@stevon: Well, I'm not sure where you got your information, but someone got things pretty mixed up somewhere along the line. I'll see if I can straighten it out without writing a whole essay.
Yes, when Yuga Khan overthrew DS, DS's plan was to have Orion "kill" him. However, this was not near the Source Wall, it was on Apokolips, within the mind of The Lump. The death was only intended to be a virtual one, meaning even if Orion had followed through, it wouldn't have actually killed Darkseid anyway. I also do not recall any references to this event in Byrnes works, and even if he had somehow retconned it into Orion doing what Darkseid had wanted, like I said, it was a virtual death anyway, so I don't see why it would matter at all. This event is in New Gods v2 21, from Dec 1990, so it wouldn't go back to 89 anyway.
Now, Orion does kill Darkseid within the Source Wall in New Gods v3 2, which wasn't published until Nov 1995. Darkseid uses technology to breach the Wall, and Orion follows him. They battle within the Source, with Orion eventually killing DS (DS wanted to die here). The Source does become corrupted, but it is not because of Darkseid's soul, it is because of Orion committing the horrible act of patricide within what is supposed to be pure and undefiled. It's also worth noting that Darkseid is actually dead here.
Now, you could argue that any appearances DS made around this time would have to be avatars. However, like I said, he was supposed to actually be dead. There is no mention of avatars popping up or anything like that from that time. Darkseid also resurrects himself at the end of issue 6. So even if you do go with the avatar route, the only other issues this would be relevant to are Wonder Woman 102-104, and JLA Annual 9. Not really major events, and with the way concurrent stories sometimes work in comics, it is entirely possible those events were simply intended to happen before New Gods v3 started (the story arc in WW, for example, started with WW 101, which was indeed published shortly before NGv3).
Darkseid is later trapped in the Source Wall again in New Gods v3 11. Yeah, just a few months later. However, he's back out again by the end of issue 15. Again, even if we assume he sent out avatars at this time to take his place, his only other appearance in this short time frame is Total Justice 2-3, which again has the issue of concurrent story arcs, and again is hardly a major appearance anyway.
Darkseid is trapped in the Source Wall yet again at the end of Genesis 4, Nov 1997. This time he doesn't come back until Jack Kirby's Fourth World 18, Aug 1998. However, once again, there are not actually any appearances made by DS in this timeframe that could be explained with Avatars; the only other place he shows up is in the JLA Rock of Ages storyline, which is an alternate future anyway.
So even if you assume Darkseid made avatars every time he's stuck in the Source Wall, he's never in there for very long, and none of these events correspond with any of his major appearances elsewhere. And while I would not mind seeing what Byrne intended in a blog post of his or something, an author's own inner thoughts aren't always automatically canon if what they "intended" wasn't actually published.
@The_Imperator: Yes, your first scan is "the" source for the Desaad retcons, but you'll note is only shows one scene with Darkseid and Superman, meaning it only retcons one of their encounters, and there were 3 in total prior to that issue. The second scan is not actually a retcon, it just reveals Desaad to have been impersonating Darkseid in that issue. It does not actually suggest he had been doing this in any other issues. Your last 2 scans also don't actually retcon anything; while they reveal Darkseid is capable of creating avatars (at least while trapped in the Source Wall), they do not actually refer to him using this ability in any specific instance. There is no reference to him sending an avatar against Doomsday, for example. It even explicitly states that Darkseid prefers not to create avatars, in general, meaning it is actually unlikely for any particular appearance of his to have been an avatar unless stated otherwise.
Basically, we can just use the old adage "if it looks like a duck, walks like a duck, quacks like a duck, its probably a duck." Aside from the first scan, none of those instances actually referred back to older events where you could replace Darkseid with an avatar or Desaad.
Final Crisis was Morrison obviously trying to retcon the New Gods, especially Darkseid, into being something they had never been before. Darkseid's statement about his enemies having only faced the "idea of a god" before is just as much grandiose hyperbole as his statements about being infinite and omnipotent. Even at the beginning of Final Crisis, Darkseid is dying because he had been fatally wounded by Orion. Is Orion supposed to be a multiversal badass now too? He seemed like the same old Orion when they found his corpse. And apparently, despite being "god incarnate" this time, Darkseid was actually taken down with even less of a fight than he has been at other times. Despite all the craziness going on in Final Crisis, it doesn't actually make him a formidable opponent.
I think you missed the point I made about Darkseid's supposed mind control. Scott Free believes Darkseid has mind control. Scott Free has never actually been subject to it, or seen it in action, he just assumes it is there. I have little difficulty believing everyone on Apokolips is raised with the idea that Darkseid can monitor and control their thoughts at will; he is, after all, essentially the deific version of Big Brother. However, there still remains the simply fact that Darkseid has never been shown to use either telepathy or mind control outside of GDS.
So, we basically have one statement from one character making the assumption that Darkseid has this power, vs. Darkseid's entire 40+ year history where he is never shown using it. I think the lack of feats carries more weight than one statement by Scott Free.
The scan of Darkseid and the Flash you showed is from the Super Powers line of comics, which were basically tie-ins to the TV show and toyline, and didn't really have anything to do with the normal DC Universe. Even if you did want to use them, they would give you pretty mixed results. Sure, in one instance he can tag the Flash. On the other hand, later he needed a machine to make his Omega Effect 1,000 times more powerful than normal just to destroy the Earth, and it was still stopped by just Dr. Fate and Superman. The Super Powers line is also where that infamous scene of Darkseid getting mugged in an alley comes from, if you've ever seen those scans and wondered what was up with them.
Log in to comment