^LOL.
Now, with that out of the way, I repeat my analysis of this fight:
This battle has been done before as well, although since it was created before the other one I don't think it deserves to be flagged. I repeat my analysis (but in more detail):
Physically speaking - Vader is superior. His strength exceeds Mace, having ripped off steel doors from ships, torn down crystalline pillars, been unaffected by the weight of a dozen stormtroopers and so forth. Windu has flattened Super Battle Droid plating with his punches, which is impressive but not quite on par. And for that matter, he unleashed numerous rapid punches to accomplish the aforementioned feat anyways, plus it may been a result of Shatterpoint, which is inapplicable against any notable opponent like Vader. Given Vader's durability which has enabled him to survive lightsaber strikes, explosions, collapsing cathedrals, etc. that won't be happening here, and of course, Vader is still noticeably stronger. As far as speed goes, they are just about even. Both have fought in blurs and generated afterimages. Windu has fought faster than thought and Vader has drawn his lightsaber faster than thought. Windu has formed webs out of his blade while Vader has spun his lightsaber around his body to form a shield.
With relevance to dueling skill, Windu takes a slight majority. He has beaten Ventress, stalemated Sora Bulq, stalemated an immobile Grievous, stalemated and contended with Dooku in the past, etc.
Vader has contended with an amped Maul, beaten Celeste Morne, beaten Roan Shyrne, beaten Ferus Olin, beaten the Dark Woman, defeated five Jedi simultaneously and dueled evenly with Obi-Wan Kenobi, all of which were achieved before his prime. At his prime, he was able to duel as a perfect equal to Luke. These are hardly unimpressive feats, and they place Vader only slightly below Windu. And for that matter, as Intrepid has just pointed out, Vader has also been noted as one of history's most celebrated duelists.
Telekinetically, Vader wins by a significant margin. Windu's exaggerated feats from Tartakovsky's mini-series barred, Windu's feats include lifting trees and boulders, moving tanks and destroying droids with a Force Push. Impressive, but Vader's feats include collapsing cathedrals, hurling everything in a temple room including furniture, chunks of rock, parts of wall, ceiling and ground (and so on), collapsing colossal trees, crushed titanic droids, hurling around ships, tearing apart large platforms, hurling a vast number of troops (which just about rivals Windu's Force Wave feat from Tartakovsky's mini-series anyways) and so forth, all prior to his prime. Vader wins by a noticeable margin.
On a side note Vader could incite Force Rage easily if he happens to be harmed or something of that nature. He could very well use some involuntary powers like Force Scream, which he has used to crack walls, melt durasteel, melt parts of ceiling and so forth. Windu has never channeled an opponent's darkness with Vaapad, at least against nobody of note. He was unable to win against Dooku, unable to win against Sora Bulq, unable to win against Grievous and unable to win against Kar Vastor. So Vaapad being automatically effective here is simply incorrect.
I have not seen anything to the contrary from the Windu supporters, so I stand by my assessment.
Log in to comment