Revan VS Mace Windu

Revan VS Mace Windu

Rules:

• Both in prime
• Battle takes place in Geonosian Arena
• Mace has no amp(I need to say that)

Revan stomps

No.

Yes. How Windu is going to counter ALL THOSE Force powers? Revan is also better tactician.

Are you seriously using Game mechanics as evidence? LAL. Mace is the superior duelist, and should have the speed advantage.

Revan crumples Windu into a little brown ball.

@dccomicsrule2011: yes, Revan has better force abilitys, and is way more trained then windu.

Sure he has better Force abilities...but Mace is the better duelist. Also, how is Revan more trained, why would that even matter much here?

@leo-343: Either Revan or Yoda would destroy Windu with the Force, if they were so inclined. Windu's chances increase with how focused Revan is on dueling, and considering the magnitude of the latter's power and the ease of which it could be used to wreck Windu, I fail to see how Windu has a chance.

Revan via power. Mace would beat him in a straight out duel, but I'd give Revan maybe 7.5/10

@dccomicsrule2011:

...did you really delete and re-post that just to give DC a second notification?

@i_like_swords: no, the first one did not notify them. so I re did it to make sure it is not ignored.

In game world, those powers are legitimate, Revan is a game character, so yes, you MUST take those powers into consideration. Being superior duelist means nothing, when you are dealing with, superior tactician stasis field and then drain life force:

Revan.

That's tantamount to spamming, lol

@i_like_swords: how is it? I am just resending my argument so it is not ignored because the origanal did not send properly.I can delete the original post when I can.

@picard:

In game world, those powers are legitimate, Revan is a game character, so yes, you MUST take those powers into consideration.

If Revan was not canonically stated to have those powers than it's just game mechanics, which is and always will be non-canon. Sorry, I don't make the canon rules, I just follow them.

Being superior duelist means nothing

LAL.

superior tactician stasis field and then drain life force:

When Revan uses drain in a canon duel and not non-canon game mechanics, call me.

Not even going to dignify this with a response. Wanking in the Battle Forum never get's old. Please don't spam my inbox up with post such as this.

As for the thread, I'm giving it to Revan 7/10, based on vastly superior Force power.

@dccomicsrule2011: I think you're underrating Revan's dueling abilities.

Revan.

@dccomicsrule2011: how am I "wanking in the battle fourms"? and what dont you need to dignify?

Pray tell where am I underatting his dueling ability? Saying Mace Windu, arguably one of the top 5 duelist in the Star Wars mythos is superior to Revan is not an insult.

None, of those characters are canon, because since Disney bought Star wars, expanded universe is non canon. So your argument is invalid.

@picard:

None, of those characters are canon, because since Disney bought Star wars, expanded universe is non canon. So your argument is invalid.

What was canon in the old EU is canon in the current Legends, and what was non-canon in the old EU, isn't canon with Legends.

So yeah, Revan's game mechanic feats still aren't canon to Legends----you have nothing to add as usual.

@dccomicsrule2011: I think that you are underestimateing what revan can do, he defeated mandalor the ultimate in single combat. he probably is not as good as windu, however I think he could put up a really good fight.

Are you seriously using Game mechanics as evidence? LAL. Mace is the superior duelist, and should have the speed advantage.

Sure he has better Force abilities...but Mace is the better duelist. Also, how is Revan more trained, why would that even matter much here?

How are the above post underestimating Revan? I already said he would win here----I just disagreed that he would do it easily.

doesn't matter because Legends are none canon in its entirety, anyway... So, again your argument is invalid. Also what do you mean by games mechanics? Do you think that force push or lightsaber throw are games mechanics? Sorry, you can't cherry pick and say that some of game's powers are legitimate and some are just game mechanics, just because you don't like them.

Revan

@picard:

doesn't matter because Legends are none canon in its entirety, anyway... So, again your your argument is invalid

Legends is like the Ultimate Universe of Marvel. It's still has it's own timeline and everything else, but it isn't connected to the Main Canon; if you actually read the tweets of the people in charge, you would know this. If something was non-canon with Legends before the retcon, it's still non-canon afterwards.

Also what do you mean by games mechanics?

It's common sense. But since I don't feel like explaining that to you, I'll redirect you to the Wookipedia

Do you think that force push or lightsaber throw are games mechanics?

You really have no idea what you're talking about....In ROTS Official movie game; Mace Windu having the Force stun ability is game play mechanics because it is something chosen by the player, and is a universal power of that game; but's it's not canon because he has not used it outside of game play ( Game-Play is obviously non-canon others wise Mace Windu can tank multiple Lightsaber shots...)

By your logic, Mace Windu has Force stun as well, and it can even work on the likes of Count Dooku and Anakin Skywalker; confirmed to be two of the most powerful Force sensitives to ever live.

Sorry, you can't cherry pick and say that some of game's powers are legitimate and some are just game mechanics, just because you don't like them.

Not cherry picking Cut-Scenes and such and confirmed Force abilities is canon. Game play and Game mechanics are not as they're largely controlled by by the individual player.

Nobody stomps, but Revan wins almost every time.

@dccomicsrule2011: No I agree, Revan won't win easily, I just thought you meant Revan had poor saber skills. That's why I pointed that out. You're not underestimating Revan at all, it just looked like you were overlooking his dueling capabilities.

It really didn't..

I'm pretty sure DC was being more concise than negligent. He wasn't overlooking anything at all.

God Revan fanboys are terrible.

His only awesome feat was destroying a metal door with force push.

Windu's Vaadpad is designed specifically to fight the dark side. His dueling skills surpass Revan.

Mace saberblitzes.

Revan.

Revan Force Drains for a instant win.

Also rag dolling some of the TOR best is pretty solid for TK.

Revan's Force Drain was aided by Mekel and it wasn't even an instant-kill and didn't cause any visual effects on Jorak Uln. Granted, it wasn't entirely peak condition Revan, and pre-prime as well, but Jorak Uln doesn't compare to Mace either.

The TK feat is very good because of the affected characters but vastly overblown. It required a brief charge-up time and apparent maximum effort, so to speak, and it wasn't really a rag-doll. Ragdoll is usually a reference to when people a literally being thrown about like ragolls, but usually the person who ragdolls is doing it casually, not with charge-up time. The fact that the various opponents were unharmed, then got back up right away and proceeded to basically defeat Revan is pretty conclusive that it's not just a ragdoll and that he can do it on a whim.

Game mechanic feats aren't making any sense... Revan's best force feat would be collapsing a regular building according to his EU writer, which isn't enough for ragdolling someone who can manipulate an AT-TE.

God Revan fanboys are terrible.

His only awesome feat was destroying a metal door with force push.

Windu's Vaadpad is designed specifically to fight the dark side. His dueling skills surpass Revan.

Here's one thing that's never made sense to me about high-level Star Wars fights.

You've got guys who can react to things that haven't even happened yet, compel people to do things agains their will, smash/crush/push/pull things with their minds and shoot lightning out of their fingertips...

And yet people seem to think that the most important question is who can wave a three-foot long glow rod around better.

It depends on character tendencies. Some characters like abusing their power, some like to duel. Some have no power and can only duel, and visa versa. Revan sort of does everything... but is primarily a Force User.

This isn't a stomp, not even close. A fight between these two would be very interesting and close in my opinion. Mace is definitely a superior duelist, however Revan is obviously more powerful and more effective with his force powers, but Windu is no slouch himself. I don't think Windu would get lolstomped by Revans force powers, but he'd certainly struggle against them, however if he can get in close (which I can see happening sometimes) Revan would be defeated by Windu's superior sword skills.

I'd go as far as too say that Mace would beat Revan with little dificulty if he got in close, due to his better saber feats. I agree Revan would win, but not as much as others think. Revan would win 5-6/10 in my opinion.

Great you leave the vine for ONE month and all the little star wars know it all newbs show up,

Revan.

Gotcha.

@dccomicsrule2011

My apologies, please continue.

Windu mid diff