@stahlflamme: Yes, the NoN did affect Elva and the dragons. When Galbatorix first used it, it had the exact same effect in them as it did on the humans and elves, it immobilized and disoriented them.
That was a different spell. It was even stated Galbatorix used a greater number of words, including a spell that stopped them from remembering the Name. The name only boosts his other magic and undoes magic and oaths using the old language.
HP spells are not beyond strong or weak. They are flashes of light that can be blocked by any solid object, or alternatively wards. Even if they hit, their effects are not as powerful as things we've seen being blocked by wards in TIC, like when Barst tanked shots from a ballista.
Harry Potter spells can cause instant transfer of mass and transform one matter in another or a person into an animal without any negative side effect to the user. All these things take tremendous amounts of Energy within Murtaghs universe and would be much more difficult to deal with than a ballista.
Also the sorry excuse of a wizard that is Wormtail blew up an entire street by waving his wand when face to face with Sirius. That is also easily above an Ballista.
And no, we were never told what Eldunari he had, so we cannot assume how powerful it was.
Size. Eldunari grow with the dragon. Dragons grow with age. The older a dragon the more powerful he gets. Barsts Eldunari was so big it made him seem obese, when it was strapped in front of his stomach. Murtaghs Eldunari were shown to be much smaller.
Besides, it makes more sense for Galbatorix to give his more powerful Elduanrya to Murtagh-a dragon rider who is leagues more crucial to him than Barst who was just a field commander.
A) Barst was the person defending the capital. B) It was stated the Eldunari Murtagh had were from young and inexperienced dragons.
Also, Barst only had one Eldunari while we do know Murtagh had more.
The killing curse is also useless because if numerous reasons. A) it's out of character for any of them to use it (yes, for Snape too), B) Murtagh can dodge it and
And I never claimed they would use it, I said it was the one spell Voldemort could use to break through Harry Potter universe defense spells.
C) Murtagh has Deathwords which are far, far above Evada Kedavra.
A) Murtagh never used Deathwords I believe. B) Evada Kedavra kills. Deathwords cause braindamage. Set up a spell against brain damage one thing. Set up a spell against death. Which one is more likely to work?
And as it was already explained to you by TheVivas, wards are not only against specific types of magic. Murtagh's wards will block anything the wizards throw at him, while he can easily cancel their own wards without breaking a sweat. Not to mention he solo's with TP in less than 10 seconds.
Again, Murtagh stomps hard. He's a reality warper and a telepath, no way in hell he's losing this.
A) What reality warping feat does Murtagh have? B) I never claimed he would lose, I said much of your argumentation is simply wrong.
Log in to comment