Pacino's Scarface vs DeNiro's Max Cady

Al Pacino's Cuban, loud mouth, coke snorting, machine gun toting gangster vs Robert DeNiro's savage, methodical, obsessive ex convict accused rapist. Who wins?

DeNiro's Cady kills Pacino's Scarface.

@powerherc: how do you figure? I think so too, just wonder where you see Cady being better.

Cady is:

• Smarter.
• More disciplined.
• More patient.
• Not coked up.
• Just as ruthless

Cady

@powerherc: true... although I wasn't picturing scarface coked up in battle lol

Scarface tanked like a barrage of assualt rifle bullets and still kept going

....prolly cause he was coked-up....but still

By the time he became a badass he was always coked up, so it stands to reason he'd be coked up when Cady came calling.

@powerherc: true... but from what I saw it made him more ruthless more impervious to pain

@blackdog2009: @powerherc: Hey being "coked-up" could be considered "in-character" for ol'Tony Montana. That gives him an advantage as far as I'm concerned, seeing what it took to finally put him down

Did Tony snort any coke?

Police stomp both.

@immortal777: hadn't thought of it, but we're going with YES. :)

So I just watched Cape Fear for the first time and had to see if there was any battles with Max Cady. Dude was absolutely insane. He’s seemingly harder to put down than actual inhumans like Jason Vorhees or Michael Myers. Cady was damn impressive, but so is coked up Tony Montana. Cady is much more fit, more skilled in H2H, and with stealth. Scarface is a total bullet sponge though. Cady wins but only after a fight that rivals the length and intensity of Peter vs the Chicken.