Sherlock replaces batman, can he beat the joker?
(Sherlock gets a week of prep)
takes place ten minutes into the movie.
Sherlock Holmes v.s Joker (Movie versions)
Sherlock slaughters without prep.
Sherlock stomps.
@Trinity00 said:
@blackadamFTW said:
Sherlock stomps.
he takes over batman's place, he doesn't immediately fight the joker.
Oh. He still can do it.
There was a fight similar to this but it was comic Joker and movie Holmes. Sherlock still wins.
@blackadamFTW said:
Sherlock stomps.
Holmes puts the sherSTOMPlock on the Joker.
@blackadamFTW said:
Sherlock stomps.
this is correct
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
Holmes puts the sherSTOMPlock on the Joker.
How will sherlock take on all of jokers men at once and save harvey dent or rachel?
The Batman in the movies barely seems to use his brain. Holmes will figure out whist going on and stop it before that point. He is friggin Holmes.
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
Holmes puts the sherSTOMPlock on the Joker.
How will sherlock take on all of jokers men at once and save harvey dent or rachel?
The Batman in the movies barely seems to use his brain. Holmes will figure out whist going on and stop it before that point. He is friggin Holmes.
Yes but he still has many advantage over sherlock
like more experience
better a h2h
gadgets
intel
ect,
Not to mention you gave him a week of prep enough time to figure out Joker's plan and stop everything that happened in the movie meaning he doesn't have to save Rachel or Harvey in the first place.
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
Holmes puts the sherSTOMPlock on the Joker.
How will sherlock take on all of jokers men at once and save harvey dent or rachel?
The Batman in the movies barely seems to use his brain. Holmes will figure out whist going on and stop it before that point. He is friggin Holmes.
Yes but he still has many advantage over sherlock
like more experience
better a h2h
gadgets
intel
ect,
This is movie batman. he is not better at h2h. also consider that holmes came up with gadgets that were a hundred years before his time. sound familiar? not to mention Holmes can visualize an entire fight perfectly before the fight even occurs. and he is always right. that is an unbelievable advantage in any fight. the advantages u listed don't exist when comparing these characters in their respective movies. In fact, i think the opposite is true. Holmes is clearly superior based on the movies, and not bat mans comics.
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
Holmes puts the sherSTOMPlock on the Joker.
How will sherlock take on all of jokers men at once and save harvey dent or rachel?
The Batman in the movies barely seems to use his brain. Holmes will figure out whist going on and stop it before that point. He is friggin Holmes.
Yes but he still has many advantage over sherlock
like more experience
better a h2h
gadgets
intel
ect,
This is movie batman. he is not better at h2h. also consider that holmes came up with gadgets that were a hundred years before his time. sound familiar? not to mention Holmes can visualize an entire fight perfectly before the fight even occurs. and he is always right. that is an unbelievable advantage in any fight. the advantages u listed don't exist when comparing these characters in their respective movies. In fact, i think the opposite is true. Holmes is clearly superior based on the movies, and not bat mans comics.
How's he going to save rachel and harvey than?
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
Holmes puts the sherSTOMPlock on the Joker.
How will sherlock take on all of jokers men at once and save harvey dent or rachel?
The Batman in the movies barely seems to use his brain. Holmes will figure out whist going on and stop it before that point. He is friggin Holmes.
Yes but he still has many advantage over sherlock
like more experience
better a h2h
gadgets
intel
ect,
This is movie batman. he is not better at h2h. also consider that holmes came up with gadgets that were a hundred years before his time. sound familiar? not to mention Holmes can visualize an entire fight perfectly before the fight even occurs. and he is always right. that is an unbelievable advantage in any fight. the advantages u listed don't exist when comparing these characters in their respective movies. In fact, i think the opposite is true. Holmes is clearly superior based on the movies, and not bat mans comics.
How's he going to save rachel and harvey than?
based on his superior problem solving skills and intellect I think its very likely that he would have apprehended the Joker much much earlier, before Harvey or Rachel could have been killed. This would not make for as good a movie... but his detective skills in Sherlock Holmes are 10x as good as Batmans were in the Dark Knight
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
Holmes puts the sherSTOMPlock on the Joker.
How will sherlock take on all of jokers men at once and save harvey dent or rachel?
The Batman in the movies barely seems to use his brain. Holmes will figure out whist going on and stop it before that point. He is friggin Holmes.
Yes but he still has many advantage over sherlock
like more experience
better a h2h
gadgets
intel
ect,
This is movie batman. he is not better at h2h. also consider that holmes came up with gadgets that were a hundred years before his time. sound familiar? not to mention Holmes can visualize an entire fight perfectly before the fight even occurs. and he is always right. that is an unbelievable advantage in any fight. the advantages u listed don't exist when comparing these characters in their respective movies. In fact, i think the opposite is true. Holmes is clearly superior based on the movies, and not bat mans comics.
How's he going to save rachel and harvey than?
based on his superior problem solving skills and intellect I think its very likely that he would have apprehended the Joker much much earlier, before Harvey or Rachel could have been killed. This would not make for as good a movie... but his detective skills in Sherlock Holmes are 10x as good as Batmans were in the Dark Knight
Surely the Joker will have thought of a plan to counter's Sherlock's plans after all sherlock could have gotten confused if Joker was a genius or loon.
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
Holmes puts the sherSTOMPlock on the Joker.
How will sherlock take on all of jokers men at once and save harvey dent or rachel?
The Batman in the movies barely seems to use his brain. Holmes will figure out whist going on and stop it before that point. He is friggin Holmes.
Yes but he still has many advantage over sherlock
like more experience
better a h2h
gadgets
intel
ect,
This is movie batman. he is not better at h2h. also consider that holmes came up with gadgets that were a hundred years before his time. sound familiar? not to mention Holmes can visualize an entire fight perfectly before the fight even occurs. and he is always right. that is an unbelievable advantage in any fight. the advantages u listed don't exist when comparing these characters in their respective movies. In fact, i think the opposite is true. Holmes is clearly superior based on the movies, and not bat mans comics.
How's he going to save rachel and harvey than?
based on his superior problem solving skills and intellect I think its very likely that he would have apprehended the Joker much much earlier, before Harvey or Rachel could have been killed. This would not make for as good a movie... but his detective skills in Sherlock Holmes are 10x as good as Batmans were in the Dark Knight
Surely the Joker will have thought of a plan to counter's Sherlock's plans after all sherlock could have gotten confused if Joker was a genius or loon.
im not trying to troll you but i think ur stretching buddy
@Pwok21 said:
Sherlock slaughters without prep.
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
Holmes puts the sherSTOMPlock on the Joker.
How will sherlock take on all of jokers men at once and save harvey dent or rachel?
The Batman in the movies barely seems to use his brain. Holmes will figure out whist going on and stop it before that point. He is friggin Holmes.
Yes but he still has many advantage over sherlock
like more experience
better a h2h
gadgets
intel
ect,
This is movie batman. he is not better at h2h. also consider that holmes came up with gadgets that were a hundred years before his time. sound familiar? not to mention Holmes can visualize an entire fight perfectly before the fight even occurs. and he is always right. that is an unbelievable advantage in any fight. the advantages u listed don't exist when comparing these characters in their respective movies. In fact, i think the opposite is true. Holmes is clearly superior based on the movies, and not bat mans comics.
How's he going to save rachel and harvey than?
based on his superior problem solving skills and intellect I think its very likely that he would have apprehended the Joker much much earlier, before Harvey or Rachel could have been killed. This would not make for as good a movie... but his detective skills in Sherlock Holmes are 10x as good as Batmans were in the Dark Knight
Surely the Joker will have thought of a plan to counter's Sherlock's plans after all sherlock could have gotten confused if Joker was a genius or loon.
im not trying to troll you but i think ur stretching buddy
Joker is crazy, he could potentially drive sherlock mad with his puzzles and twists.
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
Holmes puts the sherSTOMPlock on the Joker.
How will sherlock take on all of jokers men at once and save harvey dent or rachel?
The Batman in the movies barely seems to use his brain. Holmes will figure out whist going on and stop it before that point. He is friggin Holmes.
Yes but he still has many advantage over sherlock
like more experience
better a h2h
gadgets
intel
ect,
This is movie batman. he is not better at h2h. also consider that holmes came up with gadgets that were a hundred years before his time. sound familiar? not to mention Holmes can visualize an entire fight perfectly before the fight even occurs. and he is always right. that is an unbelievable advantage in any fight. the advantages u listed don't exist when comparing these characters in their respective movies. In fact, i think the opposite is true. Holmes is clearly superior based on the movies, and not bat mans comics.
How's he going to save rachel and harvey than?
based on his superior problem solving skills and intellect I think its very likely that he would have apprehended the Joker much much earlier, before Harvey or Rachel could have been killed. This would not make for as good a movie... but his detective skills in Sherlock Holmes are 10x as good as Batmans were in the Dark Knight
Surely the Joker will have thought of a plan to counter's Sherlock's plans after all sherlock could have gotten confused if Joker was a genius or loon.
im not trying to troll you but i think ur stretching buddy
Joker is crazy, he could potentially drive sherlock mad with his puzzles and twists.
the Joker is nowhere near smart enough or puzzling enough to drive Sherlock Holmes mad. He lives his life to solve puzzles and explain the unexplainable. Plus... he too is crazy. Holmes stomps this. lol
@Trinity00: Joker is unpredictable in the comics, in the movie we don't know because Batman was less of a detective in the movies, but based of Sherlock's feats he is a better fighter than Joker and he is smarter so I think Sherlock wins
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
Holmes puts the sherSTOMPlock on the Joker.
How will sherlock take on all of jokers men at once and save harvey dent or rachel?
The Batman in the movies barely seems to use his brain. Holmes will figure out whist going on and stop it before that point. He is friggin Holmes.
Yes but he still has many advantage over sherlock
like more experience
better a h2h
gadgets
intel
ect,
This is movie batman. he is not better at h2h. also consider that holmes came up with gadgets that were a hundred years before his time. sound familiar? not to mention Holmes can visualize an entire fight perfectly before the fight even occurs. and he is always right. that is an unbelievable advantage in any fight. the advantages u listed don't exist when comparing these characters in their respective movies. In fact, i think the opposite is true. Holmes is clearly superior based on the movies, and not bat mans comics.
How's he going to save rachel and harvey than?
based on his superior problem solving skills and intellect I think its very likely that he would have apprehended the Joker much much earlier, before Harvey or Rachel could have been killed. This would not make for as good a movie... but his detective skills in Sherlock Holmes are 10x as good as Batmans were in the Dark Knight
Surely the Joker will have thought of a plan to counter's Sherlock's plans after all sherlock could have gotten confused if Joker was a genius or loon.
im not trying to troll you but i think ur stretching buddy
Joker is crazy, he could potentially drive sherlock mad with his puzzles and twists.
the Joker is nowhere near smart enough or puzzling enough to drive Sherlock Holmes mad. He lives his life to solve puzzles and explain the unexplainable. Plus... he too is crazy. Holmes stomps this. lol
Well the joker has the advantage of having lots of guns.
@joeagentofhand1 said:
@Trinity00: Joker is unpredictable in the comics, in the movie we don't know because Batman was less of a detective in the movies, but based of Sherlock's feats he is a better fighter than Joker and he is smarter so I think Sherlock wins
Joker can always have his men gun him down.
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
Holmes puts the sherSTOMPlock on the Joker.
How will sherlock take on all of jokers men at once and save harvey dent or rachel?
The Batman in the movies barely seems to use his brain. Holmes will figure out whist going on and stop it before that point. He is friggin Holmes.
Yes but he still has many advantage over sherlock
like more experience
better a h2h
gadgets
intel
ect,
This is movie batman. he is not better at h2h. also consider that holmes came up with gadgets that were a hundred years before his time. sound familiar? not to mention Holmes can visualize an entire fight perfectly before the fight even occurs. and he is always right. that is an unbelievable advantage in any fight. the advantages u listed don't exist when comparing these characters in their respective movies. In fact, i think the opposite is true. Holmes is clearly superior based on the movies, and not bat mans comics.
How's he going to save rachel and harvey than?
based on his superior problem solving skills and intellect I think its very likely that he would have apprehended the Joker much much earlier, before Harvey or Rachel could have been killed. This would not make for as good a movie... but his detective skills in Sherlock Holmes are 10x as good as Batmans were in the Dark Knight
Surely the Joker will have thought of a plan to counter's Sherlock's plans after all sherlock could have gotten confused if Joker was a genius or loon.
im not trying to troll you but i think ur stretching buddy
Joker is crazy, he could potentially drive sherlock mad with his puzzles and twists.
the Joker is nowhere near smart enough or puzzling enough to drive Sherlock Holmes mad. He lives his life to solve puzzles and explain the unexplainable. Plus... he too is crazy. Holmes stomps this. lol
Well the joker has the advantage of having lots of guns.
lol yes. because Holmes never encounters guys with guns and gets away unscathed.
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
Holmes puts the sherSTOMPlock on the Joker.
How will sherlock take on all of jokers men at once and save harvey dent or rachel?
The Batman in the movies barely seems to use his brain. Holmes will figure out whist going on and stop it before that point. He is friggin Holmes.
Yes but he still has many advantage over sherlock
like more experience
better a h2h
gadgets
intel
ect,
This is movie batman. he is not better at h2h. also consider that holmes came up with gadgets that were a hundred years before his time. sound familiar? not to mention Holmes can visualize an entire fight perfectly before the fight even occurs. and he is always right. that is an unbelievable advantage in any fight. the advantages u listed don't exist when comparing these characters in their respective movies. In fact, i think the opposite is true. Holmes is clearly superior based on the movies, and not bat mans comics.
How's he going to save rachel and harvey than?
based on his superior problem solving skills and intellect I think its very likely that he would have apprehended the Joker much much earlier, before Harvey or Rachel could have been killed. This would not make for as good a movie... but his detective skills in Sherlock Holmes are 10x as good as Batmans were in the Dark Knight
Surely the Joker will have thought of a plan to counter's Sherlock's plans after all sherlock could have gotten confused if Joker was a genius or loon.
im not trying to troll you but i think ur stretching buddy
Joker is crazy, he could potentially drive sherlock mad with his puzzles and twists.
the Joker is nowhere near smart enough or puzzling enough to drive Sherlock Holmes mad. He lives his life to solve puzzles and explain the unexplainable. Plus... he too is crazy. Holmes stomps this. lol
Well the joker has the advantage of having lots of guns.
lol yes. because Holmes never encounters guys with guns and gets away unscathed.
They never had automatic weaponry and explosives like jokers men, not to mention Sherlock has'nt shown the capability of taking down multiple swat officers in 30 seconds (like batman)
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
Holmes puts the sherSTOMPlock on the Joker.
How will sherlock take on all of jokers men at once and save harvey dent or rachel?
The Batman in the movies barely seems to use his brain. Holmes will figure out whist going on and stop it before that point. He is friggin Holmes.
Yes but he still has many advantage over sherlock
like more experience
better a h2h
gadgets
intel
ect,
This is movie batman. he is not better at h2h. also consider that holmes came up with gadgets that were a hundred years before his time. sound familiar? not to mention Holmes can visualize an entire fight perfectly before the fight even occurs. and he is always right. that is an unbelievable advantage in any fight. the advantages u listed don't exist when comparing these characters in their respective movies. In fact, i think the opposite is true. Holmes is clearly superior based on the movies, and not bat mans comics.
How's he going to save rachel and harvey than?
based on his superior problem solving skills and intellect I think its very likely that he would have apprehended the Joker much much earlier, before Harvey or Rachel could have been killed. This would not make for as good a movie... but his detective skills in Sherlock Holmes are 10x as good as Batmans were in the Dark Knight
Surely the Joker will have thought of a plan to counter's Sherlock's plans after all sherlock could have gotten confused if Joker was a genius or loon.
im not trying to troll you but i think ur stretching buddy
Joker is crazy, he could potentially drive sherlock mad with his puzzles and twists.
the Joker is nowhere near smart enough or puzzling enough to drive Sherlock Holmes mad. He lives his life to solve puzzles and explain the unexplainable. Plus... he too is crazy. Holmes stomps this. lol
Well the joker has the advantage of having lots of guns.
lol yes. because Holmes never encounters guys with guns and gets away unscathed.
They never had automatic weaponry and explosives like jokers men, not to mention Sherlock has'nt shown the capability of taking down multiple swat officers in 30 seconds (like batman)
yeah he has. watch the movie. his fighting was more impressive. he basically has precognition. he would know exactly how to come at them and with his advanced understanding of the human body he would be able to incapacitate them while actually using less power when striking them. Same effect with less energy,,, is a win.
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
@Trinity00 said:
@IKnowEverything said:
Holmes puts the sherSTOMPlock on the Joker.
How will sherlock take on all of jokers men at once and save harvey dent or rachel?
The Batman in the movies barely seems to use his brain. Holmes will figure out whist going on and stop it before that point. He is friggin Holmes.
Yes but he still has many advantage over sherlock
like more experience
better a h2h
gadgets
intel
ect,
This is movie batman. he is not better at h2h. also consider that holmes came up with gadgets that were a hundred years before his time. sound familiar? not to mention Holmes can visualize an entire fight perfectly before the fight even occurs. and he is always right. that is an unbelievable advantage in any fight. the advantages u listed don't exist when comparing these characters in their respective movies. In fact, i think the opposite is true. Holmes is clearly superior based on the movies, and not bat mans comics.
How's he going to save rachel and harvey than?
based on his superior problem solving skills and intellect I think its very likely that he would have apprehended the Joker much much earlier, before Harvey or Rachel could have been killed. This would not make for as good a movie... but his detective skills in Sherlock Holmes are 10x as good as Batmans were in the Dark Knight
Surely the Joker will have thought of a plan to counter's Sherlock's plans after all sherlock could have gotten confused if Joker was a genius or loon.
im not trying to troll you but i think ur stretching buddy
Joker is crazy, he could potentially drive sherlock mad with his puzzles and twists.
the Joker is nowhere near smart enough or puzzling enough to drive Sherlock Holmes mad. He lives his life to solve puzzles and explain the unexplainable. Plus... he too is crazy. Holmes stomps this. lol
Well the joker has the advantage of having lots of guns.
lol yes. because Holmes never encounters guys with guns and gets away unscathed.
They never had automatic weaponry and explosives like jokers men, not to mention Sherlock has'nt shown the capability of taking down multiple swat officers in 30 seconds (like batman)
yeah he has. watch the movie. his fighting was more impressive. he basically has precognition. he would know exactly how to come at them and with his advanced understanding of the human body he would be able to incapacitate them while actually using less power when striking them. Same effect with less energy,,, is a win.
I dunno I don't think Sherlock could get far in fights without gadgets.
Sherlock Holmes.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment