i know,but they said in part one that Toby's spider man found uncle Ben 's killer even though that dude wasn't the killer.It was Sandman.

He might as well be the killer because Sandman was forced to push the trigger right after his partner bumped into him.

He still pull the trigger and sandman even admitted he shot him but it was an accented,but still murdered him

That's true, but he wouldn't have pulled the trigger if his partner didn't bump into his arm. Anyway, Tobey has far greater feats than Andrew. He heals fast, is far stronger able to dead stop what appeared to be a 40 ton steel wall and toss it aside like paper. Has incredible durability which he was able to take a pumpkin grenade to the face and not bleed and tanked several tons of pressure between his webs and a speeding train. Have Giant Sandman pound the sh1t out off him while Venom was holding him down. He's reaction timing and Spider Sense were far superior than Andrew's which enables him almost pre-cognition and sees dangerous situations in slow motion. Tobey was pretty much the comic Spider-Man with some modifications.

I'm using Toby Maguire from the first Spider Man movie.Its a Movie 1 vs Movie 1 debate.To me Andrew presented more swiftness in his speed in the films,but yeah i guess Toby went through tougher opstacles,but Andrew was more acrobatic, and his skill with his webs shooters were outstanding...Spider senses are a little off though.

Tobey can jump 60 feet off the ground too. Andrew can jump 10 to 15 feet off the ground (basket ball scene)

I'm pretty sure Andrew jumped higher in other senses,but i kinda forgot the movie lol.Andrew faced a tougher and smarter enemy.Movie Lizard would own Movie Green Goblin.

Dude, Norman would destroy Lizard. If Tobey can take Lizard easily, Goblin can too. And Connar is not smarter than Otto and Norman. Conner only specialized in biology. Norman specialized in biology, mechanics, and war strategy.

Norman holding a train or what ever with children in it is some what a good feat,but its debatable..Dude the Lizard durability and speed in the movie out matches Normans feats.The only thing that really did major damage was his tech and weapons,but i agree with you with him being smarter.

I hate Tobey Maguire.

Wait a second, when did Spiderman use web shooters? Every incarnation I seen, he just does it...did I miss a memo or something?

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@CapitolPunishment said:

Actually they tried pulling off "comic spiderman here". Peter always used Web cartridges in the comic (except with the venom suit) and he was never able to stop a train. Spiderman 2 was really pushing it with Peters abilities. I think this reboot did a better job portraying spiderman. And Toby wins.

That's the only exception. Web Cartridges.

Other than that, Andrew's Spiderman was closer to the rebooted comic version. Meaning weaker...

Tobey was pretty much classic Spiderman with the exception of not having web cartridges.

I don't see him being weaker then Tobey.The only thing is,he can run of webs but his strength and speed didn't prove him to be weak.He took on a faster and more durable enemy and The Lizard was getting hit in face and feeling Andrew hits...The original Amazing Fantasy and The Amazing Spider comics in the 60's,he didn't have organic webs but i could be wrong but i agree Tobey suit is much more like the original Spidey suit.

Yes, but when Andrew was getting hit by the Lizard, he was bruising up pretty badly. But when Tobey's face meets the explosion of a pumpkin bomb, all it did was tear off his mask while Tobey's face was fine.

1st 30 seconds

He got weaker when the bomb blew up in his face and Goblin was owning him

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@CapitolPunishment said:

Actually they tried pulling off "comic spiderman here". Peter always used Web cartridges in the comic (except with the venom suit) and he was never able to stop a train. Spiderman 2 was really pushing it with Peters abilities. I think this reboot did a better job portraying spiderman. And Toby wins.

That's the only exception. Web Cartridges.

Other than that, Andrew's Spiderman was closer to the rebooted comic version. Meaning weaker...

Tobey was pretty much classic Spiderman with the exception of not having web cartridges.

I don't see him being weaker then Tobey.The only thing is,he can run of webs but his strength and speed didn't prove him to be weak.He took on a faster and more durable enemy and The Lizard was getting hit in face and feeling Andrew hits...The original Amazing Fantasy and The Amazing Spider comics in the 60's,he didn't have organic webs but i could be wrong but i agree Tobey suit is much more like the original Spidey suit.

Tobey stopped a 40 ton steel wall (or more tons) than Andrew... The original Spiderman in comics is strong enough to lift up to 40 tons. Like so.

Skip this video to 1:46:40

Watch the steel wall fall on Mary Jane.

@Wolfrazer said:

Wait a second, when did Spiderman use web shooters? Every incarnation I seen, he just does it...did I miss a memo or something?

Since 1962.

@Wolfrazer said:

Wait a second, when did Spiderman use web shooters? Every incarnation I seen, he just does it...did I miss a memo or something?

In the original 1960's The Amazing Spider comics he was using Web Cartridges right?..i haven't read the original's in so long.

@Wolfrazer said:

Wait a second, when did Spiderman use web shooters? Every incarnation I seen, he just does it...did I miss a memo or something?

In the original 1960's The Amazing Spider comics he was using Web Cartridges right?..i haven't read the original's in so long.

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Magethor said:

@CapitolPunishment said:

Actually they tried pulling off "comic spiderman here". Peter always used Web cartridges in the comic (except with the venom suit) and he was never able to stop a train. Spiderman 2 was really pushing it with Peters abilities. I think this reboot did a better job portraying spiderman. And Toby wins.

That's the only exception. Web Cartridges.

Other than that, Andrew's Spiderman was closer to the rebooted comic version. Meaning weaker...

Tobey was pretty much classic Spiderman with the exception of not having web cartridges.

I don't see him being weaker then Tobey.The only thing is,he can run of webs but his strength and speed didn't prove him to be weak.He took on a faster and more durable enemy and The Lizard was getting hit in face and feeling Andrew hits...The original Amazing Fantasy and The Amazing Spider comics in the 60's,he didn't have organic webs but i could be wrong but i agree Tobey suit is much more like the original Spidey suit.

Tobey stopped a 40 ton steel wall (or more tons) than Andrew... The original Spiderman in comics is strong enough to lift up to 40 tons. Like so.

Skip this video to 1:46:40

Watch the steel wall fall on Mary Jane.

"The original Spiderman in comics is strong enough to lift up to 40 tons. Like so." I hope you know their both Spider-Man and this is a movie 1 vs movie 1 debate.

@Wolfrazer said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Wolfrazer said:

Wait a second, when did Spiderman use web shooters? Every incarnation I seen, he just does it...did I miss a memo or something?

In the original 1960's The Amazing Spider comics he was using Web Cartridges right?..i haven't read the original's in so long.

:/ Well thats kinda lame, seems fitting he would just be able to shoot webs all by himself.

I'm a fan of the organic web shooting but ever sense i read 1960's the amazing spider comics and saw the amazing spider man i'm a fan of the web cartridges..kinda sucked that he ran out though...

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Wolfrazer said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Wolfrazer said:

Wait a second, when did Spiderman use web shooters? Every incarnation I seen, he just does it...did I miss a memo or something?

In the original 1960's The Amazing Spider comics he was using Web Cartridges right?..i haven't read the original's in so long.

:/ Well thats kinda lame, seems fitting he would just be able to shoot webs all by himself.

I'm a fan of the organic web shooting but ever sense i read 1960's the amazing spider comics and saw the amazing spider man i'm a fan of the web cartridges..kinda sucked that he ran out though...

When they changed his webs into organic webs somewhere in the late 90's or early 2000's, Marvel stated that the Cartridge Webs were stronger and more versatile.

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

Skip this video to 1:46:40

Watch the steel wall fall on Mary Jane.

"The original Spiderman in comics is strong enough to lift up to 40 tons. Like so." I hope you know their both Spider-Man and this is a movie 1 vs movie 1 debate.

They are different. The video above shows it that Tobey is superior. They watered down the Garfield version.

spider-man has had web shooters for most of his career. and i think toby would probably win a fight. but i did love the new movie. 

The new movie was bomb don't get me wrong, but Tobey is still superior because the director stuck with the original Spiderman feats and implied them onto Tobey's movies. Save for the webs..

spidey has been classified as a 10 tonner for as long as i can remember. except when he was possessed by captain universe and had the iron spider suit. 

@Magethor said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Wolfrazer said:

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

@Wolfrazer said:

Wait a second, when did Spiderman use web shooters? Every incarnation I seen, he just does it...did I miss a memo or something?

In the original 1960's The Amazing Spider comics he was using Web Cartridges right?..i haven't read the original's in so long.

:/ Well thats kinda lame, seems fitting he would just be able to shoot webs all by himself.

I'm a fan of the organic web shooting but ever sense i read 1960's the amazing spider comics and saw the amazing spider man i'm a fan of the web cartridges..kinda sucked that he ran out though...

When they changed his webs into organic webs somewhere in the late 90's or early 2000's, Marvel stated that the Cartridge Webs were stronger and more versatile.

@Sci_Fi_Rulez said:

Skip this video to 1:46:40

Watch the steel wall fall on Mary Jane.

"The original Spiderman in comics is strong enough to lift up to 40 tons. Like so." I hope you know their both Spider-Man and this is a movie 1 vs movie 1 debate.

They are different. The video above shows it that Tobey is superior. They watered down the Garfield version.

see then Andrew's web is more tougher then Tobeys then?...This is only a movie 1 vs movie 1 debate which they're only using the feats in the first films.

Basic it only on the first movies, Toby wins. Andrew just lacks feats.