Smoker Vs Crocodile

Round 1

Pre TS Smoker

No Prep

Morals Off

They Know Each Other

Win By KO/Death/BFR

Round 2

Post TS Smoker

No Prep

Morals Off

They Know Each Other

Win By KO/Death/BFR

Which Cuban Cigars Smoker wins

Idk but hope this fight really happens after the time skip

@bobsayshi25: The Time Skip already happen unless there another Time Skip in the future(which is most likely).

Crocodile takes round 1

Smoker takes round 2

@homicidalmaniac: I know that I was just saying like that because we haven't seen crocodile yet unless I missed something

@ghostravage: How does Crocodile win round one? With no Haki on either side, shouldn't they stalemate? Sure, Croc has better feats, but how would it put Smoker down? I'm not factoring Smoker's weapon in round one because Crocodile is too smart to get hit with it considering he has used it himself.

Bump

@blackwind: you don't need haki to hurt logia users...

Crocodile both rounds

6 Cigars > 1 Cigar

Croc round 1 Smoker round 2. Round 1 would be a draw if not for Smoker having a seastone weapon that can still hurt a logia user, but Crocodile can overpower him to the point where he could disarm him, take his weapon, and beat him with it once he realizes it's seastone. Round 2 Smoker wins handily thanks to haki which would quite easily surprise Croc who over relies on his Logia powers.

I will go with Crocodile for both rounds. What could Smoker do against a simple sand tornado? The force of his Sables whirlwind attack has lifted and blown away opponents that are several times the mass and density of Smoker in human form. Say Smoker becomes smoke against the tornado. He becomes even less dense and just gets sucked in and blown away. We've seen in the Alabasta arc that the sandstorms Crocodile creates can travel several kilometers before stopping. He could win by removing Smoker from the battlefield.

Even if Smoker knows Haki it's useless against that kind of force. Also we've seen that Logia users can still evade imbued attacks as evidence with Aoikiji avoiding Whitebeard's Haki infused spear by making a hole in his chest before being hit. As long as he makes a gap where he may be hit Sir Crocodile can still dodge Haki attacks and counter with a whirlwind.

bump

how can crocodile win? blowing him away isnt a BFR since smoker just flies back

Crocodile get my vote, he do better againts Doflamingo than Smoker ( when doflamingo cut croc head his head just reform but when Doflamingo cut Smoker, Smoker dying and without Aokiji Smoker dies )

smoker crocodile was beating by pretimeskip luffy toughit was pis croc still sucked

I don't see why Smoker can't just blitz and depower Croc in round 1. He blitzed a faster Luffy than the one Croc fought and Seastone would work quite well on Croc.

Round 1 Smoker wins, he has sea stone weapons

Round 2 Smoker wins, easily.

Oh crap i forgot about sea stone.

( when doflamingo cut croc head his head just reform

doflamingo didnt use haki. and smoker was beaten offscreen with haki

@mezmero: I think this is probably the best point brought up here.

Croc is in the new world now. Undoubtedly he and Daz Bones learned CoA.

smoker even if he's a jobber

Smoker

One has a seatone stick to hit with. and one does not

it only goes to say that Smoker wins both rounds. with no diff.

Wait I may change my answer if it is current crocodile and he has armanent

@dawnone Luffy had a water(which didn't allow Crocodile turn in sand). Smoker doesn't have a natural non-haki counter(not including seastone)