@dccomicsrule2011: Sec DC, didn't you or Jedi or Silver? Or someone say that scan of Luke harming Vader with TP was from a non-canon story? Or was it vague?.....I can't remember but I recall that particular scan and something about not being canon. Though still Luke has this and later he has TP feats anyway, just recalling that bit is all.
@dccomicsrule2011: Sec DC, didn't you or Jedi or Silver? Or someone say that scan of Luke harming Vader with TP was from a non-canon story? Or was it vague?.....I can't remember but I recall that particular scan and something about not being canon. Though still Luke has this and later he has TP feats anyway, just recalling that bit is all.
Yes, it was me that stated it was vague. But the thing is the OP said All feats from books are usable, even the ones that are dubious.
I was under the impression that Marvel comics weren't considered canon unless directly referenced. S-canon level and all that, is there another classification?
I was under the impression that Marvel comics weren't considered canon unless directly referenced. S-canon level and all that, is there another classification?
The ones I posted are all confirmed to be canon except the one where Luke uses telepathy on Vader.
@dccomicsrule2011: @jedixman: Would you two users who I know and trust, or any other user that sees this consider this thread spite and lacking of discussion and therefore should be locked?
@dccomicsrule2011: @jedixman: Would you two users who I know and trust, or any other user that sees this consider this thread spite and lacking of discussion and therefore should be locked?
The problem I have is that it is a thread born in ignorance.
I don't think it is an outright stomp like most threads involving Luke usually are (which is not to say that this isn't onesided; it is). However, I don't think there can be much in the way of meaningful discussion. Especially since nobody has actually been able to reasonably defend Han / Chewie, and I don't foresee anybody being able to pull up any Han Solo feats that could turn the tide.
So yes, in light of that, it probably should be locked. I don't like to see Star Wars threads that don't encourage good discussion to proliferate around here; it sends a bad message about Star Wars fandom.
Log in to comment