"Wisppeons said:I dont think he will win he can still have his arms cut off also I dont think he could match wolverines speed."Not so. Ed figured out how to beat Greed with no prep time. But lets say, Scar knows the metal, would he still win?"
doesnt he have to know its make up if so I dont think so."
i think logan would win he has speed he has aways bn able to jump around and dodge most of hulks attacks he would just need to run up his arm and attack the head and neck. the eyes throat and neck bone which has aways proven the hardest to heal for hulk he had his neck broken by maestro.
Scar is a bullet dodger. And Wolverine has been tagged by far slower people than Scar. Throw in that Scar in the anime and the Manga has used his deconstruction power to perturb his enemies balance to get a single touch killshot. Wolverine will not be able to get his arm before he makes contact with with Scar. And Scar has shown an instinctive ability to determine elemental composition of materials by touch. This is a fight that Wolverine should not win. Scar touches wolverine's face, his entire upper body is decomposed. He touches wolverine's bones, he loses his skeleton, again. I am bumping this because Scar was grossly underestimated on this thread. Especially Brotherhood version, who would have full alchemy powers anyway.