Mace Windu vs Anakin Skywalker

Me solos

@easternwind: Its a 7 months old post...

@faymousinus: I know, but I was so baffled by what he said, I was hoping he was still around

*bump*

I feel as if opinions on this fight may have slightly changed over time. As for me:

In a pure lightsaber duel, I might give a very slight edge to Mace due to being a bit more skilled. Sure, Anakin is definitely stronger, but strength hardly matters as much as skill and speed in a lightsaber duel. Windu 6 / 10.

In a Force only duel, I'd give Anakin a solid majority. He has better TK feats and has more overall raw force power.

All-out, I'd say Mace takes this, but only by the skin of his teeth. The reason I chose Windu is because Anakin has a tendency to rely more on pure lightsaber combat rather than utilizing his TK mid-fights.

Anakin wins.