RotS Anakin, Obi-Wan, and Mace Windu Vs. Three Sith Lords - Battles

#1 Edited by shroudofsorrow (998 posts) - 5 months, 3 days ago - Show Bio

Anakin, Obi-Wan, and Mace Windu as they were in RotS take on three lords of the Dark Side: Darth Caedus, Lumiya, and Darth Malgus. Setting is The Invisible Hand Observation Tower where Anakin and Obi-Wan fought Dooku.

Note that by Mace Windu as he was in RotS I mean Mace Windu with his amp. Anakin is also still Light Side. Also, Darth Malgus is the way he was in the actual The Old Republic MMORPG.

Versus

#2 Posted by MasterJohn (2472 posts) - 5 months, 3 days ago - Show Bio

This horse has been beaten a few times.

1. Obi-Wan-Kenobi vs Darth Malgus: There is no way Malgus wins. Obi Wan has better dueling feats in ROTS then Malgus has, ever. Could Malgus keep up with that blood-lusted, morals off Anakin? No.

2. Mace Windu vs Darth Caedus: This has always been a very controversial debate as I saw on your last thread. I'l leave these to the experts.

3. Anakin Skywalker vs Lumiya: Wow. This is a serious piece of meat if you tell me. Wasn't Lumiya able to create illusions, Concealment of her own appearence, phantasms born purely of the dark side. Force phantoms, simutaneously? That's what I heard in a debate.

All in all, it's still a toss up.

#3 Edited by shroudofsorrow (998 posts) - 5 months, 3 days ago - Show Bio

@MasterJohn said:

This horse has been beaten a few times.

When has this exact fight with these exact teams been done before?

@MasterJohn said:

1. Obi-Wan-Kenobi vs Darth Malgus: There is no way Malgus wins. Obi Wan has better dueling feats in ROTS then Malgus has, ever. Could Malgus keep up with that blood-lusted, morals off Anakin? No.

Malgus as of TOR was taking on one of two teams: Hero of Tython (who is better than Obi-Wan) and Barsen'thor plus back-up, or Emperor's Wrath and Kallig plus back-up. Malgus as of the actual TOR MMO is better than the Malgus we saw in the trailers. Yes, I do think Obi-Wan still wins, but not easily.

And I never said that Anakin was bloodlusted or without morals. I said it was him as of RotS. Anakin as of RotS started off still Light Side.

@MasterJohn said:

2. Mace Windu vs Darth Caedus: This has always been a very controversial debate as I saw on your last thread. I'l leave these to the experts.

Without the amp, Caedus would likely win, but I said it was Mace with the amp. Mace wins.

I am of the belief that the Jedi win this with difficulty. Caedus is by far the most powerful of the three Sith, but amped-up Mace can take him. Anakin and Obi-Wan together can handle Malgus, even with back-up by Lumiya.

#4 Posted by shroudofsorrow (998 posts) - 5 months, 3 days ago - Show Bio

Bump

#5 Posted by Sethlol (1232 posts) - 5 months, 3 days ago - Show Bio

Sith should win this.

#6 Posted by JediXMan (22919 posts) - 5 months, 3 days ago - Show Bio

Sith stomp.

I'll go as far as to say that Caedus solos.

#7 Posted by shroudofsorrow (998 posts) - 5 months, 3 days ago - Show Bio

@JediXMan: No, they are not stomping, and no, Caedus is not soloing. Mace, Anakin, and Obi-Wan together are better than anyone Caedus ever fought with the exception of Luke and if memory serves me right there were unique circumstances to that (or just flat out PIS depending on how you look at it).

While it is true that Mace was unable to beat Palpatine, even with an amp, with the amp (and I explicitly state that he has it here) he fought evenly with him. Palpatine>>>>Caedus. So no, Caedus is not soloing. Not when Mace has his super-amp.

Mace Vs. Caedus-Caedus would normally win a majority, but Mace has his amp, so Mace wins.

Anakin can handle Lumiya or Malgus, as can Obi-Wan.

The Jedi win.

#8 Posted by JediXMan (22919 posts) - 5 months, 3 days ago - Show Bio

@shroudofsorrow said:

The Jedi win.

So, you made this thread with the intention of one side winning? Gotcha.

I was going to actually reply until I read that. Now it's clear.

#9 Posted by shroudofsorrow (998 posts) - 5 months, 3 days ago - Show Bio

@JediXMan: No, I simply have an opinion on who I think wins which I reserve the right to make. Just because it is my thread does not mean that I do not have the right to post my thoughts on who I think wins.

If you can offer a compelling counterargument, I will change my views. Until then I stand by them.

#10 Posted by shroudofsorrow (998 posts) - 5 months, 3 days ago - Show Bio

Bump

#11 Posted by god_spawn (30402 posts) - 5 months, 2 days ago - Show Bio

@JediXMan said:

Sith stomp.
I'll go as far as to say that Caedus solos.

Moderator

#12 Posted by god_spawn (30402 posts) - 5 months, 2 days ago - Show Bio

@JediXMan: I need to you to reply. I'll give this one chance to stay open and I need you, or you @Silver2467 to explain to me why this is a mismatch. I trust both of you as the leading SW knowledge around here so let's see why.

Moderator

#13 Posted by JediXMan (22919 posts) - 5 months, 2 days ago - Show Bio

@god_spawn:

I stick by my original statement. I'll wait for Silver; maybe we can discuss this.

#14 Posted by shroudofsorrow (998 posts) - 5 months, 2 days ago - Show Bio

I still need an explanation. You claim that Caedus stomps a team that includes someone who fought evenly with Palpatine. Are you trying to tell me Caedus>>>>Palpatine? Because I don't buy it. Mara Jade did well against Caedus, who only killed her via trickery and a cheapshot. Are we honestly saying that Mara Jade>>>Palpatine? Its ABC logic here. I need an explanation.