Silver Surfer & Galactus vs Dr.Manhattan

Surfer or Galactus can solo.

Im pretty sure they did a battle with Silver Surfer vs Manhattan and Surfer came on top. Adding Galan makes this a spite... 
 
Edit:  http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles/7/dr-manhattan-vs-silver-surfer/18869/?page=21

allright, i wont say i know everything about comics, its just everything ive read, manhattan is a god, which doesnt excists in time or space.
he can also see the future, he can make people blow up at command, create worlds, life, destroy worlds, life. Unstoppable power, + being fast really isnt an issue seeing he cant be killed, seeing he's a god. No matter how many times surfer and galactus disintegrated him, he would just reintegrate. 

allright, didnt read the prev votes, however, dr.m could just go into another dimension, another place, he could disintegrate surfer from a distance. WAY before surfer could absorb his powers.
+ he CAN see the future, which means he would know like, a year ahead when the surfer was coming.

IF you read comics or not you can check surfer's page in Marvel wikia or here or even wikipedia to know that he cna also move through dimensions, time travel (something manhattan cant do as he is a slave to predetermination), see through time..and please dont mention that manhattan can see the future because even if he does he does nothing or cannot do anything to change it. Surfer on the other hand can. Surfer is the only one who has ever blown up a planet by simply powering up and he has also being disintegrated and reintegrated, he can attack manhattan on the astral plane( where he's conscience dwells), absorb he's energy turn him into a tomato, dump him in a black hole (we've never seen manhattan reform anywhere far from where he was disintegrated).  and hello  surfer chased blackbody outside of space and time itself and fought him and won and accesses the energies of the big bang. Manhattan looks like a God because he's in front normal humans, Surfer was like that when he was exiled on earth and created world peace by causing everyone on earth to see true humanity via telepathy.  Thats wasn't once but twice, manhattan cna only stop 99% of russian missles, 60% in the comics, everytime surfer flew around earth every nation would launch every weapon they had and he destroyed them all easily.
 
And we havent even gotten to Galactus yet...lol. the guy disintegrats Galaxies. alters souls and if he dies the universe dies with him.lol

" Dr. Manhattan seems to have complete mastery over the manipulation of matter and energies around him, as well as a complete understanding of their make-up on the most fundamental level. This control extends to complete control of his physical person, which was generated instinctively by his mind after the accident."
 
which means, he knows how to disintegrate both galactus and surfer, their matter. And all matter can disintegrate. 
The marvel universe would maybe collapse, not the DC universe ;P
 

wow, this is seriously marvel sided site.
Manhattan can, clone himself.
Manhattan has unlimited energy, no matter how much surfer would try to deplete him, he would of been killed in seconds, comparing the surfer alone to manhattan is comparing a tv to a fully loaded shotgun. It'd be completely destroyed.
 
Galactus on the other hand, is a bit more of a challenge. But seeing how Manhattan can clone himself, and his clones are equally as powerful as he are. No matter how many galactus would kill, he would just reproduce. Silver surfer and Galactus remains one, Manhattan could be an army, or an entire planet of fully functional super powered beings. I dont see how you can hands down give this fight to the marvel guys.

" wow, this is seriously marvel sided site.  "

Galactus & Surfer.

" wow, this is seriously marvel sided site. Manhattan can, clone himself. Manhattan has unlimited energy, no matter how much surfer would try to deplete him, he would of been killed in seconds, comparing the surfer alone to manhattan is comparing a tv to a fully loaded shotgun. It'd be completely destroyed.  Galactus on the other hand, is a bit more of a challenge. But seeing how Manhattan can clone himself, and his clones are equally as powerful as he are. No matter how many galactus would kill, he would just reproduce. Silver surfer and Galactus remains one, Manhattan could be an army, or an entire planet of fully functional super powered beings. I dont see how you can hands down give this fight to the marvel guys. "

lol, im a marvel fan aswell as DC, tho i tend to find DC's heroes a little more well thought out, well. The trio of Sups, bats, and WW, and the villains of the bat.
 
i just find it intruiging that you can imagine the silver surfer even making a dent into manhatten, the guy who has a weapon who doesnt kill, it just removes them from excistance, they just disappear, no matter no nothing. And IS a god, who can do whatever he wants. I mean, its not even a debate, you just assume they would win, without thinking what manhattan can do. You know what SS and Gally can do, but Manhattan is by far as powerful as Galactus, if not more. I've read this debate on other sites, which also made manhattan victor.
 
This is why i say marvel based fan group here.

Galactus or Surfer could solo.

" the guy who has a weapon who doesnt kill, it just removes them from excistance, they just disappear, no matter no nothing.  "

" lol, im a marvel fan aswell as DC, tho i tend to find DC's heroes a little more well thought out, well. The trio of Sups, bats, and WW, and the villains of the bat.  i just find it intruiging that you can imagine the silver surfer even making a dent into manhatten, the guy who has a weapon who doesnt kill, it just removes them from excistance, they just disappear, no matter no nothing. And IS a god, who can do whatever he wants. I mean, its not even a debate, you just assume they would win, without thinking what manhattan can do. You know what SS and Gally can do, but Manhattan is by far as powerful as Galactus, if not more. I've read this debate on other sites, which also made manhattan victor.  This is why i say marvel based fan group here. "

" Surfer or Galactus can solo. "

" lol, im a marvel fan aswell as DC, tho i tend to find DC's heroes a little more well thought out, well. The trio of Sups, bats, and WW, and the villains of the bat.  i just find it intruiging that you can imagine the silver surfer even making a dent into manhatten, the guy who has a weapon who doesnt kill, it just removes them from excistance, they just disappear, no matter no nothing. And IS a god, who can do whatever he wants. I mean, its not even a debate, you just assume they would win, without thinking what manhattan can do. You know what SS and Gally can do, but Manhattan is by far as powerful as Galactus, if not more. I've read this debate on other sites, which also made manhattan victor.  This is why i say marvel based fan group here. "

" Surfer or Galactus can solo. "

" @Crom-Cruach:  I thought at full power he surpassed all of the celestials except the dreaming celestial and in his true form heis power surpassed even the dreaming celestials as well "

This is stomp.  Surfer himself can arguably beat Manhattan

i think that silver surfer and galactus together would easily beat manhattan but i think it would be a little harder if they each had to solo i agree they could win but i dont think it would be a complete blowout.

"i think that silver surfer and galactus together would easily beat manhattan but i think it would be a little harder if they each had to solo i agree they could win but i dont think it would be a complete blowout. "

" Surfer or Galactus can solo. "

seriously did OP read all i wrote before? lol. I think he needs to read on surfer because surfer also has complete control over all matter and energy. galactus can warp space and time. whole different story there.

" @Xiamocni said:

" lol, im a marvel fan aswell as DC, tho i tend to find DC's heroes a little more well thought out, well. The trio of Sups, bats, and WW, and the villains of the bat.  i just find it intruiging that you can imagine the silver surfer even making a dent into manhatten, the guy who has a weapon who doesnt kill, it just removes them from excistance, they just disappear, no matter no nothing. And IS a god, who can do whatever he wants. I mean, its not even a debate, you just assume they would win, without thinking what manhattan can do. You know what SS and Gally can do, but Manhattan is by far as powerful as Galactus, if not more. I've read this debate on other sites, which also made manhattan victor.  This is why i say marvel based fan group here. "

First off I'm not a Marvel Fan. So your statement is already fraudulent. And you don't understand Watchmen if you think Manhattan can stop Galactus. Manhattan is at best a mid tier matter manipulator nothing more in a world with no other super-powers  Galactus is a cosmic being of immense power who dukes it out with Celestials any of which can make mince meat of Manhattan any day of the week. "

manhattan will get obliterated in a nanosecond

" @RetolledTruth: No, he didn't. "

Silver Surfer  solo's.....while Galactus enjoys a slurpee. =P

Manhattan commits suicide when confronted with this challenge.

" @Xan said:

" @RetolledTruth said:

" @CosmicSpiral said:

" @RetolledTruth: No, he didn't. "

Provide proof...because I can...you don't want to be ostracized for your beliefs....    Dr.Manhattan: Super-Powers and the SuperpowersBy Professor Milton Glass  "Perhaps in the process of reconstructing it corporeal form, this new and wholly original entity achieved a complete mastery of all matter; able to shape reality by manipulation of its basic building blocks." "

 You realy should stop posting ...
 
@CosmicSpiral said:

" @RetolledTruth: It says "perhaps".  Dr. Manhattan said he was going away and may create life. Nothing about creating another universe was mentioned.  "

There is no proof of nothing. Dr M is a tank buster. "

Want to make me?  Don't think you can....  Perhaps as in: maybe that was the way he obtained his power...  You must not have read the novel...dipshit "

"Nope, both can kill him while Manhattan lacks any sort of conventional way of beating either of them. So it should be fairly easy for them both to do it, mainly because they are completely different levels of power by comparison to boot.  Manhattan's best destruction feat involves crushing a tank, Norrin on his own is turning planets into cosmic space dust or creating singularities.As for Galactus? SlaughterhouseoverkillCCCcombobreakerWTFishedoinghere. Manhattan teleports a group of protestors to their homes, while Galactus is teleporting galaxies lightyears from place to place without so much as a sign of effort.  Both of them have better feats and simply pack mind numbing amount of more power than he can even imagine.    "

"Galactus n SS based on feats alone they can solo him ethier 1 "

"In the the Watchmen Graphic novel it is said that Manhattan has complete mastery over all matter and being able to shape reality by manipulation of it's basic building blocks... " 

 "He also went off to start another universe " 

"He knows the Future and could avoid the fight altogether... " 

"
@Hellos said:

"Nope, both can kill him while Manhattan lacks any sort of conventional way of beating either of them. So it should be fairly easy for them both to do it, mainly because they are completely different levels of power by comparison to boot.  Manhattan's best destruction feat involves crushing a tank, Norrin on his own is turning planets into cosmic space dust or creating singularities.As for Galactus? SlaughterhouseoverkillCCCcombobreakerWTFishedoinghere. Manhattan teleports a group of protestors to their homes, while Galactus is teleporting galaxies lightyears from place to place without so much as a sign of effort.  Both of them have better feats and simply pack mind numbing amount of more power than he can even imagine.    "

 
Great post Hellos! 

@WhiteAngel said:

"Galactus n SS based on feats alone they can solo him ethier 1 "

Terrible, Terrible stomp to bump.

@RetolledTruth

said:

"In the the Watchmen Graphic novel it is said that Manhattan has complete mastery over all matter and being able to shape reality by manipulation of it's basic building blocks... " 

Doesn't help him against people with leagues of better in feats in all areas.   

 "He also went off to start another universe " 

 
Nope.
 

"He knows the Future and could avoid the fight altogether... " 

1. Doesn't help him at all since he's helpless to time as the rest of us.  2. Avoiding the fight would constitute as losing.     "

@ Xan I'm sorry, But we both can do well to be less rude....we hardly know one another
 
We dont know enough about Manhattan to make a proper judgement...he did however build a castle of glass almost instantly on mars