Percy Vs Jason Vs Carter

@ShootingNova: In my opinion he gets last

@darktiger: Wha....? Seriously? He has the most experience, so that's an advantage. He was instructed in swordsmanship by a god. He's done pretty well, for somebody who was hardly trained properly.

Horus is not better then percy who has beaten gods who have lots of experience,he beat ares and hades,and carter is the worst sword fighter out of all of them@ShootingNova said:

@darktiger: Wha....? Seriously? He has the most experience, so that's an advantage. He was instructed in swordsmanship by a god. He's done pretty well, for somebody who was hardly trained properly.

any other takers

@darktiger said:

Horus is not better then percy who has beaten gods who have lots of experience,he beat ares and hades,and carter is the worst sword fighter out of all of them@ShootingNova said:

@darktiger: Wha....? Seriously? He has the most experience, so that's an advantage. He was instructed in swordsmanship by a god. He's done pretty well, for somebody who was hardly trained properly.

Why do you type the response, then click "quote"?

Anyways, Percy beat a low tier god with no feats and when did he beat Hades, again?

Percy got owned by an Empousa and could barely hold his own against a non-fully formed Kronos that was being held back by Luke.

And Percy>Horus?

When Percy disintegrates she-lions with a single slash, or uses successful combat magic to summon an enormous avatar, that fights Set (who is much stronger than Ares) at his peak, in the desert, at the Red Pyramid, or enters a thousand hosts and has millenia of experience and can spread his essence over war monuments, human hosts and so on then you can tell me he owns Horus.

@ShootingNova: On the first book he fought the wife of typhon he beat hades on Last olympian also ,beat antaeus another god,hyperion,Third most powerful titan,And fought Kronos by himself,Percy can beat horus and I don't care what you think

@darktiger: Percy didn't fight Kronos by himself, he fought a non-fully formed Kronos that was being held back by Luke. If you don't care what I think, good for you.

ok he still beat hyperion and is a better combatant then carter stronger underwater can summon water that killed a million people in battle of the labryninth without achilles curse

@darktiger: He was winning against Hyperion, the Satyrs covered him with a tree.

Being stronger underwater is irrelevant in this match because you said they were fighting at the peak of Mount Olympus.

Great. He can summon water. They'll drink it....... :D

From what you told me, Jason can survive that.

ok you think carter wins@ShootingNova:

@darktiger said:

ok you think carter wins@ShootingNova:

Not necessarily. Without Horus, he probably isn't.

@ShootingNova: Without horus percy wins

@darktiger: I don't know enough on Jason, but from what you gave me, Peter Johnson wins.

@darktiger:

You must genuinely not have read the Kane Chronicles, or you are a massive fanboy for Percy.

Carter has so much varied Magic that it doesn't matter if he was the worst swordsman, which he isn't but nothing stops him from BFR'ing them to Ma'at or summoning Hapi.

@ShootingNova

Cater roflstomps with correct use of magic, though in a sword fight Percy would win due to precog and better fighting skills than Jason. Despite Carter being the best swordsman precog makes this a basic win in a sword fight for Percy...

@Pwok21: Was this from Serpent's Shadow? I haven't read it.

I dunno if he "rotflstomps", but he could win.

@ShootingNova:

He gained the ability to summon in 'The Serpents Shadow' but he only called on Hapi (God of the Nile) but the spell would work on any of them.

my foot with prep.

/thread

anyone else

@ShootingNova said:

@darktiger: I don't know enough on Jason, but from what you gave me, Peter Johnson wins.

ok

@ImTheDamnBatman said:

Percy?... I don't know much about these others

@ChaosBlazer: We talked about each character I think you should know a little bit

@Pwok21: Right.

anyone else

any other takers

CARTER KANE

<--------

IMO Percy then Jason then Carter

Percy is the best swordsmen and tied with Jason on mastership of powers

While Carter is more versatile and has better gear

But in Son of Sobek Percy was shown to beat Carter easily in sword to sword and survived a fist of horus to the chest.

I think Carter loses to Jason because Carter is the least skilled and still gets pretty tired when he uses his powers.

I think Percy beats Jason because he has before ( well kinda ), he tanked the lightning and got straight back up and they're equal in swordsmanship.

@joewell:

Yeah but you and I both know the outcome was decided by fanvote.

Realistically Percy could beat Horus-Carter with full elemental powers...but surviving a blow that shook a mountain and OHKO'd the people Percy had to stab several dozen times, use creative thinking, or cut off their limbs to kill?

And beating the Avatar of War who was vastly outmatching him in physicals"

Yeah...no.

@thedarklordpandamonium: Its was? I honestly didn't know that.

I don't understand what you're saying here sorry...

With horus I agree Carter would beat them both ( unless Percy had Achilles then i'm not sure )

Without it Percy is a much better swordsmen and strategist, and has better stamina, durability, and power output

Yeah. There was a poll on Riordan's website and everyone voted Percy, so Percy won. You didn't know?

Yeah obv with Horus Carter would pwn, and in this fight he has Horus, so yep.

And I agree...Percy is definitely a lot better than base Carter, but the Avatar powerup is ridiculous.

@thedarklordpandamonium:

No! But its still made by the same person and there still in the same universe, so its still technically cannon. And it was really the same as the Jason-Percy fight, it was pretty even throughout and really Carter got the last move ( tieing Percy's sword to his head )

OP said on the first page he doesn't have Horus

And its not thaaat bad. I honestly think Achilles Percy could stand a chance.

oh well then carter is screwed

Percy ftw

Percy has already beaten Jason before, and I don't see why he can't take Carter.

@joewell: Percy with both Achilles curse and water would beat even Horus enhanced Carter. He beats gods consistently WITHOUT the curse.

@logy5000: did you read son of sobek? he already beat karter too lol xD

In all honesty, I haven't. I've read everything related to Percy except that. I heard it was fan voted though. It would make sense for him to beat Carter.

Percy Jackson.

It was.

It doesn't make any sense for him to beat Horus-enhanced Carter though, but the OP already said no Horus.

Percy does have experience in beating gods though. He's beaten 3 gods, as well as 3 titans, as well as 2 giants.

What exactly does Horus do to Carter?

It's a godlike magic enhancement. Sorta like the Superman Prime effect.

@cooldes: @logy5000: He didn't beat Carter, its was tied ( And for anyone who wants to read it its here: http://www.epubbud.com/book.php?g=QEF8VYV3 )

And he usually doesn't beat them without interruption or help.

@joewell: He beat Ares, Hades, and Phobus by himself; granted he was amped when he beat Hades.

Percy.

this battle is would be awsome. Honestly id say carter would lose easily to either percy or jason.. i mean those two faced gods,giants,titans,monster etc... if carter uses horus' power they can just dodge and wait 'till he burns himself out of magic power and kill him. then it would be percy vs jason and percy is better so percy would win

Percy.

i want to say carter but percy has that hurricane thing going on he just has better feats than jason and carter too.

Jackson