#1 Posted by Nny (245 posts) - - Show Bio

Who would win a fight: Mr. Mxyzptlk or Q (from ST:TNG)?

I say Q: he's smarter.

#2 Posted by Captain Cascader (1284 posts) - - Show Bio

I'm a pretty big Trek fan but never really got Q. If it's a battle between who is a bigger prick, then sure, Q.

Staff
#3 Posted by Cosmic Sentinel (3749 posts) - - Show Bio

I always liked the Q episodes of TNG because John De Lancie usually bought some humour to the show and it was good to see them all vexxed. I don't think you can call a fight between two reality altering beings.

#4 Posted by Nny (245 posts) - - Show Bio

Yeah, I loved to see them vexed. I'm always like, lighten UP, people!!!

#5 Posted by Assimilation (955 posts) - - Show Bio

I never liked Q, though I loved the episodeshe was in. Q would easily beat Mxyzptlk. He's more evil.

#6 Posted by Methos (40103 posts) - - Show Bio

um, Mxyzptlk actually killed Superman once...

he is evil, he just doesn't show it much

M

#7 Posted by Superkitty (1086 posts) - - Show Bio

Mr. Mxyzptlk is a being of the fifth dimension, while Q is fourth at best (I think). I think Mzyptlk would win unless Q realized that Mzy's weakness was saying his name backwards, then he could probably easily outsmart him.

#8 Posted by Nny (245 posts) - - Show Bio

Q has nothing to do with dimensions. He can do ANYTHING.

#9 Posted by Destroyer of Evil (20 posts) - - Show Bio

Q isn't just smarter he is omniscient and Mr. Mxyzptlk isn't. So Q is the winner. A better battle would be Q Vs. The Beyonder. :D

#10 Posted by Boken (7756 posts) - - Show Bio

could some one write out the phonetic spelling of Mxyzptlk beacuse i never knew how to pronunce his name

#11 Posted by lordraiden (7075 posts) - - Show Bio

Destroyer of Evil says:

"Q isn't just smarter he is omniscient and Mr. Mxyzptlk isn't. So Q is the winner. A better battle would be Q Vs. The Beyonder. :D"

thats a good call, might have to pinch that idea and start a thread! hope you don't mind! and for my two scents worth, as cosmic sentinel put it, I don't think there'd be any real winners in a situation/battle like this, there both just as powerfull/bad as each other! and mxy isn't evil, he's just mischevious, he actually likes supes, as in likes f@#$%ing with him! if he wanted to, he could snap his fingers and turn supes into eggnog!

#12 Posted by SupremeMan (2 posts) - - Show Bio

It seems to me that Q fulfills the same purpose in Star Trek that Mr. Mxy fulfills in the DCU- being an annoyance. Both Q and Mxy can hop realities. I think they are both the same entity wearing different forms in different realities. They both can do about anything. Its a draw.

#13 Posted by Djinn (778 posts) - - Show Bio

mxyzptlk is waaaaaaaaaay better and can bet Q

#14 Posted by ClarkJosephKent1938DC (682 posts) - - Show Bio
#15 Posted by Vance Astro (91220 posts) - - Show Bio

Nobody wins.

Moderator
#16 Posted by BIackFlash (1909 posts) - - Show Bio

Q would win this

#17 Posted by gobstakid777 (1815 posts) - - Show Bio

Mxy

#18 Posted by AtPhantom (14521 posts) - - Show Bio
@BIackFlash said:
" Q would win this "
Based on what?
#19 Posted by gobstakid777 (1815 posts) - - Show Bio
@AtPhantom said:
" @BIackFlash said:
" Q would win this "
Based on what? "
cosigned. What feat has Q done that Mxy hasn't/couldn't perform
#20 Posted by Baldy (5021 posts) - - Show Bio
@gobstakid777 said:
" @AtPhantom said:
" @BIackFlash said:
" Q would win this "
Based on what? "
cosigned. What feat has Q done that Mxy hasn't/couldn't perform "
Q is effectively the same as Mxy, though smarter. That's what I think gives Q the advantage.
#21 Edited by BIackFlash (1909 posts) - - Show Bio

Mxy is super powerful, almost godlike but he comes off as clownish and is typically beat by a single opponent in DC Universe.  Losing his powers to Joker is another example, or losing to Emoboy Pirme is another embarrassment. He just seems amateurish in battles.
 
Plus its not like you can say the name "Q" backwards

#22 Posted by gobstakid777 (1815 posts) - - Show Bio
@Baldy said:
" @gobstakid777 said:
" @AtPhantom said:
" @BIackFlash said:
" Q would win this "
Based on what? "
cosigned. What feat has Q done that Mxy hasn't/couldn't perform "
Q is effectively the same as Mxy, though smarter. That's what I think gives Q the advantage. "
That does compute....
#23 Posted by AtPhantom (14521 posts) - - Show Bio
@BIackFlash said:
" Mxy is super powerful, almost godlike but he comes off as clownish and is typically beat by a single opponent in DC Universe.  Losing his powers to Joker is another example, or losing to Emoboy Pirme is another embarrassment. He just seems amateurish in battles.  Plus its not like you can say the name "Q" backwards "
So... based on nothing?
 
@Baldy said:
" Q is effectively the same as Mxy, though smarter. That's what I think gives Q the advantage. "
Based on what? Why would they be same? What has Q done to warrant this assumption?
#24 Posted by Tevnoba (3494 posts) - - Show Bio

"Q" are not Omnescient, Omnipotent, Omniversal, Omnidimensional or Omnitemporal!  They are a highly advanced race who started out humanoid and their technology evolved to where we see them in the show.
 
5D Imps (from what I understand) have a very similar story.
 
I say it's a draw, IMO.

#25 Posted by gobstakid777 (1815 posts) - - Show Bio
@Tevnoba said:
" "Q" are not Omnescient, Omnipotent, Omniversal, Omnidimensional or Omnitemporal!  They are a highly advanced race who started out humanoid and their technology evolved to where we see them in the show.  5D Imps (from what I understand) have a very similar story.  I say it's a draw, IMO. "
That's prbly is how it's gonna go down
#26 Posted by AtPhantom (14521 posts) - - Show Bio
@Tevnoba said:
" "Q" are not Omnescient, Omnipotent, Omniversal, Omnidimensional or Omnitemporal!  They are a highly advanced race who started out humanoid and their technology evolved to where we see them in the show.  5D Imps (from what I understand) have a very similar story.  I say it's a draw, IMO. "
5D imps are native to 5th dimension. They did not start out normal and then obtain some power. They were always like that.
#27 Posted by OhTru (1583 posts) - - Show Bio
@gobstakid777 said:
" @Tevnoba said:
" "Q" are not Omnescient, Omnipotent, Omniversal, Omnidimensional or Omnitemporal!  They are a highly advanced race who started out humanoid and their technology evolved to where we see them in the show.  5D Imps (from what I understand) have a very similar story.  I say it's a draw, IMO. "
That's prbly is how it's gonna go down "
stalemate
#28 Posted by Superparody (2011 posts) - - Show Bio

Stalemate
#29 Posted by xan84 (4286 posts) - - Show Bio
@AtPhantom said:
" @Tevnoba said:
" "Q" are not Omnescient, Omnipotent, Omniversal, Omnidimensional or Omnitemporal!  They are a highly advanced race who started out humanoid and their technology evolved to where we see them in the show.  5D Imps (from what I understand) have a very similar story.  I say it's a draw, IMO. "
5D imps are native to 5th dimension. They did not start out normal and then obtain some power. They were always like that. "

If this means anything he sayis it himself that his omnipotent and immortal. He also sayis (when picard dies) thas his god, and he runs the after life. This can be considered hyperboles but its something to take note of. 
The Q has no on panel feat that would be as big as something Myx has but i still belive they should win. In the show they repeated that the q have seen everything, done everything (because of this 1 q whants to die) and theat they can do whatever they whant (unless the Q majority objects). 
i always belived they are omnipotent(or very close to it) but there is no way to prove it realy. Then again nobody can probe TOAA or the Presence is omnipotent with on panel feats. Just stuff that was said in the comics. 
  
I vote for Q.
#30 Posted by mattek (1119 posts) - - Show Bio

Q wins IMO. Imps are mostly based on technology IIRC.

#31 Posted by AtPhantom (14521 posts) - - Show Bio
@mattek said:
" Q wins IMO. Imps are mostly based on technology IIRC. "
Whaat??? Where did you get that idea from?
#32 Posted by mattek (1119 posts) - - Show Bio

 The problem is that Mr Mxy's powers, by his own admission, are not actually innate powers per se, but applications of 5th dimensional superscience. Q powers are just that, virtual omnipotence. We have seen Mr Mxy have problems with magic for example, in a way that we know that Q would not, simply because the powers are innate. I lean towards Q on this one. 

#33 Posted by AtPhantom (14521 posts) - - Show Bio
@mattek said:
"  The problem is that Mr Mxy's powers, by his own admission, are not actually innate powers per se, but applications of 5th dimensional superscience. Q powers are just that, virtual omnipotence. We have seen Mr Mxy have problems with magic for example, in a way that we know that Q would not, simply because the powers are innate. I lean towards Q on this one.  "
Yeah, so are Iron man's. How does that change anything? So are Q's for that matter. Q civil War anyone? Guns with which humans can kill Q and stuff? Mxy still has far, far greater feats than Q. Q is not omnipotent.
#34 Posted by slacker the hacker (7838 posts) - - Show Bio

Q unless this is WF Mxy
#35 Posted by Pr_Beyonder (2440 posts) - - Show Bio
@Tevnoba said:
""Q" are not Omnescient, Omnipotent, Omniversal, Omnidimensional or Omnitemporal!  They are a highly advanced race who started out humanoid and their technology evolved to where we see them in the show.  5D Imps (from what I understand) have a very similar story.  I say it's a draw, IMO. "

Agreed, power wise. 
 
 
I'd give mxy and edge on feats and effective pratice over large  amounts of power. 
 
Q's more intelligent but he's pretty much a Joker too. 
 
If this is a death match I'd give it to Mxy since he's basically mentioned to be "thought of the endless"
#36 Posted by "Colossus" (4111 posts) - - Show Bio

so q is from the 4d then, i think the Q,s think humans would soon evolve to the 5th D

#37 Posted by AtPhantom (14521 posts) - - Show Bio

There is no 4th and 5th dimensions in Star Trek. Well, there is  a 4th one because that's where we're from, but that's not important.

#38 Edited by DeathpooltheT1000 (10753 posts) - - Show Bio

Superman could beat him, why does Q lose?, oh i remember, this forum is full of Q hatters that hat Q.
Q, have show the facat he know everything, at least everything of the dimension he is in, i mean he will knew the weak point of Mr.Shyshythylisxklitk and he will use it.
Hatters gonna Hat and Haters gonna Hate.

Online
#39 Posted by AtPhantom (14521 posts) - - Show Bio

If Mxy is beaten by Superman, then Q is beaten by Picard. Anyone who argues this has clearly never read a Mxy comic ever. 
 
Mxy's feats still outweigh Q's feats by a whole lot.

#40 Posted by DeathpooltheT1000 (10753 posts) - - Show Bio
@AtPhantom said:
" If Mxy is beaten by Superman, then Q is beaten by Picard. Anyone who argues this has clearly never read a Mxy comic ever.   Mxy's feats still outweigh Q's feats by a whole lot. "
Q, let you know, that he alway helped Picard, that he never actually wanted to destroy the world and that he choose, Picard, becuase he have a bigger potential, that the rest of humans.
You could see this in the Last episode of TNG.
Also, are you telling me that Superman is smarter that Picard?
Online
#41 Posted by AtPhantom (14521 posts) - - Show Bio
Thank you for proving my point.
#42 Posted by DeathpooltheT1000 (10753 posts) - - Show Bio
@AtPhantom said:
" Thank you for proving my point. "
What that Q is cooler that MXY?
You are welcome.
Online
#43 Posted by Jezer (3129 posts) - - Show Bio

Why do people say Q is omnipotent? 
 
I've read that Q admitted that the human race(or some race) would evolve beyond the Q's one day? 
Is that not true? If it is, that means he's not omnipotent. 
 
#44 Posted by DeathpooltheT1000 (10753 posts) - - Show Bio
@Jezer said:
" Why do people say Q is omnipotent?  I've read that Q admitted that the human race(or some race) would evolve beyond the Q's one day? Is that not true? If it is, that means he's not omnipotent.   "
Of course, that why Mxy wins this one, becuase Mxy is omnipotent, that was sarcasm.
Why everytime, people talk about Q,  it end with this?, being talked millions of times, still Mxy, show all his power, Q never showed all his powers.
Also Picard beat Superman.

Online
#45 Posted by Jezer (3129 posts) - - Show Bio
@DeathpooltheT1000 said:
" @Jezer said:
" Why do people say Q is omnipotent?  I've read that Q admitted that the human race(or some race) would evolve beyond the Q's one day? Is that not true? If it is, that means he's not omnipotent.   "
Of course, that why Mxy wins this one, becuase Mxy is omnipotent, that was sarcasm.
Why everytime, people talk about Q,  it end with this?, being talked millions of times, still Mxy, show all his power, Q never showed all his powers.
Also Picard beat Superman.
 
"

Funny since I didn't mention any of that. I didn't say Mxy is omnipotent. I didn't mention who I thought would win.
 
Nice nonsequitar.