#1 Posted by symbiote5 (2183 posts) - - Show Bio

who takes it it would be great fight

#2 Posted by Apile-Li (61 posts) - - Show Bio

You know how comic book writers are,they would make Cap win

or Spidey win

#3 Posted by Resonate (15054 posts) - - Show Bio

Apile-Li says:

"You know how comic book writers are,they would make Cap win or Spidey win"

You are master of the obvious, young sir

#4 Posted by The_Martian (36984 posts) - - Show Bio

Apile-Li says:

"You know how comic book writers are,they would make Cap win or Spidey win"
This is the greatest statement ever made in a Battle Thread.
#5 Posted by White Phantom (1760 posts) - - Show Bio

Apile-Li says:

"You know how comic book writers are,they would make Cap winor Spidey win"

OK, that's just too good! You do know what you said don't you?

#6 Posted by Sparda (15795 posts) - - Show Bio

Apile-Li says:

"You know how comic book writers are,they would make Cap winor Spidey win"

AHAHA! OMG........kudos to you sir, kudos.

#7 Posted by Apparition (11349 posts) - - Show Bio

lol

#8 Posted by Vance Astro (91404 posts) - - Show Bio

Apile-Li says:

"Resonate says:
"Apile-Li says:
"You know how comic book writers are,they would make Cap win or Spidey win"
You are master of the obvious, young sir"
Your point?"

You didn't actually give an answer.Your post implies that either character could win but the point was to choose one.

Moderator
#9 Posted by Vance Astro (91404 posts) - - Show Bio

Colt Python says:

"Apile-Li f#cked up real bad with his statement.Anyone else who comes in this thread...you don't have to acknowledge that he did."

LMFAO!

Moderator
#10 Posted by Apile-Li (61 posts) - - Show Bio

Resonate says:

"Apile-Li says:
"You know how comic book writers are,they would make Cap win or Spidey win"
You are master of the obvious, young sir"

Your point?

#11 Posted by Vance Astro (91404 posts) - - Show Bio

Alexander Anderson says:

"Spider-Man, realistically. If Peter goes all 'maximum spider' on him, there's nothing much Cap can do about it."

Iunno about that.Cap is a really really really good fighter.He and Black Panther are well known for beating people who outclass them physically.They know so much about fighting that it's hard to defend or offend against them because they know a ton of attacks and counters.That shield put Hulk on his ass and Cap knows so many trick with it to hitting people.I think this fight could go either way.

Moderator
#12 Posted by Alexander Anderson (4030 posts) - - Show Bio

Spider-Man, realistically. If Peter goes all 'maximum spider' on him, there's nothing much Cap can do about it.

#13 Posted by Vance Astro (91404 posts) - - Show Bio

Alexander Anderson says:

"Vance Astro says:
"Alexander Anderson says:
"Spider-Man, realistically. If Peter goes all 'maximum spider' on him, there's nothing much Cap can do about it."
Iunno about that.Cap is a really really really good fighter.He and Black Panther are well known for beating people who outclass them physically.They know so much about fighting that it's hard to defend or offend against them because they know a ton of attacks and counters.That shield put Hulk on his ass and Cap knows so many trick with it to hitting people.I think this fight could go either way."
In a comic, it certainly could go either way (and was pretty inconclusive in Civil War, as I recall). But if Peter completely cuts loose and uses his speed, strength, agility and webbing to their full potential, I don't think Cap would be able to keep up with him. Peter is constantly doubting himself and pulling his punches; when he gets over his mental blocks, he becomes a one-man wrecking crew."

Against the Kingpin maybe.This is Captain America where talking about.

Moderator
#14 Posted by Alexander Anderson (4030 posts) - - Show Bio

Vance Astro says:

"Alexander Anderson says:
"Spider-Man, realistically. If Peter goes all 'maximum spider' on him, there's nothing much Cap can do about it."

Iunno about that.Cap is a really really really good fighter.He and Black Panther are well known for beating people who outclass them physically.They know so much about fighting that it's hard to defend or offend against them because they know a ton of attacks and counters.That shield put Hulk on his ass and Cap knows so many trick with it to hitting people.I think this fight could go either way."

In a comic, it certainly could go either way (and was pretty inconclusive in Civil War, as I recall). But if Peter completely cuts loose and uses his speed, strength, agility and webbing to their full potential, I don't think Cap would be able to keep up with him. Peter is constantly doubting himself and pulling his punches; when he gets over his mental blocks, he becomes a one-man wrecking crew.

#15 Posted by Alexander Anderson (4030 posts) - - Show Bio

Spider-Man could break Cap's bones like toothpicks if he wanted to. He can take away the shield, web him down and punch him until his organs turn to jelly. He's more agile, faster, and although he's not skilled in conventional martial arts he's developed a personal fighting style that perfectly compliments his powers. Cap is good, but he's never faced a fully unleashed Spider-Man. Firelord has. He got beaten senseless.

#16 Posted by Vance Astro (91404 posts) - - Show Bio

Alexander Anderson says:

"Spider-Man could break Cap's bones like toothpicks if he wanted to. He can take away the shield, web him down and punch him until his organs turn to jelly. He's more agile, faster, and although he's not skilled in conventional martial arts he's developed a personal fighting style that perfectly compliments his powers. Cap is good, but he's never faced a fully unleashed Spider-Man. Firelord has. He got beaten senseless."

Most people think Spider-man beating Firelord was bad writing.

Moderator
#17 Posted by Alexander Anderson (4030 posts) - - Show Bio

I do too. But the fact remains that Peter is fully capable of murdering Captain America.

#18 Posted by The_Martian (36984 posts) - - Show Bio

Alexander Anderson says:

"Spider-Man could break Cap's bones like toothpicks if he wanted to. He can take away the shield, web him down and punch him until his organs turn to jelly. He's more agile, faster, and although he's not skilled in conventional martial arts he's developed a personal fighting style that perfectly compliments his powers. Cap is good, but he's never faced a fully unleashed Spider-Man. Firelord has. He got beaten senseless."
Although I agree Spidey beats Cap easily, Spider-Man can't be Firelord.
#19 Posted by Vance Astro (91404 posts) - - Show Bio

SEXUAL SEDUCTION.

Moderator
#20 Posted by Vance Astro (91404 posts) - - Show Bio

Nobody says:

"Vance Astro says:
"SEXUAL SEDUCTION."
What? "

Iunno I just said the first thing that came to mind and that damn Snoop Dogg video was on with the fruity dancing and the voice machine (sexual seduction).

Moderator
#21 Posted by Alexander Anderson (4030 posts) - - Show Bio

Vance Astro says:

"SEXUAL SEDUCTION."

Well that certainly takes it in a new and disturbing direction...

#22 Posted by King Saturn (225088 posts) - - Show Bio

Sexual Seduction is an awesome song by Snoop Dogg.

#23 Posted by Vance Astro (91404 posts) - - Show Bio

Alexander Anderson says:

"Vance Astro says:
"SEXUAL SEDUCTION."
Well that certainly takes it in a new and disturbing direction... "

Sexual Seduction is how Cap wins.

Moderator
#24 Posted by The_Martian (36984 posts) - - Show Bio

Vance Astro says:

"SEXUAL SEDUCTION."
What?
#25 Posted by Apile-Li (61 posts) - - Show Bio

Vance Astro says:

"Apile-Li says:
"Resonate says:
"Apile-Li says:
"You know how comic book writers are,they would make Cap win or Spidey win"
You are master of the obvious, young sir"
Your point?"
You didn't actually give an answer.Your post implies that either character could win but the point was to choose one."

That is because there are 2 sides to a story,you should know that by now

#26 Posted by Noir_Dark (861 posts) - - Show Bio

Apile-Li says:

"You know how comic book writers are,they would make Cap winor Spidey win"

You just ended every VS. thread on the Vine.

#27 Posted by Apile-Li (61 posts) - - Show Bio

Noir_Dark says:

"Apile-Li says:
"You know how comic book writers are,they would make Cap win or Spidey win"
You just ended every VS. thread on the Vine. "

Sorry to hear that

#28 Posted by Apile-Li (61 posts) - - Show Bio

White Phantom says:

"Apile-Li says:
"You know how comic book writers are,they would make Cap win or Spidey win"
OK, that's just too good! You do know what you said don't you? "

Yeah last time I checked

#29 Posted by Methos (40103 posts) - - Show Bio

i'd have to give this one to Spidey realistically...

he outclasses Cap in speed, strength, agility and intelligence...

while Cap's experience may help out a bit, i don't think it's going to be enough to take down Spidey

M

#30 Posted by Eternal Chaos (22990 posts) - - Show Bio

Ugh. I hate when people bring this battle up so many times. And guess what you retard, this was done before, check the damn battle thread. Is that so complicated?

Anyway, Peter wins this, hands down.

#31 Posted by Forever (4332 posts) - - Show Bio

Eternal Chaos says:

"Ugh. I hate when people bring this battle up so many times. And guess what you retard, this was done before, check the damn battle thread. Is that so complicated? Anyway, Peter wins this, hands down."

You are correct all the way around, except in calling him a retard. That's not needed.

#32 Posted by Apile-Li (61 posts) - - Show Bio

Resonate says:

"Apile-Li says:
"You know how comic book writers are,they would make Cap win or Spidey win"
You are master of the obvious, young sir"

Thanks-I guess

#33 Posted by Apile-Li (61 posts) - - Show Bio

Vance Astro says:

"Colt Python says:
"Apile-Li f#cked up real bad with his statement.Anyone else who comes in this thread...you don't have to acknowledge that he did."
LMFAO!"

No they don't and that includes you

#34 Posted by aloe vera (283 posts) - - Show Bio

Pete would probably win, he has more speed and seems smarter than captain too

but at the same time captain america can fight an army of people so yeah...

but in the end it seems like spiderman wins

ughh now everytime i hear the name spiderman

im tempted to say: "spiderpig spiderpig does whatever a spiderpig does..." lol

#35 Posted by POHOCOM (807 posts) - - Show Bio

SPIDER-MAN BEATING FIRELORD WAS ONE OF THE WORST TRAVESTIES IN THE HISTORY OF COMIC BOOK BATTLES. FIRELORD'S BODY TEMPERATURE CAN MELT BULLETS BEFORE THEY TOUCH HIM! SPIDER-MAN WOULD HAVE BEEN SEVERELY BURNED AFTER ONE PUNCH. ALSO, FIRELORD HAS TAKEN PUNCHES FROM THE MIGHTY THOR. REMEMBER, AS A HERALD OF GALACTUS FIRELORD'S BODY WAS CREATED TO SURVIVE THE RIGORS & TRAUMA OF OUTERSPACE, LIGHT SPEED TRAVEL, AND THE CRUSHING GRAVITY OF EVEN BLACKHOLES! EVEN IF SPIDER-MAN COULD TOUCH HIM, HE REALISTICALLY COULD NOT STOP FIRELORD.

AFTER ALL OF THE RESEARCH PUT INTO CREATING THE ORIGINAL OFFICIAL HANDBOOK OF THE MARVEL UNIVERSE VOLUMES, ITS UNFORTUNATE THAT, EVERY NOW & THEN, WRITERS ARE PERMITTED TO COMPLETELY IGNORE THE ABILITIES OF CHARACTERS. AS FOR CAP VS SPIDEY, IVE SEEN THEM FACE OFF AT LEAST 4 TIMES. CAP EASILY BEAT SPIDEY TWICE, THE OTHER 2 ENCOUNTERS WERE BRIEF AND INCONCLUSIVE. I'D PUT MY MONEY ON CAP TO BEAT ALMOST ANY CHARACTER AT OR BELOW THE 10 TON LEVEL OF STRENGTH IN A NO HOLDS BARRED PHYSICAL FIGHT. (AS LONG AS THE OPPONENT IS NOT BULLET PROOF).

#36 Posted by Apparition (11349 posts) - - Show Bio

POHOCOM says:

"SPIDER-MAN BEATING FIRELORD WAS ONE OF THE WORST TRAVESTIES IN THE HISTORY OF COMIC BOOK BATTLES. FIRELORD'S BODY TEMPERATURE CAN MELT BULLETS BEFORE THEY TOUCH HIM! SPIDER-MAN WOULD HAVE BEEN SEVERELY BURNED AFTER ONE PUNCH. ALSO, FIRELORD HAS TAKEN PUNCHES FROM THE MIGHTY THOR. REMEMBER, AS A HERALD OF GALACTUS FIRELORD'S BODY WAS CREATED TO SURVIVE THE RIGORS & TRAUMA OF OUTERSPACE, LIGHT SPEED TRAVEL, AND THE CRUSHING GRAVITY OF EVEN BLACKHOLES! EVEN IF SPIDER-MAN COULD TOUCH HIM, HE REALISTICALLY COULD NOT STOP FIRELORD. AFTER ALL OF THE RESEARCH PUT INTO CREATING THE ORIGINAL OFFICIAL HANDBOOK OF THE MARVEL UNIVERSE VOLUMES, ITS UNFORTUNATE THAT, EVERY NOW & THEN, WRITERS ARE PERMITTED TO COMPLETELY IGNORE THE ABILITIES OF CHARACTERS. AS FOR CAP VS SPIDEY, IVE SEEN THEM FACE OFF AT LEAST 4 TIMES. CAP EASILY BEAT SPIDEY TWICE, THE OTHER 2 ENCOUNTERS WERE BRIEF AND INCONCLUSIVE. I'D PUT MY MONEY ON CAP TO BEAT ALMOST ANY CHARACTER AT OR BELOW THE 10 TON LEVEL OF STRENGTH IN A NO HOLDS BARRED PHYSICAL FIGHT. (AS LONG AS THE OPPONENT IS NOT BULLET PROOF). "

must you write in all caps?

#37 Posted by Amplitudo (215 posts) - - Show Bio

Captain America. I don't know how, but I'm a big fan of his and am immune to logic in cases like these.

#38 Posted by POHOCOM (807 posts) - - Show Bio

SPIDER-MAN IS CERTAINLY CAPABLE OF GIVING CAPTAIN AMERICA A VERY TOUGH FIGHT IF BOTH MEN WENT ALL OUT. BUT, OTHER THAN WOLVERINE, HOW OFTEN HAVE WE SEEN ANY SUPERHERO GO ALL OUT? SPIDER-MAN HAS THE SPEED, INTELLECT, & STRENGTH & WEAPONS TO BEAT CAP. HOWEVER, PEOPLE CONTINUE TO OVERLOOK THE INTANGIBLES THAT MAKE CAPTAIN AMERICA "THE ULTIMATE HUMAN COMBATANT". CAP'S TENACITY, RESOURCEFULNESS, CONFIDENCE, AND EXPERIENCE ARE ALL FAR BEYOND SPIDEY'S AND MOST OTHER CHARACTERS. THAT'S WHY IN NATURE SOME ANIMALS LIKE BADGERS, BOBCATS AND WOLVERINES, CAN OFTEN DRIVE OFF AND EVEN INJURE LARGER PREDATORS LIKE WOLVES AND BEARS.

COMBINE THAT WITH FIGHTING SKILLS MATCHED BY VERY FEW CHARACTERS IN COMICS, AND IT'S EASIER TO SEE WHY CAP BEATS SPIDEY.

#39 Posted by Orifiel (123 posts) - - Show Bio

HHmmm as much as I love Captain America, I would have to say Spiderman.

#40 Posted by The_Martian (36984 posts) - - Show Bio

POHOCOM says:

"SPIDER-MAN IS CERTAINLY CAPABLE OF GIVING CAPTAIN AMERICA A VERY TOUGH FIGHT IF BOTH MEN WENT ALL OUT. BUT, OTHER THAN WOLVERINE, HOW OFTEN HAVE WE SEEN ANY SUPERHERO GO ALL OUT? SPIDER-MAN HAS THE SPEED, INTELLECT, & STRENGTH & WEAPONS TO BEAT CAP. HOWEVER, PEOPLE CONTINUE TO OVERLOOK THE INTANGIBLES THAT MAKE CAPTAIN AMERICA "THE ULTIMATE HUMAN COMBATANT". CAP'S TENACITY, RESOURCEFULNESS, CONFIDENCE, AND EXPERIENCE ARE ALL FAR BEYOND SPIDEY'S AND MOST OTHER CHARACTERS. THAT'S WHY IN NATURE SOME ANIMALS LIKE BADGERS, BOBCATS AND WOLVERINES, CAN OFTEN DRIVE OFF AND EVEN INJURE LARGER PREDATORS LIKE WOLVES AND BEARS. COMBINE THAT WITH FIGHTING SKILLS MATCHED BY VERY FEW CHARACTERS IN COMICS, AND IT'S EASIER TO SEE WHY CAP BEATS SPIDEY."
THANKS FOR THE INFO. WELCOME TO THE VINE.
#41 Posted by Ryo (17 posts) - - Show Bio

Well these 2 heroes have fought each other in the Marvel Civil

Wars whatever....and in that comic Spider-Man had a crappy outfit made by Tony Stork.Ok putting that aside Cap and Spidey

went of at each other trading blows (yes at close range) and Captian America managed to punch Spidey three times while Spidey managed to punch Cap once.Spidey then said (I think)

This guys moves very fast and he is hard to keep up with due to him military skills.I better keep my distance since it is not a good idea to fight him at close range".

Sharp tentectales came out of Spidey's back (like Dr.Octopus)

and cut Cap in the face.Captian America then made an exit and ran away leaping from building to building.

If only these 2 had a rematch then we would see who owns who?

Spider-Man (Marvel's famous) or Captian America (Marvel's legend).

#42 Posted by Apile-Li (61 posts) - - Show Bio

Vance Astro says:

"Apile-Li says:
"Resonate says:
"Apile-Li says:
"You know how comic book writers are,they would make Cap win or Spidey win"
You are master of the obvious, young sir"
Your point?"
You didn't actually give an answer.Your post implies that either character could win but the point was to choose one."

Oh...

#43 Posted by Apile-Li (61 posts) - - Show Bio

Ryo says:

"Well these 2 heroes have fought each other in the Marvel Civil Wars whatever....and in that comic Spider-Man had a crappy outfit made by Tony Stork.Ok putting that aside Cap and Spidey went of at each other trading blows (yes at close range) and Captian America managed to punch Spidey three times while Spidey managed to punch Cap once.Spidey then said (I think) This guys moves very fast and he is hard to keep up with due to him military skills.I better keep my distance since it is not a good idea to fight him at close range". Sharp tentectales came out of Spidey's back (like Dr.Octopus) and cut Cap in the face.Captian America then made an exit and ran away leaping from building to building. If only these 2 had a rematch then we would see who owns who? Spider-Man (Marvel's famous) or Captian America (Marvel's legend)."

I like that.

Captian America (Marvel's legend) vs Spider-Man (Marvel's famous).

#44 Posted by Vance Astro (91404 posts) - - Show Bio

Apile-Li says:

"Vance Astro says:
"Apile-Li says:
"Resonate says:
"Apile-Li says:
"You know how comic book writers are,they would make Cap win or Spidey win"
You are master of the obvious, young sir"
Your point?"
You didn't actually give an answer.Your post implies that either character could win but the point was to choose one."
That is because there are 2 sides to a story,you should know that by now"

No there isn't.Unless the writers are writing it and there not,were deciding on it.Spider-man realistically would beat Captain America,he outclasses him greatly.

Moderator
#45 Posted by Apile-Li (61 posts) - - Show Bio

You know Ryo (cool name) that was a very short match,I know what you mean.But I've always wanted to see a rematch between the two.....I still do-no matter who wins

#46 Posted by Apile-Li (61 posts) - - Show Bio

Vance Astro says:

"Apile-Li says:
"Vance Astro says:
"Apile-Li says:
"Resonate says:
"Apile-Li says:
"You know how comic book writers are,they would make Cap win or Spidey win"
You are master of the obvious, young sir"
Your point?"
You didn't actually give an answer.Your post implies that either character could win but the point was to choose one."
That is because there are 2 sides to a story,you should know that by now"
No there isn't.Unless the writers are writing it and there not,were deciding on it.Spider-man realistically would beat Captain America,he outclasses him greatly."

Surley you can give Captian America more credit than that

#47 Posted by Vance Astro (91404 posts) - - Show Bio

Apile-Li says:

"Vance Astro says:
"Apile-Li says:
"Vance Astro says:
"Apile-Li says:
"Resonate says:
"Apile-Li says:
"You know how comic book writers are,they would make Cap win or Spidey win"
You are master of the obvious, young sir"
Your point?"
You didn't actually give an answer.Your post implies that either character could win but the point was to choose one."
That is because there are 2 sides to a story,you should know that by now"
No there isn't.Unless the writers are writing it and there not,were deciding on it.Spider-man realistically would beat Captain America,he outclasses him greatly."
Surley you can give Captian America more credit than that"

And I did but the only reason Cap would even last 5 minutes is because his level of fighting skill but he's so greatly outmatched physically that he really only has a few chance to knock Peter out before he gets broke off.

Moderator
#48 Posted by Apile-Li (61 posts) - - Show Bio

Vance Astro says:

"Apile-Li says:
"Vance Astro says:
"Apile-Li says:
"Vance Astro says:
"Apile-Li says:
"Resonate says:
"Apile-Li says:
"You know how comic book writers are,they would make Cap win or Spidey win"
You are master of the obvious, young sir"
Your point?"
You didn't actually give an answer.Your post implies that either character could win but the point was to choose one."
That is because there are 2 sides to a story,you should know that by now"
No there isn't.Unless the writers are writing it and there not,were deciding on it.Spider-man realistically would beat Captain America,he outclasses him greatly."
Surley you can give Captian America more credit than that"
And I did but the only reason Cap would even last 5 minutes is because his level of fighting skill but he's so greatly outmatched physically that he really only has a few chance to knock Peter out before he gets broke off."

Agreed (even though I hate saying this).Spider-Man would beat Captian America,he is faster,agile,stronger and has that Spider-Sense of his to warn him of any attack.Caps would put up a pretty good fight against Spidey,but in the end the wall crawler would win.

#49 Posted by POHOCOM (807 posts) - - Show Bio

Being "outclassed greatly" in strength and speed by no means suggests that Captain America could not beat Spider-Man. Ive seen Royce Gracie and other fighters defeat opponents who were not only bigger, younger & stronger, but were skilled in more forms of martial arts.

Captain America would beat Spider-Man because he is the "Ultimate Human Combatant". Advantages in speed can be neutralized by the ability to anticipate an opponents moves and the skill and experience to react appropriately. Captain America with his peak human speed and reaction time is not as fast as Spidey, but he is fast enough that his vast fighting skills and experience would be a factor. Realistically, it would not be as easy as portrayed in Civil War or when Cap decked Spidey in Amazing Spider-Man # 187, but I think i would give the fight to Cap.

#50 Posted by ulitmateninjagaidenx (2064 posts) - - Show Bio

POHOCOM says:

"Being "outclassed greatly" in strength and speed by no means suggests that Captain America could not beat Spider-Man. Ive seen Royce Gracie and other fighters defeat opponents who were not only bigger, younger & stronger, but were skilled in more forms of martial arts. Captain America would beat Spider-Man because he is the "Ultimate Human Combatant". Advantages in speed can be neutralized by the ability to anticipate an opponents moves and the skill and experience to react appropriately. Captain America with his peak human speed and reaction time is not as fast as Spidey, but he is fast enough that his vast fighting skills and experience would be a factor. Realistically, it would not be as easy as portrayed in Civil War or when Cap decked Spidey in Amazing Spider-Man # 187, but I think i would give the fight to Cap. "

same here