#1 Posted by MasterAction (671 posts) - - Show Bio

Hi everyone :) I've seen quite a few of these threads in one form or another on the site so thought it'd be cool if I started my own

Basically I'd like you to pick your 5 favourite comic book characters of all time and put them in individual 1 vs 1 matches against my own 5. Obviously try and match them up as fairly as possible, eg if I have Batman and you use Galactus against him then Bruce doesn't have a chance in hell! And on that note please don't choose a team entirely based on mega-powerhouses (Living Tribunal, Beyonder, etc). For all I know your favourite 5 may all be cosmic level but try and keep it reasonable :)

Individual match rules are as follows- Morals off and a fight to the death. Takes place in a completely empty Times Square. No prep, random encounter

Anyway my favourite 5 go as follows;

Batman

Flash (Wally West)

Shadowcat

Green Lantern (Hal Jordan)

Invisible Woman

Thanks for reading :) I look forward to seeing how your 5 fare against mine!

#2 Posted by Militaris (80 posts) - - Show Bio

Wasp (Janet van Dyne) vs Batman... Probably Batman.

Dr Doom vs Flash .... Without Prep Flash.

Lobo vs Green Lantern .... Lobo due to durability and strength.

Flash (wally west) vs Invisible Woman - Flash is simply to fast.

Loki vs Shadow Cat.. A bit one sided I think, but Loki Wins.

#3 Posted by Xaraghoul_the_Ravager (99 posts) - - Show Bio

@MasterAction said:

Hi everyone :) I've seen quite a few of these threads in one form or another on the site so thought it'd be cool if I started my own

Basically I'd like you to pick your 5 favourite comic book characters of all time and put them in individual 1 vs 1 matches against my own 5. Obviously try and match them up as fairly as possible, eg if I have Batman and you use Galactus against him then Bruce doesn't have a chance in hell! And on that note please don't choose a team entirely based on mega-powerhouses (Living Tribunal, Beyonder, etc). For all I know your favourite 5 may all be cosmic level but try and keep it reasonable :)

Individual match rules are as follows- Morals off and a fight to the death. Takes place in a completely empty Times Square. No prep, random encounter

Anyway my favourite 5 go as follows;

Batman

Flash (Wally West)

Shadowcat

Green Lantern (Hal Jordan)

Invisible Woman

Thanks for reading :) I look forward to seeing how your 5 fare against mine!

Samus Aran: Samus sh!tstomps Batman

Sheogorath: I'm not sure if Flash can hurt the mad god, but he may just end up becoming a sweetroll.

John Egbert, John's like a teenaged Thor with an overbite and dorky glasses, he stomps.

Vecna: Epic level D&D Magic is beyond broken, this is a horrible stomp.

Rose Lalonde (John<3Rose OTP forever) Rose stomps with her magic.

#4 Posted by luhjgh (83 posts) - - Show Bio

Okay, mine are in no particular order here, so I don't favourite Mike over Deadpool as an example XD

Batman vs Michelangelo ... If Mikey was focussed.ready he could win, but otherwise Batman would have turtle soup.

Flash (Wally West) vs Deadpool... If DP could somehow catch up to him, Wally could be in for it. Otherwise, Flash would run circles around him (Literally)

Shadowcat vs Nightwing ... Nightwing would win most likely

Green Lantern (Hal Jordan) vs Ken (Street fighter) ... Yeah no other character in my favourites is fit to kill him XD Hal wins.

Invisible Woman vs Sub-Zero ... Sub-zero could freeze her and be done with it or somehow Invisible woman could get the drop on him. I don't read much Fantastic Four so I'm unaware of her other real powers other than... Invisibility XD

#5 Edited by Veitha (3362 posts) - - Show Bio

Cool thread. My favs are mutants, let's see:

  • Cyclops vs Batman... without prep I think that Cyke takes this.
  • Magik vs Green Lantern... Illyana takes this easily.
  • Emma Frost vs Invisible Woman... it depends on who attacks fiirst, but it's more likely that Sue wins.
  • Psylocke vs ShadowCat... Betsy kills her very soon.
  • Magneto vs Flash.... I really don't know this... I think Flash??
#6 Posted by KnightRise (4762 posts) - - Show Bio

Damn, I wish my favorites were more diverse!

These are my all-time favorites:

Nightwing vs Batman. When its down to the wire (no pun intended), Dick won't hang (pun totally intended).

Batman vs Invisible Woman. No prep and morals off? Lol poor Bats.

Red Hood vs Shadowcat. Yay! We might win one! One.

Superman vs Wally West. I don't know, but a bloodlusted Wally is a scary thought...

Spider-Man vs Hal Jordan. LOL.

These are my more recent favorites:

Nightwing vs Shadowcat. Hehehe. Ahahahaha. MUHUHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!

Batman vs Batman. Batman is so Batman that Batman can out Batman Batman.

Sinestro vs Hal Jordan. Much more even, but Hal leads morals off.

Damian Wayne vs Wally West. Make it quick, Wally, he's a child...

Kaine vs Invisible Woman. Would be pretty cool to watch, possibly.

#7 Posted by Ancient_0f_Days (12431 posts) - - Show Bio

@KnightRise said:

Nightwing vs Batman. When its down to the wire (no pun intended), Dick won't hang (pun totally intended).

#8 Posted by KnightRise (4762 posts) - - Show Bio

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@KnightRise said:

Nightwing vs Batman. When its down to the wire (no pun intended), Dick won't hang (pun totally intended).

Whyithankyou

#9 Posted by Ancient_0f_Days (12431 posts) - - Show Bio

@KnightRise said:

Whyithankyou

You'reverywelcome

#10 Posted by ToO_RaW (1116 posts) - - Show Bio

Mine may not be exactly fair, but here it goes.

Thanos

Mr. Majestic

Dr. Doom

Deadpool

Deathstroke

#11 Posted by The_Lunact_And_Manic (3286 posts) - - Show Bio

Batman Vs Batman - My Batman>>>Your Batman

Flash Vs Nightwing - Reason can't beat my fanboyism

Shadowcat Vs Zatanna - Nothing to say on this one

Green Lantern (Hal Jordan) Vs Thor - It would be a fun fight

Invisible Woman Vs John Constantine - If he's smart enough to use a powerful spell in the first second of the battle.

#12 Posted by whacknasty (5596 posts) - - Show Bio
@MasterAction:  Hard to choose just five...lol. Cool thread.
  
Colossus vs Invisible Woman - Could be a good match up? lol

Silver Surfer vs Flash (Wally West) - Can be debated either way (and has been in more than one thread around here, lol) 

Sabretooth vs Batman - Eh...morals off and no prep leans towards Sabes I would think, but I'm not sure 

Thor  vs Green Lantern (Hal Jordan) - Debatable, but morals off I may choose Thor...

Hulk vs Shadowcat - Probable stalemate I would think, unless Hulk has hurt intangible characters before?
#13 Edited by Chronus (1115 posts) - - Show Bio

Batman vs Batman

Flash(Wally West) vs Joker

Shadowcat vs Superman

Green Lantern vs Thanos

Invisible Woman vs Doctor Doom

#14 Posted by Esquire (3833 posts) - - Show Bio

@MasterAction said:

Individual match rules are as follows- Morals off and a fight to the death. Takes place in a completely empty Times Square. No prep, random encounter

Anyway my favourite 5 go as follows;

Invisible Woman

  • Fantomex vs Batman

Fantomex wins via Misdirection, but it would be an interesting fight if we take that out. Jean-Phillipe has excellent skills and roughly peak-human stats, and he also has a healing factor and guns. But a moral-less Batman is a frightening thought. I'd say it's a pretty even split, with Fantomex winning if he can keep the fight at range and Bruce winning if he closes the distance.

  • Amadeus Cho vs Invisible Woman

Morals-Off Sue is pretty tough to beat. Amadeus might be able to use his mace to exploit a weak point in her defenses, but she should win 9/10.

  • Batman vs Shadowcat

Batman has no way of hitting her in her intangible form, so Kitty would beat him without much issue.

  • Mister Majestic vs Flash

Majestic has FTL speed, incredible operational speed, the durability to tank most of Flash's hits, and the reflexes to avoid projectiles moving at 6x the speed of light. Wally can probably win since he's morals-off, but Majestic will give him a good fight.

  • Blue Beetle vs Green Lantern (Hal Jordan)

Morals Off Blue Beetle is no one to be trifled with, and the Scarab was, after all, built to kill Green Lanterns. But a Morals Off Hal, arguably the greatest in the Corps, would still take a majority, imo.

#15 Posted by Epicbeast3000 (956 posts) - - Show Bio

Hercules AND tHOR SOLO

#16 Posted by HomasTardy (127 posts) - - Show Bio

First off, awesome team you've got there! My favourites are the movie versions of the comic book characters (with the actor/actress who played them), and I can't decide which of my favourites would face yours in the individual battles, so I'll put mine against each one of yours...

My 5th Favourite: Sebastian Shaw (played by Kevin Bacon)

  • vs Batman - With no prep it depends on whether Shaw is loaded with energy or not. If he is then Batman loses, but if he isn't then Batman would win pretty easily.
  • vs Flash - I'd give this one to Flash, before Shaw could blink the Flash could quite easily decapitate him.
  • vs Shadowcat - Shadowcat should win this one, Shaw wouldn't be able to even touch her.
  • vs Green Lantern - I think Shaw could pull out the win here, he could absorb all the energy that Green Lantern can throw at him.
  • vs Invisible Woman - Shaw takes it, Invisible Woman's powers only make the situation worse.

My 4th Favourite: Bane (played by Tom Hardy)

  • vs Batman - Too close to call in my opinion.
  • vs Flash - Flash is just too quick.
  • vs Shadowcat - Shadowcat due to her ability.
  • vs Green Lantern - Green Lantern is just too powerful for Bane.
  • vs Invisible Woman - Only if Bane could get his hands on her would he win this one, other than that Invisible Woman takes this.

My 3rd Favourite: Black Widow (played by Scarlett Johansson)

  • vs Batman - I would love to say Black Widow, but unfortunately she just couldn't take Batman :(
  • vs Flash - Flash... again
  • vs Shadowcat - If Shadowcat didn't use her ability then Black widow could take her easily.
  • vs Green Lantern - Green Lantern (Natasha isn't doing very well against your team)
  • vs Invisible Woman - ...Sue takes it (I wish Black Widow had an ability...)

My 2nd Favourite: Wolverine (played by Hugh Jackman)

  • vs Batman - Wolverine easily, Batman would die a quick death.
  • vs Flash - I think Wolverine again... if he could catch Flash.
  • vs Shadowcat - Shadowcat could just phase out Wolverine's heart.
  • vs Green Lantern - Green Lantern could take Logan quite easily I think.
  • vs Invisible Woman - Could go either way.

My Favourite: Magneto (played by Michael Fassbender)

  • vs Batman - If there's metal around then Magneto, if not then Batman.
  • vs Flash - Flash (he's doing pretty good in these battles)
  • vs Shadowcat - Again, if theres metal around then Magneto wins.
  • vs Green Lantern - Green Lantern could destroy Magneto here.
  • vs Invisible Woman - Invisible woman could take it here.
#17 Posted by IronBatmanfan (17 posts) - - Show Bio

Batman vs Batman = Batman

Deadpool vs Wally = Probably Wally

Green Arrow vs Shadowcat (Don't know much about Shadowcat)

Doctor Doom vs Green Lantern (Me being biased I'll go with Victor XD)

Thor vs Invisible Woman (hard to say, if Thor strikes first successfully it could mean the end for Susan)

#18 Posted by MonsterStomp (20655 posts) - - Show Bio
  • Owlman
  • Kyle Rayner
  • Supergirl
  • Helspont
  • Black Adam

Owlman vs Batman = Could go either way but I'm putting bets on Owlman

Kyle Rayner vs Hal Joudan = No idea, still a toss up. Current versions go to Rayner though.

Supergirl vs Flash = Flash

Black Adam vs Flash = Flash

Helspont vs Flash = Helspont via mind r8page.

I should win in a tough fight if Flash doesn't kill Helspont first.

#19 Posted by sandw1tch (28 posts) - - Show Bio
  • Batman vs Hellboy
  • Flash vs Deadpool
  • Shadowcat vs Elizabeth sherman
  • Green Lantern vs Doctor Strange
  • Invisible Woman vs Huntress

Batman and Hellboy can both deal damage when close and handle their fair share also.

When deadpool gets knocked on his ass he gets up laughing.

Would be an easy win for Shadowcat, but it'll be difficult to rip out Elizabeth's heart when it's on fire.

Green Lantern and Doctor Strange are both the wishy washy etheral type.

Invisvible Woman and the huntress... think alien versus predator.

#20 Posted by Lunacyde (19523 posts) - - Show Bio
#21 Posted by UltimateHero0406 (2171 posts) - - Show Bio

Shadow the Hedgehog - Invisible Woman

Dante - Shadowcat

Deadpool - Batman

Dormammu - Flash

Asura - Green Lantern

?

#22 Posted by Floopay (8721 posts) - - Show Bio

@MasterAction said:

Hi everyone :) I've seen quite a few of these threads in one form or another on the site so thought it'd be cool if I started my own

Basically I'd like you to pick your 5 favourite comic book characters of all time and put them in individual 1 vs 1 matches against my own 5. Obviously try and match them up as fairly as possible, eg if I have Batman and you use Galactus against him then Bruce doesn't have a chance in hell! And on that note please don't choose a team entirely based on mega-powerhouses (Living Tribunal, Beyonder, etc). For all I know your favourite 5 may all be cosmic level but try and keep it reasonable :)

Individual match rules are as follows- Morals off and a fight to the death. Takes place in a completely empty Times Square. No prep, random encounter

Anyway my favourite 5 go as follows;

Batman

Flash (Wally West)

Shadowcat

Green Lantern (Hal Jordan)

Invisible Woman

Thanks for reading :) I look forward to seeing how your 5 fare against mine!

Batman vs. Beast (Marvel)

Beta Ray Bill (Marvel) vs. Flash (Wally West)

The Creeper (DC) vs. Shadowcat

Quasar (Wendell Vaughn, Marvel) vs. Green Lantern (Hal Jordan)

Spawn (First Generation, Image) vs. Invisible Woman

Thanks for reading,

Floopay

#23 Posted by Mistry_Riddler (31 posts) - - Show Bio

Batman vs Cap America - Im going to go for Cap, even though Brucey will have some gadgets, Steve's endurance and experience as well as near superhuman strength should just be enough to overcome to the Bat

Flash vs Nightcrawler - A tough battle seeing as Kurt could jump around like a hyper active smurf, but Flash could take him within the blink of an eye if he's not careful

Shadowcat vs Iceman- tough battle, both can do sufficient damage but i can see a draw happening here, Icy could freeze her but the cat could avoid this somehow?

Green Lantern vs Thor - I'm going to go for Thor - he is a beautiful man for starters (movie version (Chris Hemsworth) ), although Hal's could use shields, Thor could eventully break him down, Thor's strength and durability should help him through this.

Invisible Woman vs Magneto - empty times square - i presume there will be metals around so he could manipulate the environment and throw metal objects at her with force, but Sue with the opportunity could rip him to shreds ( I think- a little sneak attack in his brain and bye bye Magneto)

(BTW had to reduce some of my favs as they are powerhouses) (And some in comparison to yours would be like a snowball in hell - no chance)

#24 Edited by comiczmaestro (82 posts) - - Show Bio

@masteraction: Batman vs Squirrel Girl Squirrel Girl STOMPS

Franklin Richards vs Flash Franklin Stomps

Bugs Bunny vs Shadowcat Bugs stomps

Green Lantern vs Loki I think Loki takes this after a tough fight.

Invisible Woman vs Impossible Man- IM stomps

LOL all my faves were either high end reality warpers, gods, or Masters of the Toon Force!