Ah, bon.
Mara is more skilful. Shaak has almost no realistic, non-circumstantial feats, to be honest. She was wrecked by Grievous twice, but in both scenarios, she was not in peak physicality, though I doubt that if she was, she would be able to properly compete with him anyways. She was also driven off by Anakin who was already seemingly hindered to some degree. As for the often-cited feat of contending with the numerous Magnaguards, that was entirely circumstantial. To begin with, during the entire chase, Shaak never even defeated a single Magnaguard via raw skill. She had difficulty with a single one and she relied on it hitting passing trains with its electrostaff in order to expose itself, which was how she won. Granted, I do believe she probably could beat one in raw skill, it would certainly require significant effort on her part. She lost to the mass of Magnaguards (and they never attacked her all at once, only in small or large chunks), and then relied on having an electrostaff, a weapon of greater length, in order to give her greater reach and repel more staffs. Is her combination of electrostaff and lightsaber combat, which was sufficient to hold off the Magnaguards a noticeable combative feat? Yes, but it does not apply here. Shaak was also winning against Galen Marek in respects to raw skill, but given Marek at that stage had also been on the losing end against Kazdan Paratus and only fought roughly evenly with Kota, I don't consider it an overwhelming feat.
Mara performed well against Yuuzhan Vong, who, based on their displays against other Jedi, are just as good as the Magnaguards in a consequential sense, which in of itself almost automatically renders herself the superior duelist. She defeated Luuke (who was Luke's equal), IIRC, when Luke was aiding her. Corran Horn also conceded that she was the better duelist, and Corran himself has performed well against the Yuuzhan Vong, beaten Jensaari, and has beaten Gantoris and Shedao Shedai. If anything, he is already a better duelist than Shaak, so for Mara to be superior to him elevates her above Shaak by at least a tier. Mara has also beaten Alema Rar and fought about evenly with Lumiya, both feats to assure her elevation to a tier or two ahead of Shaak.
For physical attributes, I don't believe it would be overly consequential. Shaak has formed shields out of her blade, dodged blaster fire and moved invisibly fast and in blurs, but Mara has performed virtually all of those feats, and more, such as, IIRC, creating fans and I seem to recall her forming webs as well. Shaak has blitzed droids before, IIRC, but Mara has simply contended with faster beings like Caedus (although given the stupidity of that fight as a whole, it might not be worth bringing it up) and Lumiya. Mara managed to react to and avoid Force Lightning from the NR era alone, which was years before her prime. She should be faster.
For power, Shaak managed to effortlessly (or at least, almost effortlessly) lift and hurl a stream of debris whilst exhausted, which is a decent showing. She has also hurled groups of droids, used Saber Throw and utilized Deflection against lightsaber blades. Mara has utilized Barrier to repel explosions, utilized Heal on an unborn Ben, displayed fairly respectable showings of Sense and Telekinesis , and has telepathically probed thirty minds during the Rebellion era alone (so in her prime, she should be much more powerful). Mara was able to levitate across areas whilst producing bubbles of Force energy, manipulating the air around her, and minimizing her heat signature/emissions, all at once. She also learned a variety of other powers such as Concealment and Force Lightning. Shaak is fairly powerful, but Mara is still more powerful, and more versatile.
Really Mara, has virtually all of the edges here, whether slightly or significantly. She is faster, more skilful, more powerful and more versatile. I would give her 10/10 in a decent fight.
Log in to comment