Marv (Sin City) vs The Comedian

Marv Abilities:

Agility, Berserker Strength, Escape Artist, Marksmanship, Stamina, Unarmed Combat, Weapon Master.

The Comedian Abilities:

Gadgets, Marksmanship, Stamina, Tracking, Unarmed Combat, Weapon Master.

Simple Rules:

Win by death or K.O.

Both characters are at their peaks.

PUT REASONS WHY ONE WOULD WIN!

Feats for Marv?

@leo-343: shot in the head with what? A handgun? If so Eddy could still killed him with a shotgun or assault rifle. Also a grenade would take him out? Right?

As Marv beaten anybody worthwhile?

@allstarsuperman: It doesn't matter who he has beaten. Are you just curious? There is something spooky about Marv. I don't think Comedian could overcome Marv in a fight.

Hurm. I just might watch this movie.

I'd back Marv for this fight. It would be an epic fight though.

Either could probably gun the other down under the right circumstances, but the Comedian has far better training and experience with firearms and military tactics, so i'd say if one shoots the other first it'd be Eddy. However, in a fist fight i reckon Marv would win, because he has too many advantages. Strength, durability, stamina, etc. Eddy is probably more skilled, due to being trained and beating Adrian and whatnot, but i'm pretty sure Marv could overpower him. So, basically, in my opinion, if they have guns and start far enough apart then Eddy most likely wins, but if it's a fist fight then Marv most likely wins.

Marv stomps, dude jumped out of buildings, and tanked a lot of hits before his death, Comedian isn't nearly as durable.

Marv's unreal damage soak is too much for eddy to overcome.

I think Marv will stomp Blake, just on his berserker strength alone.

Comedian due to training and superior weaponry. If the fight gets close marv can win. but it wont

marv

Marv, damage soak is insane for a human. Eddy is no slouch and can put out some damage but I feel when it gets close and personal its over for Comedian. Comedian can win with some big guns to start, but he better aim right between Marv's eyes because anywhere else he'll just soak it.

Marv

I get that Marv has high damage soak, but how many gunshots can Marv take to the head? I don't think it'd be much.

I think Comedian would just keep shooting him in the head.

I haven't read Sin City.

Although I do think that Marv could win, I'm back Comedian for the majority. I don't think Marv can take several headshots.

Marv

Marv. He could one shot the comedian.

If they had a gun fight he only needs to shoot the comedian a couple times while the comedians has to shoot him almost ten times more. Only a shotgun or rifle would hurt him and even then maybe not outright kill him.

The comedian is much more skilled but Marv is pretty smart.

In a gun fight I'd give Marv only a slight advantage H2H Marv beats Comedian's head into a stain on the ground.

@thecomedian_: I can't remember if it happened the same in books but in the movie they shot him over ten times in the head albeit it was only an Uzi.

As much as I like Comedian, but Marv freaking demolishes him in every form or way. We're talking about who stands at 7 feet and 9 inches tall according to Sin city wikia and has shown to be capable of blowing people's brains out with his bare hands, go to blows with superhuman people (like Kevin, who is believed to not being human) and can tank ridiculously amount of terrible punishment and damage. I don't see poor Comedian touching Marv in a fight, who can knock out a hundred guys with a single blow as seen in Sin City 2, fighting Marv is like fighting a freaking dreadnought vehicle.

Marv's damage soak should get him the win here in a brutal slugfest.