This a generic point I want to make concerning the Silver Surfer, in comparison to Doc Manhattan, since in this thread there is obviously going to be comparisons between the two
1. What's stopping Silver Surfer from taking Dr Manhattan to the astral plane and screwing with him there?
2. Silver Surfer himself has stated he could make singularities in people's heads. He's even made a black hole beforehand (although he ran away from it lol).
3. Silver Surfer can Warp, and the furthest Doc Manhattan has ever teleported someone to is Mars.
4. Silver Surfer has flown through a sun. Not Just walked on its surface.
5.Silver Surfer can also turn intangible too. He can also trap people in his board.
Simply put, Manhattan has done nothing to put himself on the level of Silver Surfer. He openly admitted that he could stop all the Soviet missiles. Silver Surfer channeled the energies of the crunch (so why he can't absorb Doc Manhattan is beyond me), destroyed a Planet in his fight with Morg, and was threatening to destroy the planet due a bad bad dream he was having- and when he woke up, repaired the city wide damage instantly. Silver Surfer is a Telepath who can travel to the Astral Plane at will. Doc Manhattan didn't know he was tricked into thinking his wife had cancer. Doc Manhattan has transmuted Viet Cong Soldiers into bloody messes. Silver Surfer has transmuted an alien who could survive in space into nothing but Atoms.
Calling Doctor Manhattan a silver surfer lite is being kind to the so called "Good Doctor". If you put an herald level character in the world of Watchmen they would be regarded as Gods too.
Edit- For those people claiming that Doc Manhattan failing to stop the Soviet Missiles is PIS, it isn't. That Idea is integral to the plot. Manhattan had no reason to lie about the his capabilities, and if he could stop all the soviet nukes, the Cold War would have ended flat out there and then, and the threat of nuclear war. Hostility continued between the USSR and USA because the US knew that Manhattan's presence wasn't enough to prevent MAD. Hence why Viedt made the plan to have the whole world unite against Manhattan, and ensure world wide peace.
All in all, the Wanking of Doc Manhattan needs to stop. I said it before, and I'll say it again, you put an Herald level plus character in that universe, and they would seem like God's. Such a title isn't hard to achieve when they are no other super-powered individuals in the Watchmen universe, let alone cosmic scale characters.......
Log in to comment