Natsu Dragoneel vs Edward Elric.

This Fight takes place in the desert.

Win By KO only

No BFR

No one is blood lusted.

Both current or final versions (Ed right before he lost his Alchemy)

3 rounds

Round1: pure H2H

Round 2: All out.

Round 3:Ed has philosphers stone and can control it. Natsu is in Lightning-Fire dragon mode.

Who wins and why?

No one?

Round 1: Eric, 2: Natsu, 3 No freackin' idea.

On that note, debating Manga's not necessarily my thing.

Anyone else?

@nelomaxwell: round 1 natsu round 2 natsu again a he can attack from a distance with fire dragon roar oneshoting him round 3 natsu as he's way to fast to be able to be countered by edward of all people

Natsu all 3 rounds effortlessly.

Round 1 goes to Ed 8/10 times. Natsu relies more on his magic to power his punches while Ed fights H2H much more often. And those automail limbs will be able hurt Natsu.

Natsu takes 2 and 3 for the majority. He has superior power output and durability.

@joewell: .. You do understand Natsu fights H2H CONSTANTLY and mixes his dragon slayer magic with it, and has been hit by people FAR stronger than Edward..

@dbvse7: i dont watch fairy tail but i doubt natsu is beating Edward h2h i think ed wins all rounds

@alakemega123: How can you doubt it.. if you've never watched it..?

@dbvse7: i watched a couple episodes and i know a lot of people who like it and they never shut up about it

@dbvse7:

I do. But I believe Edward is still more skilled. Natsu is more of a brawler than a martial artist.

You are right about his durability though. It would take a lot of hits for Ed to put him down, possibly more than he can deliver.

@joewell: @alakemega123: Skill IS debatable. Natsu is more than just a brawler though he's experienced.. you have to give him that much for what he's shown. He may not be an Iron Fist or Batman or Karate Kid but he can hold is own for what he can dish out when it comes to skill.

And yea that's what I mean it doesn't matter if he was better or not.. whats the point when you can't keep you're enemy down. An enemy who's stronger has better durability, and is just as skilled if not pretty damn close.

And still you can't just watch “ a couple of episodes ” and draw a conclusion.

@dbvse7:

Hm. You're right. Looking back on it Natsu can take a lot of damage.

Changin' mah mind. Nastu takes all three in a good fight.

Ed would break his hands trying to punch Natsu.

And one Fire Dragon Roar would blow him away. This isn't equal at all.

Natsu wins all three rounds. Edward is more of a martial artist than natsu but natsu is durable asf. Round two is a slaughter. Round three will be close fight. That philosopher stone ain't no joke but lightning flame dragon mode... O_O

Edward will only win round 3. Philosophers stone = God mode.

Any version of natsu stomps . assuming he still has supply of magic