Red Robin vs Batgirl (barbara)

fight takes place at midnight. In New York. Morals on. standard gear. current versions

red robin, any of the robins beat babs even though i like her more than tim and damian

i disagree. people seem to forget, barbara was also trained by batman, has more experience, and is smarter than both robins. babs is almost as agile as nightwing and catwoman, and just as agile as batman. since babs has gotten her mobility back, sheks been kicking ass. i seriously think, if she couldnt out fight damien or tim, she could definitely out think them both. like batman who often does the same thing.

Red Robin easily.

Barbara is smarter than Tim in compute skills. She is one of the weaker fighters in the Batfamily.

@max4523 said:

i disagree. people seem to forget, barbara was also trained by batman, has more experience, and is smarter than both robins. babs is almost as agile as nightwing and catwoman, and just as agile as batman. since babs has gotten her mobility back, sheks been kicking ass. i seriously think, if she couldnt out fight damien or tim, she could definitely out think them both. like batman who often does the same thing.

Tim is pretty smart in his own right. But since the OP doesn't mention prep time, i think we should assume that there is none, therefore prep smarts doesn't really come into play.

As such, tim takes it. They are both the weaker fighters of the Bat-clan, but I think tim is better. Especially since babs was out of commission for a while....

Is this a joke thread?

Tim stomps her @ss....

Red Robin