Spider-Man vs The Amazing Spider-Man

Now, I'm not talking about the movies, I'm talking about the versions of Spider-Man that were represented in them. What would happen if Tobey Maguire's Spidey fought Andrew Garfield's in a one-on-one fight set in the version of New York from the original trilogy? Here are a couple of ground rules:
- For starters, try not to let your opinion be biased on which movies you think are better or which actor you like more, base it on the skills they've shown and weaknesses they've shown, etc.

- Both versions of Spidey are in character
- No Prep
- Set in New York (like the first part says, although, let's say there are no civilians)

Who would win? Also, let me know if there's any information you think I still need to mention. 3...2...1... Go!

This has probably been done before.

But I'll actually go with Tobey's Spidey for now.

Tobey

Tobey Spiderman.

Well, if I may interject on my own post

Like @leo-343 said, Garfield's Spidey is smarter, he actually created his own web-shooters and demonstrated his intelligence in other scenarios. He certainly does seem to be faster considering he managed to pull people's hands away from that metal railing while Electro's electricity was moving through it rapidly as well as catching all those tubes of whatever it was at the beginning of the second movie, and dodging all those bullets from Aleksei at the beginning. Not sure about agility, but considering that he seemed to move into more abstract poses, I'd give that to him. With the webs, as far as I remember, Tobey only created lines a net and a break (for that train). Garfield did about the same, but he also used it with his speed to contain his enemies (e.g. The Lizard) and to make that slingshot at the end of the first movie to propel him out of the crane. On top of that, he's definitely more confident as Spider-Man and his Spider-Sense doesn't seem to fail as much as Tobey's did (there were multiple scenarios where it should have warned him about danger, but it didn't). In terms of Strength, I'd give that to Tobey, considering that he has shown greater physical strength.

In addition, Garfield's version seems to be a lot more resourceful.

creating his own web shooters doesn't make him smarter. tobey didn't have to create his own webshooters because he already had them. tobey seems to be a lot stronger. however, asm 2 spidey is fast as heck. that lightning feat was pure pis. he was able to outpace electricity and save other people at the same time. that is close to superman and flash level speed. since it's in the movie, it's cannon. i will give it to tobey. he was able to stop a moving train.

@christianrapper: The creators of the movie said that they gave him natural webs because they didn't think it would be possible for a teenager to create the webbing. That implies that Tobey's Spider-Man isn't as intelligent. Also, as for the train feat, that was more about his webbing. The first time he did it, they all snapped, so he added more, and afterwards, he was almost completely out. Speed is a bit more of a decisive factor than strength is.

Amazing

of course he was completely out...he stoppped a train. he also used his body and strength as well. that's one heck of a feat if u think about it. that train was completely out of control, and he stopped it without it tearing his body in 2. a train weighs hundreds of tons. the people in the train probably have a combined weight of about 10, 000 pounds, too. plus u have to count the speed that it was traveling. that strength level is even above pre brand new day peter. that lightning feat in asm2 is also way above any speed feat that the comic book spidey has done. i give it to tobey because he is more developed, and is a grown man at the time. ii's still close. in asm 2 i had no sense that spidey ever was in danger of losing any of his fights. he handled them with ease. i will give it to tobey in a close battle 6 out of 10. an argument can be made that these 2 could beat their comic book counterpart.

@christianrapper: My point about him being out is that while he is stronger, it took everything out of him for him to accomplish it.

Tobey Spider-Man.

i knew what u meant. however, the point is that he still had just stopped a train weighing many many tons moving pretty quicly. he used all of his power and strength. he did recover pretty quickly though. it's not like he was out for a couple of days.

Tobey was much stronger then Andrew and fought stronger enemies as well.

I like Tobey better, he is classic.

Garfield. Waaaaay too fast.

INB4 @monsterstomp says "Tobey couldn't even punch through Reinforced Glass"

The main reason TAS Spiderman isn't as strong as Tobey's is the same reason Ultimate Spiderman isn't as strong as regular 616 Spiderman:he's young,his powers aren't fully developed.

Ts. Neither can do sh*t to each other.

Tobey can't even knock Doc TFO and he was only human.

Garfield cracked reinforced glass, but that's it.

Regardless, both of their durability exceeds both of their damage output by a mile.

STALEMATE!

@monsterstomp said:

@foolsgold said:

INB4 @monsterstomp says "Tobey couldn't even punch through Reinforced Glass"

Ts. Neither can do sh*t to each other.

Tobey can't even knock Doc TFO and he was only human.

Garfield cracked reinforced glass, but that's it.

Regardless, both of their durability exceeds both of their damage output by a mile.

STALEMATE!

:

:/

@foolsgold: Its a sad truth.

Doctor Octopus' was given plot induced superhuman durability for the film and you know it :p

@foolsgold: :P

By resourcefulness, I mean he'd be able to think on his feet better than Tobey could, allowing him to better use the environment around him

Tobey's was stronger but Andrew's was faster.

Speed > Strength.

Tobey is the real OG. He wins by default.

@monsterstomp said:

@foolsgold said:

INB4 @monsterstomp says "Tobey couldn't even punch through Reinforced Glass"

Ts. Neither can do sh*t to each other.

Tobey can't even knock Doc TFO and he was only human.

Garfield cracked reinforced glass, but that's it.

Regardless, both of their durability exceeds both of their damage output by a mile.

STALEMATE!

Though it could be explained that Tobey was holding back, not wanting to hurt Doc to badly (Like his Comic counterpart as you know). He as other really impressive strength feats that show what he's truly capable of (*Cough* Train *Cough*). Not to mention the Durability!

It hurts every fiber of my being to say that Tobey Spider-Man wins anything. But he does... I'll admit it here...

Can someone honestly enlighten me as to why everyone says that Tobey would win? I really don't get it.

Tobey Spider-Man.

Tobey

Tobey. Better strength (train or warehouse wall) agility (saving Gwen, fight on train), h2h (fights with Harry), and durability (sandman, took an explosion to the face)

Garfield's Spidy If Tobey has black suit tobey

Tobey.

Tobey Spidey, always

Tobey is stronger, but Garfield is faster. He wins a majority.

Garfield stomps

Garfield blitzes lol

Garfield is still strong lol people act like Tobey gonna 1 shot him

Garfield's Spider-Man wins. Smarter and faster. I don't see how Tobey can win.