Nolanverse Villains vs Watchmen

These are the film versions only. In character.

Nolanverse Villains:

• Ra's Al Ghul
• The Joker
• Bane
• Scarecrow
• Two-Face
• Catwoman
• Talia

~vs~

Watchmen:

• Nite Owl II
• Rorschach
• Ozymandias
• The Comedian
• Silk Spectre II

Round 1:

1. Standard gear.
2. Random encounter.
3. Battle takes place in TDKR Gotham City with the city in chaos; some scattered civilians.
4. Win by death, KO, or incapacitation.

Round 2:

1. A week of prep for both teams.
2. Battle takes place in relatively peaceful Gotham City.
3. Innocent bystanders present.
4. Win by death, KO, or incapacitation.

Round 3:

The Watchmen must stop each of these villains and their dastardly schemes from the Nolanverse trilogy. Can they do it?

Team Watchmen win

Watchmen stomps Round 1. Rest goes to Batman villans.

What @wardemon32 said

I see Watchmen winning Round 2 and 3, Villains winning Round 1

@batman242: @reaverlation: @wardemon32: @willpayton: Can y'all elaborate a bit? Explanations please.

The Nolan team have some weak links, while the Watchmen are all fairly solid... and Ozy is a beast, both physically and with prep. Nolan's team only has one advantage, numbers, but IMO not enough to counter the Watchmen. It'd be a good fight, but the Watchmen win in the end, with Ozy as MVP.

@venomoustaco:

Well straight H2H their definately not winning. All of Watchmen are basically superhuman. Batmans villians may have teh skilled guys for the most part but Watchmen are also skilled and can take much more hits. Thier only hope if the scaregas really.

In all of the Batman movies the villians has done excellent things with prep.

• Bane taking over all of Gotham. High-Jacking Batmans weapons and vehicles. Aiplance scene.
• Jokers & Scarecrows bomb traps.
• Etc...

And their not going to win round 3. Joker is just too smart and so is Bane. Both have been shown to be tactical geniuses and some of the rest.

@willpayton:

For Ozy to do what he did it took him years to do. I doubt he's going to out prep Batmans villans with just a weeks prep.

None of the Batman villains are as smart as Ozy. None of them have the money and resources that Ozy has. In a prep battle, Ozy destroys them.

The Watchmen have numbers here while the only people on Nolan's team that can compete is Bane and Ra's who I can see winning against everyone here 1 on 1 except Ozy.In the prep round,Nolanverse has all of Wayne Enterprises at their disposal like the tumblers to wreck house against the Watchman while they only have Nite Owl's ship which won't do against multiple tumblers.In the Scenario round,the Watchman die easily especially to Ra's al Ghul's plan as they have no clue about the fear toxin in which the Watchmen will kill each other.With Joker,that depends on his scenario.They'll fail against Bane against his army and a back up Nuke.Two Face is a complete non factor with Catwoman

pretty much this...

But then Joker might win... by holding a gun to his head and convincing the Watchmen (like Dent) that he is just an agent of chaos.

What idiotic logic... yoh retard! why don't you shoot the kingpin who is ultimately responsable for your gf's death in the face and then finish off the (dirty cop) minions? I thought you went to school, don't they teach logic + vengeance? How the flip did you become a DA if you couldn't think that??

good day

@theonetaichou: Lol. I always wondered why Two-Face didn't just shoot the Joker. Hahaha, I guess it's not his M.O.

@willpayton:

They don't necesarily have to be as smart as Ozy to beat him. Smarts>Tacticion, Tacticion>Smarts. You have one smart and tactical man vs 4 tactical men(Not unculding Catwoman, and Two-Face).

They may not have the money and resoures but they sure do have the connections. If they can get their hands on Batmans tech they win. There's nothing to really show for Ozy when it comes to a weeks prep and his tech.

@wardemon32: @allstarsuperman: @willpayton: Y'all seem to believe the Watchmen stomp in a random encounter, would this change if Batman was added only to Round 1?

@venomoustaco: Watchmen Characters were near/are superhuman

@allstarsuperman: Aside from Ozymandias (and possibly Rorschach), I don't think they were superhuman. But anyways, would the outcome of Round 1 change if Batman was thrown into the mix, standard gear and all?

@venomoustaco: Nite-Owl and Silk Spectre were more superhuman then Rorschach. they broke bones and kicked people like 5 feet away.

Even then I think the Watchment still win. Team Batman will have numbers, but Watchmen still have Ozy and Comedian, who's standard gear includes automatic weapons... and he's perfectly willing to start the fight going for kills. The Comedian alone could take out half the Batman team within the first 30 seconds. Night Owl's standard gear also includes his laser, which is deadly if he goes bloodlusted.

If we're talking just h2h, then Watchmen would still win. Ozy could fight 3 of the other team at once. Scarecrow and Two-Face would go down quickly, and then the numbers are even. Again here Ozy is MVP cause while the others can more or less fight on even terms, no one can take out Ozy and he'll take out people one by one.

Watchmen still win.

@venomoustaco:

I doubt it would make a difference for round 1.

@willpayton: Joker has firearms as standard gear as well among other weapons. Scarecrow has scare gas. Two-Face, although possibly not as experienced, also has a trusty revolver. I'm not saying they wouldn't go down, but would it really be that easy?

P.S. All characters are in character. No bloodlust.

@allstarsuperman: Right, I forgot about that. However, wouldn't that indicate that Bane was "superhuman" considering his uncanny ability to punch through walls and break pillars?

Yeah but Jocker only had that machine gun in one scene, from what I recall he wasnt armed the rest of the time. But, even if he is, he's no match for Comedian who's a trained killer and armed to the teeth. Jocker is also too random to be much good in this fight. He'll go down quickly. Two-Face might get off some lucky hits with a gun, but mostly he'll go down.

yeah, but he had a plot device on his face

@willpayton: Fair enough.

This.

Ozy solos round one.

Nolanverse wins other rounds.

Watchmen. Ozymandias is the MVP.

Watchmen all rounds.

For sure.