LOTR vs Chronicles of Narnia

LORD OF THE RINGS VS CHRONICLES OF NARNIA .

ROUND 1 : Whose movies are better?

ROUND 2 : Whose books are better?

ROUND 3 : Which had better warfares?

Round 4 : Is any of these movies even close to as good as twilight?? O.o

Just kidding :P The fourth round was a joke :P

Whose characters would win in these fights :

Morals on .

Bloodlust off

Fight takes place in the HOT GATES .

Both movie and book versions .

1: Human Gandalf vs Aslan

2 : Human Gandalf vs the white witch .

3 : Frodo vs Edmund

4 : Legolas vs susan

5 : Boromir vs Prince Caspian

6 : Treebeard vs 2 minotaurs

7 : Edward Cullen vs Sauron

8 : The lorax vs Mr beaver

9 : Horton vs Edmund

R1. LOTR

R2. LOTR

R3. LOTR

1. Aslan doesn't have that many offensive feats though he basically is God in the series if that means anything. Gandalf should win.

2. Gandalf

3. Frodo

4. Legolas in a decent fight, unless its h2h where she dies. Susan was actually a sweet shot in the movies.

5. Boromir stomps

6. Treebeard breaks their backs without effort

7. Okay that's spite and you know it

8. WTF

9. WTF

1.LOTR was better movie all over.better story,better charaters and almost every thing was better
2.never read any books so IDK
3.this a tough one.very very tough but i am siding with LOTR as the fight were really awesome(legolas taking down that giant mammoth or gandalf taking out the balrog or the fight scene in hobbit 2 or when oh i could carry on for a long time)
4.both were better than twilight

fight

1.if this was in narnian forest than aslan would have rather stomped without any difficulty but now in hot gates i give it to gandalf
2.white witch
3.edmund murderstomps frodo without any problems
4.legolas better archer better fighter.
5.aragorn vs prince would have been better.that being said prince caspian
6.treebeard
7.what???
8.WTF
9.WTF

I agree completely.

I enjoyed the chronicles of Narnia more when I read them, but the LOTR films are faaaaaar better.

1: Human Gandalf vs Aslan

2 : Human Gandalf vs the white witch - Gandalf doesn't have a feat like plunging an entire country into winter and transumting organisms and if Jadis is in Charn she would curb him. Assuming win means ending Gandalf's physical form only, she can't do anything permanent to him.

3 : Frodo vs Edmund - Edmund, should've made it Sam.

4 : Legolas vs susan - Legolas curbs.

5 : Boromir vs Prince Caspian - Boromir curbs.

1: Aslan - And this isn't even close.

2 : Human Gandalf wins only because of the fight location. Jadis (white witch) was almost powerless on earth.

3 : Edmund dominates unless Frodo did something crazy in the books i don't remember.

4 : Legolas in a blowout

5 : Boromir in a blowout

Narnia..... wins the Majority....

Fanboy: "Gandalf wins because he's an angel!"

Me: "Go look up what Aslan can do. Then tell me who wins."

Fanboy: "THE HECK!!!??"

Me: "Oh is it me? or did someone realized that Aslan has created Narnia (Also known as another planet) by himself with his own power?"

I'll be fair. I like the books and movies of Lord of the Rings better overall than Narnia, though Narnia does have some cool and awesome stories.

LOTR

LOTR

LOTR

Aslan has 0 offensive feats although his hax is pretty good, regeneration+world creation+ teleportation. Actually I think he maybe able to eat Gandalf with his teleportation lmao

WW has the deplorable word idk what Gandalf can do to that

Edmund stomps hes had years of training Frodo is as non violent as they got( I'm talking about movie interpretation since I haven't completed the LOTR books)

Legolas probably

Boromir

What feats did the minotaurs have again?

Edward seduces sauron and steals the one ring

----

----

ROUND 1 : Whose movies are better? LOTR

ROUND 2 : Whose books are better? LOTR

ROUND 3 : Which had better warfares? LOTR by far

1: Human Gandalf vs Aslan

2 : Human Gandalf vs the white witch .

3 : Frodo vs Edmund

4 : Legolas vs susan

5 : Boromir vs Prince Caspian

7 : EdwardCullenvs Sauron (?? wtf)