Pie vs Cake - Battles

#1 Posted by King Saturn (210944 posts) - 5 years, 3 months ago - Show Bio

Which dessert do you like more ? Is in Apple Pie ? Chocolate Cake ? Ice Cream Cake ? Key Lime Pie ? Which dessert is your favorite Pie or Cake ?

Online

#2 Posted by Andferne (38808 posts) - 5 years, 3 months ago - Show Bio

Strawberry Cake with Strawberry iceing.

#3 Posted by Alexander Anderson (4031 posts) - 5 years, 3 months ago - Show Bio

Apple pie with a slice of sharp cheddar cheese. Heaven.

#4 Posted by Akira Overdrive (9955 posts) - 5 years, 3 months ago - Show Bio

Yeah um...

Ive got to go with Pie...unless the cake is like all chocalate with the caramel or german cake..whatever..chocalate cake is damn good..but pie pwns otherwise lol

#5 Posted by kuchiku (4070 posts) - 5 years, 3 months ago - Show Bio

pie is moister then cake

#6 Posted by Static Shock (47330 posts) - 5 years, 3 months ago - Show Bio

Cake. Chocolate cake. And, if it's Cookies and Cream Ice Cream cake, then it's a done deal!

#7 Posted by Methos (40100 posts) - 5 years, 3 months ago - Show Bio

#8 Posted by Morphid (1166 posts) - 5 years, 3 months ago - Show Bio

Pie by a long shot, can't beat the boison berry:)

#9 Posted by Superkitty (1057 posts) - 5 years, 3 months ago - Show Bio

As for eating, I slightly favor pies, especially if it's a la mode...

But in battle terms of throwing and hi-jinx, pie wins "hands down"

#10 Posted by Phoenix God (389 posts) - 5 years, 3 months ago - Show Bio

If I make my apple pie, then yes, pie. If I am out to eat with friends, I will never order pie because it is hardly ever good; but at restuarants, the chocolate cake is always good.

#11 Posted by Cosmic Sentinel (3743 posts) - 5 years, 3 months ago - Show Bio

#12 Posted by Methias (437 posts) - 5 years, 3 months ago - Show Bio

Pie for me. More variety; cheesecake (called cake, but it's pie), lemon meringue, berry, apple, pumpkin.

#13 Posted by Shawnbaby (5858 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

#14 Posted by nickzambuto (7806 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

I'll lol if this turns into a serious debate.

#15 Posted by god_spawn (30402 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

I hate cake for the most part. Pie wins in a crust stomp.

Moderator

#16 Posted by MonsterStomp (2695 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

Strawberry cheese cake!

#17 Posted by Dane (10162 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

@god_spawn: I disagree. Cake is delicious and comes in many varieties and textures. I'm willing to post scans as evidence.

#18 Posted by _Whisper_ (3158 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

I was all set to come in and say pie until I saw Dane's evidence in favor of cake.

#19 Posted by god_spawn (30402 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

@Dane: I'll agree with the second scan. The rest don't look that good. And pie also looks delicious and comes in many varieties.

....Dammit. They all look the same.

Feel the wrath of my PUMPKIN AND KEYLIME PIES!!!

Moderator

#20 Posted by sync1 (643 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

Cookies & Cream icecream Cake solos.

#21 Posted by Night Thrasher (2703 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

Spice Cake is the best!!!

#22 Posted by Dane (10162 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

@god_spawn:

Dat pumpkin.

#23 Posted by Sufferthorn (1597 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

Pie is Superior

#24 Posted by Gritterr (383 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

Pie in a muderstomp. side note cheesecake should not count as cake it is a different animal. Ice cream cake is OP and should be DQ'd

#25 Posted by acer51 (1824 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

Pie stomps! anyone who thinks Cake wins is a LOLING trolling fanboy.

#26 Posted by god_spawn (30402 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

@Dane: ...But what if it is ice cream cake or that molten cake from Chili's?? Pumpkin pie better watch his crust.

Moderator

#27 Posted by Dane (10162 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

@god_spawn: Ice cream cake is pretty dynamite. I'm considering making an ice cream cake out of peppermint ice cream in the shape of Swamp Thing because of reasons.

#28 Posted by acer51 (1824 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

@god_spawn said:

@Dane: ...But what if it is ice cream cake or that molten cake from Chili's?? Pumpkin pie better watch his crust.

Ice cream cake melts fast, sure it's tough while it lasts but in a few minutes it melts, while pie will last hours and still taste good as new.

it's still good for leftover days later.

Ice cream cakes got nuthin.

#29 Posted by Gritterr (383 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

Cake seems to need gimmicks to compete with pie

#30 Posted by Bane_of_sith (2273 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

Pie=Galactus. Cake=Puck. Pie FTW

#31 Posted by Xanni15 (5923 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

I hate pie.

Cake wins.

#32 Posted by Bane_of_sith (2273 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

Pie encompasses so much more than cake,,,fruit pies,,,meat pies,,pizza pies,,,and every guys favorite ...honey pie

#33 Posted by TDK_1997 (9650 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

Cake.

#34 Posted by Ghostalt (329 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

Stalemate

#35 Posted by The_Lunact_And_Manic (2905 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

Cake Stomps.

#36 Posted by redbird3rdboywonder (3299 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

Only if it's The Rock's definition of pie does pie even have a chance. Otherwise Cake STOMPS in an epic fashion

#37 Posted by Baldy (5021 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

This isn't a battle, belongs in off topic, and on top of that is a mismatch. Pie is obviously superior.

#38 Posted by icysloth (1305 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

Buttermilk pie

#39 Posted by Soul_Rebel (1074 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

Cakes from Friendly's always looks so delicious, but i love coconut cream and pumpkin pie... Hard choice, but i'll go with cake.

#40 Posted by charlieboy (7023 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

peanut butter pie. mmm. and i like red velvet cake. i am torn.

#41 Posted by venomoushatred1001 (11766 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

Pie.

#42 Posted by Batking200 (141 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

Are u forgetting cake gets eaten at ftl speeds. Cake stomps

#43 Posted by YourNeighborhoodComicGeek (13821 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

Stalemate.

#44 Posted by YourNeighborhoodComicGeek (13821 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

Stalemate.

#45 Posted by Strider92 (11207 posts) - 8 months, 5 days ago - Show Bio

Pie.......the cake is a lie.