@jedixman: It's odd how the OP gives a picture of an older Obi Wan yet states the version fighting is the younger Obi Wan. I take it your previous comment was about an older Attack of the Clones/Revenge of the Sith level Obi Wan?
@jedixman: It's odd how the OP gives a picture of an older Obi Wan yet states the version fighting is the younger Obi Wan. I take it your previous comment was about an older Attack of the Clones/Revenge of the Sith level Obi Wan?
I was under the assumption that this was RotS Obi-Wan - basically, Obi-Wan in his prime.
AotC Obi-Wan would put up a fight, but lose. TPM wouldn't stand a chance. RotS vs Luke would be a good fight, ending in Luke's victory.
@jedixman: Silver actually said that RotJ Luke and RotS Obi-Wan were perfect equals, but I think I actually agree with you more this time.
I am not disagreeing with Silver, so I don't know why you're bringing that up. I'm giving Luke a slight edge. If you want numbers, I'm going with 6/10.
@jedixman: Silver believed it to be too close to call (in his own words "a complete 50/50) you believe it to be a close win for Luke. That's two different opinions is it not?
@jedixman: Silver believed it to be too close to call (in his own words "a complete 50/50) you believe it to be a close win for Luke. That's two different opinions is it not?
We both agree it's close. I think that Luke takes a slight majority; I don't think he would disagree one way or another, hence why it is close.
@dccomicsrule2011: Despite the votes on our last debate, in reality, it took every ounce of resourceful thinking I had to come up with arguments for Superman to overcome Palpatine's capabilities. And even then, in the course of our debate, I was convinced Superman would only beat Palpatine morals off and barely at that. You are that good man!
Log in to comment