Battle of the young sidekicks. This fight is to the death no holds barred.
If they would be about the same age during the fight then I would probably go with Robin. I'm giving them a draw in everything else but I think Dick would be a better acrobat and he has that great utility belt. Bucky doesn't even have a shield to defend himself with.
Robin, if he really knew how to use the utiliity belt well, Bucky would be a better hand to hand fighter because of all the millitary hand-to-hand training (all military branches and special ops) But if robin took advantage of batarangs, bolos, and had his little staff thing, then he might get the upper hand. who would win with them older? http://www.comicvine.com/message/winter-soldier-vs-nightwing/109273/&c=17&17