Odin and Thor (marvel) vs Odin and Thor (Norse Mythology)

Are they on the same level? If not state your reason.

No, the mythology is set up differently from the comics.

@Nefarious said:

No, the mythology is set up differently from the comics.

Did you understand the question?

who's more powerful? And please if you don't know much about mythology, don't comment.

@yeimsick said:

Explain more please, hand to hand combat or full out battle with no rules?

No rules. It's just which version is more powerful?

@Trinity00 said:

Norse they're actual omnipotents.

They are far far below that..... From what I've heard norse gods are kinda weak.

@Trinity00 said:

@kingkronos said:

@Trinity00 said:

Norse they're actual omnipotents.

They are far far below that..... From what I've heard norse gods are kinda weak.

I heard Odin is a true omnipotent.

And you heard that from.........

@ShootingNova: Such as?

@FourthDeity said:

@ShootingNova: Such as?

What ShootingNova is trying to say is that in mythology gods don't have powers they have power. In mythology you don't see a god that can't do something, it's just that it depends on the god's level of power and his limits. Unlike comic characters who have powers instead of power.

I think they're close to equal, since a lot of the Norse stories are referenced in the comics. However, they appear weaker in Marvel compared to the other characters, such as Galactus.

@ShootingNova said:

@kingkronos said:

@FourthDeity said:

@ShootingNova: Such as?

What ShootingNova is trying to say is that in mythology gods don't have powers they have power. In mythology you don't see a god that can't do something, it's just that it depends on the god's level of power and his limits. Unlike comic characters who have powers instead of power.

There are gods that couldn't do certain things in mythology, many times. Not just Norse, but in all mythologies.

True, that depends on the limits of a gods' power.

@kingkronos: @ShootingNova: ahh I see Thank you both for clarifying but if marvel odin vs the people mythology odin fought I'm almost certain he would one shot them too.

@FourthDeity said:

@kingkronos: @ShootingNova: ahh I see Thank you both for clarifying but if marvel odin vs the people mythology odin fought I'm almost certain he would one shot them too.

And who the hell is that?

Also if you mean myth odin then no. Odin was very powerful in mythology.

@kingkronos: Nah not odin. The people Mythology odin one shotted

@FourthDeity said:

@kingkronos: Nah not odin. The people Mythology odin one shotted

Who the hell is "the people Mythology odin"???

@kingkronos: You said Mythology Odin one shotted who ever he fought right?

Im saying Marvel Odin could do the same.

@FourthDeity said:

@kingkronos: You said Mythology Odin one shotted who ever he fought right?

Im saying Marvel Odin could do the same.

And when did I ever state that?

And no marvel odin could not one shot anybody from marvel and escpecially not from mythology.

I said he is powerful but he's not going around one shotting people in mythology. He is a wise and powerful warrior. In norse myth, the gods were all warriors. So odin being the god of war means alot.

@ShootingNova said:

@ShootingNova said:

@FourthDeity said:

@ShootingNova: Such as?

Even looking at the relics you can tell they have more power. When Odin throws Gungnir in Marvel, it hits and comes back. In mythology, it would always hit and always kill.

I May have misinterpreted that

Odin is overpowered in the mythology as compared to this current Marvel Odin who's old and no longer a solo war machine.
As for the Thors -
Myth Thor is the absolute god of Thunder.  His hammer when it clashes generates electricity.  He isn't like Thor who charges up.

Bump

@ShootingNova said:

Why the bump?

@ShootingNova said:

The fight is as easy as this: Mythological Odin throws Gungnir, Marvel Odin dies.

LOL. Nova, you scrub. How could you?

Marvel team stomps. Better feats in almost everything.

Did you just quote yourself? And you are contradicting your own opinion, well, and sound unlike you generally do.. everything ok mate?

(shared account or dual personality?)

@ShootingNova said:

@PrinceAragorn1: It was kind of a joke...... but it was kind of true because I didn't want people to get mislead by my past garbage.

Changed personality then.. lameeee... dual would have been much cooler :p

@ShootingNova said:

@Mad8Baller said:

Odin is overpowered in the mythology as compared to this current Marvel Odin who's old and no longer a solo war machine. As for the Thors - Myth Thor is the absolute god of Thunder. His hammer when it clashes generates electricity. He isn't like Thor who charges up.

How is he overpowered when you look at someone like Surtr, Jormungandr, Fenrir, Ymir etc.

Btw, Thor did beat Jormungand in ragnorok, though he died in effort due to venom. Surtur was nemesis/destined enemy of freyr, I daresay thor could've handled him.. fenrir was beaten by vidar, and thor may have done as good. Idk how odin failed and vidar succeeded though. Ymir, we really don't know how tough the battle was, but probably I'd was stronger than thor..

There really aren't a lot who can beat thor 1 on 1 in the norse myths (I haven't touched it in a while though)

One battle I'd die to watch was tyr vs thor though. The war God vs the strongest aesir.. it'd be incredible.

@ShootingNova said:

@PrinceAragorn1: Yes, I know.

Odin failed because the Norns destined him to die by Fenrir, and so it was. Tyr died killing Garmr.

still, the guy needed a bit more focus, only thing I can remember him being distinct was losing his arm. Kind of sad.. and he may not have died with both arms..

@ShootingNova said:

@PrinceAragorn1: He lost a hand, not an arm.

hand then..

@Racob7: Myth odin has a 100% kill spear.

@ShootingNova said:

@Racob7: Kindly explain to me how shattering mountains and calling upon featless lightning is winning against throwing Mjolnir which travels at FTL speeds, creating cosmic hurricanes, summoning winds from a thousand worlds, and so forth?

touche. Only awesome thing thor has done in the myth was lifting the world serpent and holding his own against time/age..

Norse dominate