Supergirl runs the gauntlet

Stops at Power Girl.

@citizenbane: You do realize Superman only beat Supergirl while she was controlled by Darkseid because he used a Kryptonite ring, right? Did you bother to read the comic?

2 months ago.....

2 months later.....

Touched as I am by your time-spanning concern for my Supergirl awareness, rest assured that I was aware of that.

Just as I was aware of the fact that the kryptonite was affecting Superman as well.

Superman would beat the tar out of Supergirl. His quantifiable feats are better in every possible way, and the only writer who's ever differed from that opinion was Loeb.

Feel free to reply 4 months from now.

Power Girl

Stops at Wonder Woman.

BTW that scan of Blackfire stating Supergirl is stronger than Superman is complete bullcrap.

Superman has already stomped her.

I'll stick to Pre New 52 Supergirl in my judgement.

Wonder Girl - Supergirl outclasses her in every way

Donna Troy - She got killed by a Superman robot. Even if she got stronger, Kara's still her superior.

Starfire - Her starbolts wouldn't be much use against Supergirl and physically she's outclassed.

Power Girl - The first real challenge. Karen has the potential to beat Kara her based on feats against Wonder Woman and other powerhouses

Wonder Woman - If she does get past Power Girl she won't beat Wonder Woman. Diana's stronger, faster, has better reaction times and is more skilled. Too many advantages to cope with if the lasso comes in as well.

4 or 5

Stops at Wonder Woman

Powergirl. She's basically a more powerful Supergirl.

hasn't she lost to and beaten all these characters before?

Wonder Woman beats her this fight