So much to say, so little time...
First off, can we please stop bashing the CG Clone Wars show? Everyone keeps saying it "stomps on continuity" or "ruins continuity" but I still haven't been given one shred of evidence to support such claims. Whenever I ask for evidence, all I get is something along the lines of "Ahsoka sucks". That doesn't cut it. Ahsoka's inclusion does not "spit on continuity" with the exception that how Anakin got her as a padawan is admittedly ridiculous. But her inclusion in the SW canon does nothing to ruin continuity. So what if she wasn't mentioned in anything before the CG Clone Wars show? A character introduced in 2008 is not going to be in something that came out in 2007 or earlier. Just like how all of the important Prequel-Era Jedi (along with other important characters from the Prequel Era) didn't ever show up or be mentioned in anything in SW that came out pre-1999 because they didn't exist yet. That is an invalid argument. That her inclusion ruins Anakin's relationship with Obi-Wan is also rubbish to me. Anakin and Obi-Wan are still a pair and a duo and their eventual fight against one another still tragic. The only thing that has changed is that Anakin now has an apprentice of his own and thus another person in his life. Big deal. I'm no big fan of Ahsoka, but I don't believe she "spits on continuity".
@ShootingNova: And no, the CG Clone Wars show does not "ruin continuity", nor is it filled with any kind of PIS, CIS, or "WIS" (whatever the last one means). So Sidious is fighting Maul and Savage. So what? He fought Mace evenly even though he's better than Mace. There is an explanation for that. Who's to say there isn't one for Maul and Savage. Perhaps Maul is being amped too. Or perhaps Sidious was toying with them. It certainly looked that way. So no, that's not PIS or CIS either. And considering that the episode featuring that fight hasn't even aired yet I don't think we should be saying anything about that because we don't know the context behind it. There could be unique circumstances, same for Palpatine's fight against Mace Windu or Anakin beating Dooku when Mace never did even though Mace>Anakin. In all of the episodes I have seen I have not seen any PIS, CIS, or "WIS" of any kind. Nothing. The only retcons to pre-existing continuity that I have seen are Adi Gallia and Even Piell's earlier deaths. And those earlier deaths do not render the entirety of the stories containing their original deaths non-canon. So no, until given some actual substantial evidence that I can buy, I maintain my belief that the CG Clone Wars show does not "ruin continuity".
But despite me saying all of this, I also know that I won't be changing anyone's minds. So how about we all not waste time debating this and agree to disagree? Especially considering that none of this has any relevance to the fight I posted whatsoever. And as such I will not be responding to any response I get to this. Just putting in my two cents. No more no less.
@ShootingNova said:
It kind of already seems like Palpatine was toying with them. And if it did turn out he was toying with them..... what would you say? And what if it turned out to be the other way around? If Maul and Savage somehow obtained "the blessing of the Force" and won....... LOL. I sincerely hope that the latter never comes true.
Also.... on a side note, when you haven't clicked on the video and it shows Palpatine with one saber ignited and about to ignite the other...... it somehow looks very much like Kreia.........
They're not going to. Do you really think if Maul would let his old master live if by some miracle he won? Trust me: Sidious ain't losing this fight. I see it as being like Mace Vs. Sidious, where Maul gets a big amp that allows him to hold his own but ultimately not be able to win.
And yeah, I see that similarity too. In fairness though, I've always considered Kreia to be a female Palpatine. So it is a fitting comparison.
Man I am dying to see that episode. I'll be rooting for Maul and Savage even though I know they'll lose.
Regarding the fight itself, I'd say Mara wins, since doing well against Darth Caedus is better than doing well against Anakin and Obi-Wan and also losing to Obi-Wan at one point. But I do think its a somewhat close lightsaber duel. Who is superior Force-wise? I know Ventress has some pretty good TK feats. Does Mara have any Force feats of note?
Log in to comment