Geonosis Battle Arena(so Jinn has an easier time using Ataru)
Morals off
FIGHT!
Mace loses. Both of the combatants are on a similar tier to him in both combative skill and offensive Force power, and Qui-Gon is stronger than Mace where Kit is faster. Mace's form should be more potent and effective than the other two's, and he is a better unarmed fighter and Force user, but he would still lose in a somewhat good fight.
Mace would beat either one of them one-on-one for a strong majority, together they're a bit to much for him.
Mace would beat either one of them one-on-one for a strong majority, together they're a bit to much for him.
To be honest, if we are using solely film versions, then Qui-Gon and Kit could, quite possibly, beat Palpatine. But then again, I see no reason to refrain from EU discussion, whereby Mace clearly did not defeat Palpatine (he was tremendously amped and still only stalemated Sidious, where the novel makes it clear that Palpatine faked a shatterpoint which Mace fell for - and an encyclopedia indicates Mace would not have been able to react if he weren't amped, which is logical because Mace-speed class characters can't even see Palpatine).
@shootingnova: where the novel makes it clear that Palpatine faked a shatterpoint which Mace fell for
Wait, he actually faked a shatterpoint? I always just thought that 2 things happened: Mace felt Anakin's fear and thought it was Palpatine's, and that Mace figured out that Palpatine trusted Anakin (which is true I'd say).
@nfactor1995: Pretty sure Mace exploited that fear which was Anakin's.
@shootingnova: But is that Palpatine faking a Shatterpoint?
@spartankobe: mace 10/10
@nfactor1995: Well, Mace thought that it was a Shatterpoint, IIRC. And if that was an entirely false fear, then it stands to reason that Palpatine misdirected his use of Shatterpoint.
In the future, though, try not to respond to posts from 2 or more years ago. Opinions change drastically in that time.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment