Luminara Unduli vs Barriss Offee

Did the apprentice surpass the master?

Morals ON

Barriss at the end of Season 5; Luminara, same.

Barriss. Not just because she had better dueling feats, but I highly doubt Luminara would go all out against her apprentice.

@shootingnova@jkbart

@burnface@dccomicsrule2011

@jedixman@erkan12@juiceboks@killerwasp

@penderor@sirfizzwhizz@zaluk

@noah_ouellette@eisenfauste @night4345@reikai@itzxsloth345

@sirfizzwhizz@wollfmyth209

Depends on the morals. For one thing, Unduli will more than likely not kill her old apprentice, which right from the start would give Barriss some edge. Unduli is a superior telekinetic, and Barriss is likely a better duelist.

I find both to be mind numbly boring, so I'm abstain, here.

Barriss.

Bariss, for pretty much the same reasons others have given.

@dccomicsrule2011: Hah. I think their boringness makes them some of the best, non-emotional Jedi.

Luminara wins. Stalemating Ventress in sabers and the Force for over a minute with impaired vision is a very, very underrated feat. Ventress is better than Barriss, too. Luminara has this in the bag.

And screw you all, they are very interesting characters. :(

Luminara

With morals on? I guess bariss.

@thevivas: Why do you think Luminara?

@silentbat: More experienced.

could go either way

@thevivas: What specifically about Luminara's experience > Barriss.

I'd think Luminara's mastery of Soresu would eclipse Barriss', because her decades of refinement with her technique, as well as her incredible physical abilities, (flexibility, dexterity, agility) all of which surpass Barriss'. Nothing her apprentice brings to the table is something she would be unprepared for, honestly. Where do you think Barriss learned Jar'Kai, and by extension Makashi? Barriss hasn't been on her own long enough to change her style so much, so it's logical to assume Unduli taught her.

Luminara has this, peeps. The only way I see Barriss winning is if Luminara is passing up lethal openings.

Luminara is just the better duelist and stronger in force, she has a great defense and is very wise and smart

Luminara is still probably better, but not by much

Luminara. Morals aren't going to prevent her from incapacitating Barriss or disarming her, both of which she should have the capacity to do.

@SilentBat:

barris wrecks

luminara in tcw was just an a-hole