Nightwing vs Bane

bane....

@EpitomeofCool:
OP said who wins and why

i think Bane wins, he Smart and strong

he could just bring down the sewer system on nightwing's head

Bane

Bane wins because he has the advantage in close-range.

@entropy_aegis said:

"Bane "

"

@entropy_aegis said:

"Bane "

 

What if it was Batdick? "

I think that Dick has no chance to defeat him H2H, Bane defeated him twice while off venom and Nightwing only has the chance of winning this if he use gadgets.

I think Bane can a younger version of Nightwing,but current Nightwing defeats him.

@Stronger said:

I think Bane can a younger version of Nightwing,but current Nightwing defeats him.

That was training simulation.

@Stronger: This. Nightwing can take this. He became the Batman and he was good. With no prep he could deal with Bane, but he had to be really careful with getting too close. Bane would have the advantage there.

@BigCimmerian: @Phaedrusgr:

I think Nightwing and even Tim Drake(versions after the Battle For tthe Cowl story arc.) can take him.

Bane would defeat classic versions though.

@Morpheus_ said:

Bane wins for the simple reason that they fought twice, and he already beat Dick in both encounters. And in close quarters, where Nightwing cannot properly utilize his trademark agility, the disadvantage is all the more grave.

@Stronger: You think that Tim could take this? Don't know about that, but I can't accept Bane beating Nightwing. Dick is the best after Bruce for me. He became the Batman and he honoured the mantle, before getting his own mantle again. Nightwing isn't boy wonder anymore. It seems to me that nobody can understand this, not even the writers sometimes.

Pre or Post BFTC, Bane wins. It's not like he's been in hibernation while Dick and Tim suddenly developed mad new skills.

Bane.

I think it could go both ways,but thats only because its in the sewer. Anywhere else with room to move ,dick wins.

@Stronger said:

I think Bane can a younger version of Nightwing,but current Nightwing defeats him.

Did you really try to pass off a training simulation of Bane who did nothing but spam firearms as the real deal?

Bane wins. He's already smacked around Grayson with ease twice. I don't believe it would be as easy as his victories on panel, but he's skilled enough and physically powerful enough to generate the same outcome for a majority.

nightwing

@jeanroygrant said:

nightwing

Disagree.

@k4tzm4n said:

@jeanroygrant said:

nightwing

Disagree.

why

@jeanroygrant: Look above your post.

@BigCimmerian: @Phaedrusgr:

I think Nightwing and even Tim Drake(versions after the Battle For tthe Cowl story arc.) can take him.

Bane would defeat classic versions though.

@(((Prodigy))) said:

@Stronger said:

@BigCimmerian: @Phaedrusgr:

I think Nightwing and even Tim Drake(versions after the Battle For tthe Cowl story arc.) can take him.

Bane would defeat classic versions though.

You think Tim Drake could beat Bane? LOL

-_-

Unamused face is unamused.

And for the record (Stronger), Bane embarrassed classic Drake. He'd wreck current, too.

@(((Prodigy))) said:

@Stronger said:

@BigCimmerian: @Phaedrusgr:

I think Nightwing and even Tim Drake(versions after the Battle For tthe Cowl story arc.) can take him.

Bane would defeat classic versions though.

You think Tim Drake could beat Bane? LOL

-_-

Unamused face is unamused.

And for the record (Stronger), Bane embarrassed classic Drake. He'd wreck current, too.

@(((Prodigy))): Agreed.

Any scans of there encounters?

Bane.

@karrob: Bane vs Nightwing or Bane vs Tim Drake?

@k4tzm4n: Bane vs Nightwing

Nightbane.

Given the close quarters and Bane having access to venom, Nightwing loses. 
But, in a more neutral zone without any access to venom, I personally havent seen any reason why Bane would win.......

@Vance Astro said:

Nightbane.

Lol

@buttersdaman000 said:

Given the close quarters and Bane having access to venom, Nightwing loses. But, in a more neutral zone without any access to venom, I personally havent seen any reason why Bane would win.......

How about Bane already beating Nightwing while off venom?

@karrob:

Keep in mind this is under Dixon, the man who wrote a good chunk of the beginning of Nightwing's volume.

Fight 1:

Fight 2:

@k4tzm4n said:

@karrob:

Keep in mind this is under Dixon, the man who wrote a good chunk of the beginning of Nightwing's volume.

Fight 1:

Fight 2:

Damn! Bane ftw

@buttersdaman000: Yes, that's it for those fights. The elbow knocks Nightwing over, and then it turns into Batman vs Bane.

LOL there shouldn't discussion about Tim vs Bane, Bane would one shot him.

@buttersdaman000: You're welcome.

Current Bane Without venom vs Current Nightwing (post "Battle For the Cowl" after being Batman for a good year) I think I'd give it to Nightwing now...he's shown himself to be on par with Bats these days....

Nightwing isn't on par with Batman. Not even close.

@Morpheus_ said:

Nightwing isn't on par with Batman. Not even close.

That is a matter of opinion...which is probably why the argument itself is pretty old...

@Rolandthunder25 said:

@Morpheus_ said:

Nightwing isn't on par with Batman. Not even close.

That is a matter of opinion...which is probably why the argument itself is pretty old...

I can just as easily say Nightwing is on par with Galactus and that will also be a matter of opinion. It wouldn't change the fact that both opinions would be erroneous.