@rogueshadow said:
To look at, you'd probably think Shane, but...
Scenario 1: h2h - Hank has better feats, he beat the sh*t out of two tough guys in a bar simultaneously. All Shane did was beat up Ed and Rick, Rick's a badass but he isn't incredibly tough. Rick was in Rick lite mode then too, not bloodlust Rick from early season 3 and late season 4.
Scenario 2: both have a gun - Eh, neither have great feats I recall, all Shane did was shoot slow moving targets, I can't fully recall Hank doing much other than being in a firefight with Jack.
Scenario 3: There are Zombies around them - Shane, Hank wouldn't know how to deal with them. Though depending on how many there are they could both die.
Scenario 4: Both BLed ,0 morals, both armed with a knife, Carl and Lori are at stake for Shane, Marie is in stake for Hank. Hank.
how is beating 2 random thugs better than beating Rick and Ed? He also killed the heck outta Randal. And Shane can take a punch. Hank's feats:beating 2 fodders, beating Jesse Pinkman,beating a 51 years old guy with lung cancer . Shane's feats:Beating Rick in a fair fight (Rick being an officer of the law, attacking him first as well), and beating Ed(not much of a feat, however he carried him like luggage and pounded him)
Beating 2 thugs at the same time. Ed did nothing but beat his wife and try to molest his own daughter. Rick wasn't in his bloodlust mode like he is now. Randal, Ed, Jesse & Walt are non factors.
Scenario 2: I remember Shane being a shooting instructor. Rick gave him that job for a reason. Furthermore when he was teaching Andrea he shoot all the bottles(unmoving targets).Later on, he tied a log to a rope and improvised a moving target(it was moving very quickly) .Andrea couldn't shoot it in numerous occasions. Shane told her she was not focused. Then he pulled out his gun and shoot it right in the bull's eye in the first shoot.
Shooting a log = master marksman now? Shooting a log while not in a stressful situation is meaningless. Surprised you haven't brought up the pilot's opening fire fight since that's his best shootout feat.
Scenario 3: Not sure myself here.
Scenario 4: Idk, Shane seemed to care a lot about Carl and Lory, he even broke a guy's neck in an instant and BROKE HIS OWN NOSE LIKE IT WAS NOTHING. That's a durability feat right there man. He showed he's ready for everything . I think he would play dirty as heck in this scenario. To sum up I think he has scenarios 1,2,4
If you show me feats that I didn't take into consideration about Hank, I might change my mind,
Log in to comment