Sylar vs Magneto

This is Magneto from First Class. Battle takes place in the city. Battle is won by death or KO. Who wins and why.

Round 1- Takes place on the beach from the end of X-Men First Class.(Same scenario with the humans ready to bomb to beach.) Season 1 Sylar

Round 2- Takes place on the beach from the end of X-Men First Class.(Same scenario with the humans ready to bomb to beach.) Season 3 Sylar

Which version of Sylar, because that really decides the outcome. FutureSylar with illusions, flight, healing, etc.? Future Sylar with S1 and S3 powers? S1 Sylar? S3 Sylar? S4 Sylar?

@The_Imperator said:

Which version of Sylar, because that really decides the outcome. FutureSylar with illusions, flight, healing, etc.? Future Sylar with S1 and S3 powers? S1 Sylar? S3 Sylar? S4 Sylar?

True but I'd say any sylar takes the majority

@AllStarSuperman: Nah, I'd give it to both future Sylar's, but S1 Sylar isn't going to be able to do it, unless he goes straight for something other than TK. S3 and S4 probably could, though.

@The_Imperator: season 1 sylar us still powerful I don't remember how much or what powers he had exactly

@AllStarSuperman: While he seemed more competent than most other versions of Sylar, he seemed to just... not ever use his power to its fullest. But maybe he could.

I know that Michael Fassbender is a lot hotter :D

@The_Imperator: correct me if I'm wrong but wasn't he the most ruthless

@AllStarSuperman: Point. I haven't seen S1 in forever, so I could be totally off base with my analysis.

@The_Imperator: well I could be wrong to I've only watched threw the show once. But my best friend always talks about it. And hes watch like 4+ times

@The_Imperator said:

Which version of Sylar, because that really decides the outcome. FutureSylar with illusions, flight, healing, etc.? Future Sylar with S1 and S3 powers? S1 Sylar? S3 Sylar? S4 Sylar?

I'll edit it and do it that way thanks.

Season 4 Sylar is a good guy, and never went all out with his powers in his one showing. I might give it to Magneto in this case.

bump changed the scenarios made them better

bump

Ok Sylar takes this instantly.

Sylar has
Intuitive Aptitude

• Telekinesis from Brian Davis (Six Months Ago)
• Freezing from James Walker (Don't Look Back)
• Melting from Zane Taylor (Run!)
• Enhanced hearing from Dale Smither (Unexpected)
• Precognition from Isaac Mendez (.07%)
• Induced radioactivity from Ted Sprague (Landslide)
• enhanced memory from Charlie Andrews (Seven Minutes to Midnight)

He can melt any metal that Magneto uses against him, Telekinesis as a force field (Shown to use it for Bullets in this way) and simply freeze everything or uses his radioactivity to mess with the magnetic fields Eric controls. As it controls the Electromagnetic Spectrum.

I still don't think it'll be that easy.

Can you explain why?

edited the first post

@perpetr8rmike: what if magneto threw something the size of a submarine at him. He couldnt just melt that away

Sylar has shown he can use his telekinesis to hover effortlessly and later used it to mimic flying short periods. He could simply dodge it while using enough force to slow it down. He has used it on multiple targets all at the same time. In fact when he first meets peter he uses it to list dozens of glass shards and sends them flying in all directions to catch peter showing his fine motor control with it. He has shown flipping a full speed Semi on its back and stopping it from skidding into him.

Also in Season three he has

• Rapid cellular regeneration from Claire Bennet (The Second Coming)
• Alchemy from Bob Bishop (The Butterfly Effect)
• Clairsentience from Bridget Bailey (One of Us, One of Them)
• Sound manipulation from Jesse Murphy (One of Us, One of Them)
• Electric manipulation from Elle Bishop (It's Coming)
• Lie detection from Sue Landers (Our Father)
• Imprinting from Joe Macon (Out of Town... On Business)
• Shape shifting from James Martin (Into Asylum)
• Disintegration from Tom Miller (I Am Sylar)
• Flight from Nathan Petrelli (An Invisible Thread)
  
  On top of his original ability and Telekinesis.