Over the past few days (okay, months) now, I have been quarreling with a TROLL on YouTube. comichero75. He believes that Captain America is superior to Batman in most ways, and that he would DEFINITELY win in a fight. Do you agree? I don't. I'll tell you why soon but first, here is an argument I was in with him:
Him: You fan boys kill me LMAO. Caps sheild is not affected by magnetism. Bat is only smarter when it comes to solving a crime. Cap is a tactical genious.
Me: They are even in skill. But Cap has more stamina. Batman counters Cap's stamina because of his indomitable will which he will use to force himself beyond his physical limits. Cap has near indestructible shield. Batman has remote controlled and reverse batarangs to hit Cap from behind. Batman and Captain America are both conjoined no. 1 on my favourite comic book heroes of all time list. The fight could go either way in my opinion.
Him: Yea, nice fairytale. Caps will is equally stong. And not only that, Cap is tactically smarter than Batman. Cap will be moving too fast to any batarangs. And even Batman admitted to Cap that he will loose in a long fight against CA. All the gadets that Batman has wont equal the tactical genious, strenght,speed, and stamina of Cap.
Me: It's not a fairytale. Prove to me that Caps will is equally as strong. Prove to me that Cap is more of a tactical genius than Batman. Prove to me that he can a hear a remote batarang, which doesn't produce any sound, coming at him from behind. The thing is, if they got into a fight without prep, they would draw. With prep, they would draw. They are equals. If you can't prove to me otherwise, which you won't be able to do, I stand firm on my opinion.
Him:Cap is stronger due to the Super Soldier Serum, he can bench press close to 1 000 pounds. Cap lead miltary units in the second world war and he was the battle leader of the avengers for a heck of a long time. and his mental capabilites are also at the height of human perfection. The batarnag thing? it still has to move through the air, which it will disturb with its physical presents, which Cap will hear due to his senses. Batman fights like Batman, Cap fights like a Soldier.
Me: That did not prove to me anything. You did not prove to me any of the things I requested. Batman can bench press ABOVE 1000 pounds and so can Cap. But Cap CAN lift more than Batman. Batman has lead the Justice league for a while at one point. Batman's mental capabilites are above genius level intellect. What do you mean the batarang will disturb Cap with it's physical presence? Neither Cap or Batman have a sixth sense. Face it. Captain America and Batman ARE EQUALS. And the fight could go either way.
Him: Batman and Cap are not equals. Batman is nowhere close to Cap in strenght, agility, stamina, speed, and tactical skills. The only thing they are similar in is fighting skill. But Cap takes that due to his physical advantages. The only thing Batman has over Cap is crime solving. So Batman would win in a game of clue, Cap would win in Stratego.
Me: I said that Cap is physically superior to Batman. They are not similar in fighting skill. Batman will play dirty. He will cheat and break your arms if he has to. Even in a straight up fight he will. Being physically superior doesn't mean shit. For example Bruce Lee was taught by Yip Man. But Bruce Lee was not a great fighter at all. The only special thing about him was his speed. And in a straight up fight with Yip Man, Bruce couldn't even touch him because Yip Man was more skilled.