Quinlan Vos vs Ki-Adi-Mundi

At the request of ShootingNova, I present to you: an SW battle thread. Enjoy.

Quinlan Vos

• Standard equipment for both.
• Regular morals and mindsets apply.
• Random encounter. No prep or knowledge of the other.
• Victory by death or KO.
• Combatants begin fifteen meters apart.
• Battle takes place in the undercity of Taris, unpopulated.

I'm giving this to Vos for now, due to the proximity. I might give it to Mundi due to possibly better TK feats if they were farther apart, but I think Vos is the better duelist.

Probably Vos....

@JediXMan said:

I'm giving this to Vos for now, due to the proximity. I might give it to Mundi due to possibly better TK feats if they were farther apart, but I think Vos is the better duelist.

Agreed.

Maybe thirty or thirty-five would be sufficient. Vos is probably a greater duelist, and if Mundi can't use his TK to its best effect, he's probably going to lose.

LOL, Silver, I thought you said you hated wiki sources..... :D

Not really convinced that Ki-Adi is a better telekinetic. Ki-Adi's best TK feat is lifting a skiff out of sand on Tatooine.

Gallery

LOL, Silver, I thought you said you hated wiki sources..... :D

@Silver2467: I know, I was joking with you.

I have to go, so I'll post the full argument later.

@Silver2467: That hat makes Mundi look like some Chinese old man.....

Indeed, Ki-Adi Mundi has shown high levels of saber prowess. Not to mention that one of Ataru's weaknesses was blaster fire, and Mundi held his ground fairly well in multiple fights which included blaster shots. He also deflected blaster bolts from multiple clone troops at close range and managed to redirect two of them back to slay two Clones. Also, in this fight, there is indeed one enemy only, which Ataru is best suited for (Zez-Kai Ell says this, and others).

Vos is also trained in Vaapad, but isn't a master of it. However, he has held his own against the like of Sora Bulq, though, which is fairly impressive.

I think they are quite close in saber duelling, however, but I'm probably still going for Voss.

Vos is also trained in Vaapad, but isn't a master of it.

However, he has held his own against the like of Sora Bulq, though, which is fairly impressive.

@Silver2467: Well, he was having telepathic problems then.

@Silver2467: Okay, "telepathic" is an incorrect term to describe it. Yes, he was wrestling with the Dark Side. But without having to wrestle with such, he would have fared much more decently. I still think he is probably winning this fight.

Yes, he was wrestling with the Dark Side. But without having to wrestle with such, he would have fared much more decently.

@Silver2467: The only thing was, he never really overcame his dark side during the duelling part. He was still struggling against it. If he wasn't struggling like that, he would have fared better. I never said that feat surpasses that of Ki-Adi Mundi fighting Grievous. Also, Mundi lost even with the aid of multiple other Jedi, including Shaak Ti and Aayla Secura.

If he wasn't struggling like that, he would have fared better.

I never said that feat surpasses that of Ki-Adi Mundi fighting Grievous.

So where the disparity in combat efficiency lies escapes me.

Also, Mundi lost even with the aid of multiple other Jedi, including Shaak Ti and Aayla Secura.

The fact that Ki-Adi was not at peak condition at the time and the fact that Ataru, his preferred lightsaber form, is not well-suited to fighting multiple enemies or a single enemy with multiple weapons speaks well of his prowess.

@Silver2467: It's more an assumption/inference. Its more difficult to fight when you're dealing with a second problem.

Okay.

And he lost his lightsaber and was using another. And he was disarmed once again and was saved by the clones.

Yes, he demonstrated skill.

@Silver2467: It's more an assumption/inference. Its more difficult to fight when you're dealing with a second problem.

And he lost his lightsaber and was using another. And he was disarmed once again and was saved by the clones.

So where the disparity in combat efficiency lies escapes me.

@Silver2467: I never said Quin was a better duelist....

I think he could still win overall.

@Silver2467: Duelling is not everything.

I said he could (massive emphasis on could) win overall.

@Silver2467: Duelling is not everything.

I said he could (massive emphasis on could) win overall.

@Silver2467: I didn't mean that, I meant TK or other Force abilities might be used in a fight, though I would agree that this fight would consist mainly (if not all) of saber combat.

I am going with Vos. I think he has more impressive feats.

@SithLantern93 said:

I am going with Vos. I think he has more impressive feats.

LOL...... look at the argument on the previous page. Ki-Adi Mundi would probably win majority duelling, but I see Vos being capable of winning.

Bumping a three year old thread . . . now.

@silver2467: The second guy dies when he tries to do this:

Why........Just why....

@zetsumoto: Hah I love that.

Mundi. Not even a question

Mundi comfortably

Ki-Adi.

Quinlan Vos wins.

Mundi 10/10 with difficulty.

Mundi, most likely, though it isn't comfortable or 10/10.